Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

The only thing that's holding me back from making the same conclusion is that "role hint" Luna mentioned in the OP. That could mean scum were informed that there is a certain role, or at least a certain type of role, is in the game.

I thought about this, but I don’t see why scum would be warned or informed of a cop. Usually they’re just given counters and then they know.


Alternatively, scum could just have a GF/Lawyer/Framer, so they would know that there's an alignment investigative role.

Thought about this as well, but then scum has to ask if the informed claim could be CC’d by a non-hidden miller.


I still don't think Kohai does this regardless, since it doesn't give him or his partner much in the way of cover if he is scum (someone getting a "guilty" is still likely to result in a lynch), so the strategy doesn't make sense from his perspective. He's more likely town than not.

yeah

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

There is an outside chance Lunatic switched things up. I don’t think it’s likely.

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Yeah I don’t think Kohai is gambiting. Was thinking on it but there’s just too much that can go wrong, plus his bold claim from last game was in a desperate situation. If there’s no informed, scum Kohai would still be screwed if there’s no cop


He’s town.

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Both times when I had Whiteflame do this in his setups, the hidden negative utility was the person informed about it. I may have done this in one of my own games, idr.


More likely than not it’s you

Mag1cman

Ted Lasso Mafia

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I guess I’ll put some cards on the table to get something moving. I won’t full claim but I have some information about tbe game namely there is a hidden miller in this setup


Interesting.

Mag1cman

Innocent child and Soldier play pretty much the same role in the setup; that’s my one critique.


pretty good setup overall

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

or more accurately, it's a bad look one way, and not necessarily a good look the other way

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

possibly


but he has to bus in that situation


honestly it's just a bad look for him either way

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

yeah just go ahead and hammer if you've seen his defense


I think you do want to hammer soon but you're trying to be courteous about it


thanks, no need


unless you actually want something more from him


your choice

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

idk man. scum did not play this well at all, I would not be shocked if Magoroth claimed his real character. Heck since we think scum played poorly, now the door is opened to wasting all questions just to find out motion detector is available.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

If Magoorth joined my Rex wagon Kohai was probably gonna be forced to claim anyway, unless he outright refused and said we'd all get it tomorrow. Don't think that would have worked and it seems the plan was not for him to refuse to claim.


I wouldn't say claiming cop is a plan but it is a hail mary that could've been done with a tailor in the game.


just refusing to claim was maybe the better hail mary. Maybe he gambled that the cop was offline? refusing when town wants to just lynch someone is hard. not claiming may actually be worse then


not sure, both are bad


either way looking for literally anything else to claim would've been better. So either way a mistake was made.


Just doesn't clear Magoroth here.


Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Whiteflame had a clearing idea on Shining last DP.


I don't think it's accurate. There's a chance Shining used all of his questions to find Trump.


It's actually common for Pie to leave a major character out of his games so scum can fake claim it


not gonna move my vote just yet but this is worth noting

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Pie doesn't strike me as a three investigators type of guy,

Motion Detector has a lot more conflict with Wylted's JOAT than a Dreamer would. Basically the same role, his is just weaker.

Mag1cman

MAGA Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

like he can talk about his vote on Kohai, but looking at the situation, scum is basically forced to bus. so now what