Mag1cman

And the thought here on Whiteflame is also possible opportunism on Thoth last DP and that he left after voting, and reappeared right at the same time Pie did at the end, which I wonder if it could be pairing, like one said to other "hey lets go post confusion for town cred since the thread isn't closed yet." His alibi is a lot better than Pie's imo but it's still weird timing, especially since they reappeared at the same time.


As for this DP, a little fencesitty imo.

Mag1cman

And yeah mutual claim or bust, I was going to include Lunatic but I'll leave it for now because as I was typing it out, I realize the case isn't as strong as I thought. I might still go for him later anyway but for now I'll at least consider the idea that Whiteflame could be ahead of him on my sus list.


The case against Lunatic:


  1. At the start of DP1, he did nothing but post fluff, no analysis or commentary, absolutely nothing outside of his argument with Thoth, then disappeared. At this time, some people were inactive, so remember that scum had an incentive to hide like this.
  2. When he reappears, he drops this:
I don't have a lot of reads so far, its been kind of an inactive day phase. Mharman feels good, no red flags from pie yet, whiteflame is just inactive. Wylted seems okay, thoth I can't take seriously because of his wylted hate campaign, Banana feels very afk other than a few odd posts, but ive been inactive too, Rex hasn't said a ton, mago doesn't really stand out, yeah kind of a bad dp1 so far


These are nothingburger reads. Really not impressive at all.


3 The push on me out of the gate this DP. Opportunism like Pie.


There is one counterpoint I can think of and it's that he wasn't on the Thoth wagon.


I still lean scum on him but my confidence has dropped just a bit.

Mag1cman
Again, at the end of the day, you have no way around the fact that I could've re-entered the thread, been all like "yup Thoth isn't in my town pile anymore and it's low time so let's just hammer right here," but I didn't.

And again, this would've been BEFORE Thoth entered the thread to claim. So his Link claim isn't even relevant for how you look at me here.

Mag1cman
As for the reasons Mag1c has given to sus Pie, the not being there at EoD is the weakest. I went back and checked and, yes, that's what Pie said would happen ahead of the game. A lot of the rest of this looks like Mag1c's frustration in response to tunneling (fair, I've been there) and the shift to focusing on him after the events of the last DP. I get why those would be frustrating, but I can't say the continued pursuit of his read or the decision to push Mag1c this DP comes off as scummy. It's not unusual for Pie to pursue someone like this as scum or town.

That's such bullshit. His logic is soooooo bad.

Mag1cman
But people aren’t going to vote a person who claimed the main character, are they? You know this as well as anyone. Multiple people have stated they would’ve unvoted.

This isn't relevant if I can just vote before he claims. And I could have. He was out of my town pile before I re-entered the thread.


Again, as scum lynching the bigger fish is always desirable. Your hand was forced the second Thoth came on and claimed Link.


You think you and Lunatic were bigger fish? holy ego batman. No. Scum tries to survive and will take what mislynches they can get. That includes Thoth. There's a reason he is one of the most frequently mislynched players, and it's because scum teams know they can get easier pushes on him. This game is just another example.


You hammered Thoth as scum because he claimed Link, who is a main character. It’s really that simple. You couldn’t use time because he had just claimed the main character. Voting for that as scum is suicide.

Lol you have no real argument here so you're appealing to "it's really that simple." Again, at the end of the day, you have no way around the fact that I could've re-entered the thread, been all like "yup Thoth isn't in my town pile anymore and it's low time so let's just hammer right here," but I didn't. It's really that simple :)

I said it was “alarm bells.” I never stated I thought you were scum.

Wink wink nudge nudge. Cmon Pie we can put two and two together. That is a scumread you moron.


Lmfao. So you admitted to being a moron in Paper Mario. And are claiming to be a moron here, but Pie is somehow the moron. Nice lol


I made an obvious honest mistake here, and you failing to recognize that would make you an even greater fool. Listen I know your brain's tiny like your wiener but this aint rocket science. My ADHD-induced mistakes are nowhere near the level of the retardation of ignoring precedent and incentives, be real here. This logic is cucked and you know it.


Uh yes? She was getting ready cause we were gonna go get ice cream.

How convenient.

Mag1cman
I null read 3 people. Mharman, REF, and Thoth. I picked a person from those 3. Nothing more to it.

you’re contradicting yourself. You were straight up sussing me. I wasn’t a null.


This is just wrong. If you are town, you have yourself to blame, just like Paper Mario Mafia. You claiming will help me determine whether you are truly scum or a moron.

And then why can’t it be the same here? If I can be town there I can be town here. You know this. All of you see what was an obvious honest mistake. And you’re falling for it. And Pie ur a fucking dipshit for even thinking this case is any good. If I’m a moron you’re the moron supreme.


I already said in signups I was going to be with the girl until Sunday afternoon. I checked in when I could. Nice try though.

really, and you suddenly stopped being with the girl when it was time for you to enter thread and express your “confusion?”


Technically possible but the timing still isn’t good. Good effort, but no dice

Mag1cman
You were peddling a Pie and Luna lynch because you townread Thoth. And you’re saying if you had just hammered based on time, it would’ve been fine?

You had to do this. Otherwise people would’ve questioned why you were hammering a person you townread lol


yes it would’ve been fine. It’s common people will vote someone they townread on low time just to have a lynch, especially DP1.


and I don’t even need to go for any lynch on you or Lunatic as scum, nor do I even need to say I townread Thoth.


Anyone can check the thread. Before I re-entered the thread on low time, I was questioning Thoth and had moved him out of my town block. Upon re-entering the thread, instead of appealing to low time and hammering Thoth, I observed the situation, moved him back into my town pile, and then started pushing for lynches on Pie and Lunatic, only hammering Thoth in my own confusion about my PM after he claimed.



Mag1cman

What specifically did I fool you with in those games you are referencing.


and I’ve laid out my case in Pie several times already.


  1. opportunism. Pursues Thoth over me when I’m townread and others are sussing Thoth. Only pursues me after the mistake from last DP, when he hopes the perception of me would’ve changed.
  2. bad arguments. His bad logic, bad faith, and outright dishonest arguments/ignoring my real points has been well documented. When Pie’s logic starts to slip, it’s a scumtell. Casey did a good job of noting this in past games.
  3. not being there for EoD, but then randomly showing up just after Thoth was hammered
Mag1cman
“No scum incentive” to hammer the guy that claimed Link?


Again, take note of how Pie repeatedly ignores the point.


I’m NOT saying scum has no incentive to hammer Link, I AM saying scum has no incentive to do such weird CC shit, WHEN they had an easy alternative to simply appeal to low time and hammer off that, BEFORE Thoth could even claim. INSTEAD, I pinged him so he could claim.

Mag1cman

Im getting pissed excuse I should be widely townread at this point for what was an obvious mistake that matches no scum incentive, and yet, people are somehow buying even a small percent of Pie’s arguments.

Mag1cman

lol ok bitch boy


objective fact is you’ve been misinterpreting everything I’ve been doing intentionally with the worse bad faith sleight of hand arguments. You pushed Thoth when some people were against him, and now you’re pushing me when you think people will be against me.


WIFOM WIFOM WIFOM. But what about the possibility of mag1c’s WIFOM guys!


This really is Paper Mario Mafia all over again. As unfortunate as my tracker/watcher mix-up from that game was, Lunatic’s arguments about how I could just be WIFOMing were proven wrong.


WIFOM appeal is a crutch when you want to ignore incentives.


You know the incentives don’t match. Scum could easily appealed to low time and vote long before Thoth re-entered the thread to claim.



Mag1cman

Fuck no.


youre letting Pie convince you. Stop letting him convince you just because he’s bold. Have a logical backbone


and yall are just ignoring my responses. wtf is wrong with you people

Mag1cman
Exactly. And he claims he made the same mistake before. If anything that’s even worse. Help me pursue a full claim from him


How does that make things worse?


maybe it’s just that sometimes I don’t pay as much attention while reading as I should. Remember that I was town in Paper Mario.


and again, if you think you’re Link, you’re going to vote that, not Unvote. Notice the sleight of hand tactic from Pie: He appeals to what people would’ve done in his shoes, but in not in the shoes of someone who thought their PM said they were Link.


this isn’t honest argumentation.

lets get his claim

Mag1cman

lol. I know you trying to use hard on everyone, trying to push them all to go after me, but the only reason I claimed male was because I thought I was Link.


I “lied” about my character’s gender the same way I “lied” about being Link- just by misreading my PM.


Me claiming male is exactly what one would expect if I misread my PM and thought I was Link. This isn’t rocket science.

Mag1cman

Pie can lolcat all he wants, but it doesn’t add to his case. It’s just bad faith interpretation + overdramatic laughter. That’s his whole “case.” It’s pretty empty in substance.

Mag1cman
The long and short of it is that I didn't. I told Mikal I could do some night in the future. Mikal hopped on and asked if I wanted to do the recording, said there were a bunch of other people who were similarly doing their videos. Schedule's been mostly full, so I took him up on it after posting a vote and my remaining thoughts on Thoth at the time. 


alr.

Mag1cman

I won’t deny I made a dumb mistake but it’s not unfeasible that someone misreads his PM on a skim and then claims from memory instead of double checking. Especially when you have a case study on record of him doing it in a previous game (Paper Mario Mafia).


Mag1cman
He was in my null pile. I would’ve unvoted him if I had been on. But I was busy doing other things with the girl. And I explained why I “shaded” you. You were in my POE as well.

if I’m sussed you go for me, not the guy some other people want dead.


its real simple- too many people expressed townreads in me last DP, so you went for a null. Now that last DP’s goof is in everyone’s head, you think you have a chance at it