Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Yeah it’s weird but egos explanation makes sense.


I still don’t care for Rex but I’m not that bothered by that

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I don’t doubt he has the role. It’s like Banana’s popular claim, people are gonna test it.


The issue here is that scum can, in fact, be ascetic.

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Oh lol


at any rate he’s still done almost nothing.


I guess I’ll put him lower than Wylted. Especially since Shining’s actually my top scumread.

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

As for Banana, I’ve decided she’s in the town pile with Kohai.


Whiteflame and Pie are more null. I don’t like how Pie entered the thread not even reading all of what happened. He is getting on Shining ass and looking for a claim just to clarify him; I’ve seen him do that as town plenty. I think Whiteflame looks slightly better on his thoughts though. Especially on Wylted.


Wylted I actually feel slightly worse on. I don’t hate a claim from him but there’s still a few things giving me pause. And yes he has a slight point on optimal popular play but I don’t see how 7-2 is unbalanced; his initial reasoning on popular was still bad. But he doesn’t fully fit his scum profile either. The softing weirdness, I’m not sure what to think.

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Honestly I don’t care for either Rex or Shining. Shining’s lazy like usual but post 30 is weird to me. The thought process is literally just that is probably not Kohai by the numbers… which just ignores past setups. Also opens the door to arguments for any guilty result being the hidden miller.


Rex had kinda done nothing aside from test Banana and vote Shining and didn’t explain a thing himself. Asking Kohai if he was the cop was weird. “Look guys! Mafia totally wouldn’t dare ask someone if they were cop, right?”


I actually wouldn’t mind claims from both.


VTL Shining

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

about 30 hours in the DP. I’m fine with getting a claim from Shining


VTL Shining

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Can one of yall see if Banana has ever played in a past game where someone was a popular. I’m curious

sure

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Wylted’s actually got a small point. Not with his initial reasoning that Banana could’ve saved her role for LYLO, but in that generating behavior around discussion of you makes sense.


Another fact is that because mafia knows you’re popular, that’s one person that they know isn’t a more important PR.


That being said, does Banana know this? She’s gotten quite a few games under her belt now but there’s still quite a few things she probably doesn’t know.


I do know that she tends to be more combative as scum. Her guessing that Wylted is reaction baiting is actually quite towny in my book. Comes from the mind of someone who doesn’t even see how anyone could scumread them. Tends to be a towny bias, especially when they think they have something that should make them widely townread.

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I'm not going to stay on late tonight, trying to get some sleep early. That being said, I don't like the fact that Wylted caught back up and didn't have anything to say about softclaiming at all. With Pie, it's just that he's busy, but I don't get Wylted suddenly posting a vote on Banana and having little else to say.

Town Wylted does try to game solve quickly but normally he's hyperactive and also finds town slots. When scum, he takes his usual fluff a bit further than normal, does some excessive mech talk, and then disappears. He's not completely fitting the profile of either here.


The logic behind the push is pretty bad.

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

im pretty sure ur tryin to get a reaction out of me because your supposed to claim popular dp1 also if i was mafia u'd have to beleve that i just risked being the first to claim and not being countered which is a bit crazy

No maifioso is going to claim popular unless they actually have because it can be tested. They're never worried about being CC'd in that case.

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

VTL banana
No point in claiming popular off the rip and losing an advantage at lylo in teasing out a quick hammer


Just asked Lunatic about this. He attaches mylo/lylo clauses to populars, so the quick hammer play isn't relevant.


Banana's still null. We have no behavior to go off, and the role isn't towny or scummy.

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Null on everyone but Kohai btw. In particular, everything Whiteflame has done is NAI in my book. Literally everything I can see as legit or faked.


Almost scumread Thoth's intro before I realized he wasn't in this game