Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Lemme ask you this. Do you think the following thought process is natural? Why or why not?


  1. Magoroth outed his character in his opening, while babbling about the pros and cons of him outing his character.
  2. Magoroth claimed an investigative. By contrast, Pie was very secretive about his character, even refusing to soft for some time.
  3. Given 1 and 2, Magaorth’s claim timing makes him suspect; it goes against the incentives of a townie questioning the dangers of an early character claim, and an investigative, who normally wants to be secretive about his character.
  4. Magoroth is scum.
  5. Since Magoroth is scum, his sensor claim must be fake.
  6. Vader usually has two investigatives in a 9 player game.
  7. Given 4, 5, and 6, it is reasonable to conclude there is another investigative somewhere who has not claimed.
  8. Wryly went out of her way to argue there could be three investigatives.
  9. Wryly asked Magoroth if he was a dreamer, indicating she visited him.
  10. Given 7, 8, and 9, Wryly is most likely to be the investigative who hasn’t claimed.


Because this was my thought process. To restate: I scumread Magoroth, but the lack of another investigative somewhere was a challenge to my read. So I looked for someone who could be an investigative to amend this problem with my scumread of him.


I would not have called Wryly being cop, if it weren’t for my scumread of Magoroth.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Lemme ask you this. Do you think the following thought process is natural? Why or why not?


  1. Magoroth outed his character in his opening, while babbling about the pros and cons of him outing his character.
  2. Magoroth claimed an investigate. By contrast, Pie was very secretive about his character, even refusing to soft for some time.
  3. Given 1 and 2, Magaorth’s claim timing makes him suspect; it goes against the incentives of a town question the dangers of an early character claim, and an investigative.
  4. Magoroth is scum.
  5. Since Magoroth is scum, his sensor claim must be fake.
  6. Vader usually has two investigatives in a 9 player game.
  7. Given 4, 5, and 6, it is reasonable to conclude there is another investigative somewhere who has not claimed.
  8. Wryly went out of her way to argue there could be three investigatives.
  9. Wryly asked Magoroth if he was a dreamer, indicating she visited him.
  10. Given 7, 8, and 9, Wryly is most likely to be the investigative who hasn’t claimed.


This wasn’t thought process. To restate: I scumread Magoroth, but the lack of another investigative somewhere was a challenge to my read. So I looked for someone who could be an investigative to amend this problem for my scumread of him.


I would not have called Wryly being cop, if it weren’t for scumread of Magoroth.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Scum has a tailor and a ninja. Why use rolecop? I think the former two are much better roles.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Assuming that Tailor shows scum the role card of the person they tailored.
I asked Vader and he said he could not answer that.
Scumslip?


No, it’s common for trailers to reveal to scum their role of the townie they just killed on here. It’s reasonable to assume such a feature of this game’s tailor.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

And if he were town roleblocker (assuming Shining used tailor on him), it would be a scummy claim, yes. But is that not better than giving up?

On tailor:


It might just be this in combination with Rex not wanting to play anymore.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Why is that?


Because tailor is great for stealing town roles to claim. Yeah it can be used to characters, but roles are more important.


So it makes sense that given how good tailor is for getting roles, characters would be provided.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

like he deployed this complicated battalion of arguments in hopes you won't notice the gaps that he should know better than to make.


I literally made concessions where there were to gaps for the sake of honesty


are you kidding me

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

🤦‍♂️


ah yes. Let me bring little miss “MOTHERFUCKER YES MAG1C SCUM” into the next DP, and out my whole plan while doing it. This scum play won’t totally backfire. It’s totally not too risky.


again, it’s not just that I have to be a few specific roles, it’s that o have to be doing the most retarded gambit possible, while outing it


this is stupid

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Correct, though if a Framer/Lawyer/GF can manipulate the Sensor's results, then it's possible for scum to be among Thoth and Wryly. I have behavioral reasons that they're implausible as well, but there would have to be some mechanical hijinks going on to place both scum in the same pool of Sensor results.

Thoth and Wryly cannot be godfather for the same reason I can't be godfather, see my case again.


Framer is no-go because then he'd get two scum on the wagon, not one. You need framer plus godfather on the same slot somehwere, and that's very unlikely.


Lawyer I didn't consider when steelmanning against my case. I didn't think lawyer could self-target. I asked Vader, and annoyingly, a lawyer can self-target. So I guess you (kind of?) have that. That's not what I do when I host, but whatever (I hate self-targeting).


But here's the thing: If I am a lawyer, I can't have used it on myself NP1, because of Magoroth's results. So there's another assumption you have to make.


I don't think any scum case against me withstands Occam's Razor. REMEMBER: It's not just the fact that I need to have one of a small handful of specific roles, it's that I also need to be doing a crazy gambit with Wryly on top of that... when it's far better for scum me to kill her NP2.


It's a valid argument that he can't be the GF, but that's about it. The disclaimer is basically just an extended point explaining why we shouldn't see alternatives as plausible because he wouldn't talk at length about the possibility of other roles being in the mix and wouldn't have kept you alive, which just aren't convincing reasons to dismiss his potentially being scum. Would hardly be a first for scum to talk about their actual role as a hypothetical, nor to leave an investigative alive with intent to use their result.

If you think it's a 50/50 or even so much as a 70/30 that I just outed my whole plan, the point of doing it would be defeated.


And the point of the disclaimer isn't just that I wouldn't be talking about it, it's to say that you need quite a few things to align for me to be scum.. The roles, the gambit with Wryly, the gambit of outing such a gambit, and anything that needs to align with any of the specific roles you think I could be.


Most of this I get, it's part of the reason I've been townreading Magoroth for so long. The one caveat is the bid for the Dayvig. I wouldn't be surprised if scum saw through that ruse early and therefore didn't see a risk in it.

Very possible.

Are you guys listening to this shit?

-Shining, Post #298 DP2. Thoth is known for being weird. I think it's the type of thing only scum would see through.



Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Very interesting play here from Mag1c, considering he was the only one who did not VTL Shining last game aside from Thoth, who is mechanically innocent.

Mag1c is also the only player Shining did not FOS. The two players Mag1c is now accusing were ones Shining opposed, particularly so Magoroth. Take a look at #96, #224, #284, #288, #291. In contrast, Shining largely supported Mag1c's arguments.

Mag1c's behavior toward Shining was also imo consistent with a mafioso whose scummate is in jeopardy of being lynched. He ran interference and tried to keep the field of suspicion as wide as possible by saying "there are no unpairings anymore", stalled on voting by doing a lot of research on people, pretended to sus Shining for this and that only to dismiss his conjecture, said oh yes definitely Shining was a bit sus but he would prefer to lynch Magoroth, etc.


Stalling on a lynch because I wanted to do something before the end of the DP got me sussed in Game Shows Mafia. I was town there too.


#885 - SL - Waiting to hammer on scum while claiming he might is suspicious. And since WyIted wanted to post notes, it’s possible they decided that notes from Mharman would look less suspect.

-Savant, Post #33 of DP2, Game Shows Mafia. This ended up snowballing into a mislynch of me on the final day phase.


As for Shining, a few posts where he agreed with me are nothing; I was very active and driving a lot of discussion throughout that DP. As for him townreading me, let's ask: Do you really expect scum to townread their teammate the whole game?


As a matter of fact, do you expect scum NOT to bus their teammate when they're going to be lynched? In this game, scum has an even greater incentive to bus a dying teammate, since Thoth was vocal about planning to use his governor... meaning that a teammate bussed for towncred could still be saved anyway. I really did feel more confident on Magoroth, and I stood on business.


And I'm not speculating a bus for no good reason. Game Shows Mafia DP4. I hard defend Banana, despite thinking her to be the second scummiest player in the game, because Mikal, the scummiest player in the game, was attacking her all game long. She gets lynched and flips scum. DP5. I let Mikal go at the very end, because I couldn't fathom the bus. I get mislynched; Mikal wins as scum. And that's just the main example in my mind.


I'm going to dismiss this. It was easy to guess I was the Cop, so I'm alive for a reason, and that reason is I had some utility to scum. My cop of Mag1c is instrumental to the argument he is making for his innocence, so he would definitely want me in DP3.

It was obvious that you were a cop to me. That cannot be established for everyone else. REMEMBER: I wouldn't have thought you were a cop had I townread Magoroth. I specifically searched for a third investigative (really a second one), because I really did not believe Magoroth's claim. The belief in a third investigative that you had would've been interesting, but alone it wouldn't have been enough for me to say you were investigative. For your obvious visit of him, I would have brushed it off as a protective visit; Whiteflame had not claimed at that time.


But the material point is that Mag1c can only be guilty if he's a Godfather, and according to Magoroth, there could not be a Godfather in his POE.

btw, I specifically wanted to hammer this point in because Magoroth spent a lot of time talking about a godfather last DP, at times accusing me of being the godfather. I took it as TMI.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

okay I suppose I should ask. if we Lynch Mag1cman today and he flips town are people going to Lynch me or are they going to Lynch Whiteflame
because it its me I’ll vote Whiteflame.

"Yo if I mislynch Mag1c would yall let me mislynch Whiteflame too?"


come on now


Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

the reason i got miller/hated confused is because miller is a common sop to claim, and I wasn't paying that much attention to kohai


scum me is going to pay a lot more attention to the setup, I promise

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

lol I can smell the desperation


all that saying my solve is true, even with the admittance in #56 is mostly scum outside of you, and you vote me

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Why would town be looking for investigatives? Because I think you're scum, but didn't think you could be scum if there were only two investigatives. So I looked for someone who could be that third investigative


and since we agree cop-tracker-sensor is busted, killing Wryly and pushing you is a lot simpler than all the wifom you'd have to assert I'd be doing. Plus I leave Kohai alive as a last ditch if I need it.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

the framer + godfather would have to be on the same slot, with the godfather being passive, if you want to assert anything outside of you and Whiteflame. Said framer would've had to have framed either me or Whiteflame on top of that.


face the music. You know I'm right but you don't want to concede that it's between you and Whiteflame.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

your own results indicate Wryly cannot be scum, so you can't reasonably assert she is lying about her cop. Especially since I just debunked the concept of her being a godfather.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

there was a chance you could've been doctor, but I was so convinced Magoroth was scum that I was convinced there just had to be another investigative lurking


happy to be validated


yes three investigatives is technically possible, but among Vader/SupaDudz's 8-10 player games, only two of them had three investigatves. Most had only two.


And since you want to ask why you're still alive, an alternative reason is the sheer confidence of which you declared me scum at the end of last DP.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP3

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

GAME SOLVED.


The scum between the two of you (Magoroth and Whiteflame) can concede to save us all time, btw.


POINT ONE: Thoth and Wryly are town confirmed. Magoroth is either lying about his results, or he is telling the truth. If he is lying, he is scum, and Thoth and Wryly are not. If he is telling the truth, Shining was the one scum from (Thoth, Shining, Wryly); therefore, Thoth and Wryly cannot be scum.


POINT TWO: I, Mag1c, am (almost, but realistically) town confirmed, for I cannot be a godfather (nor can Thoth or Wryly). If Magoroth is lying, he is scum, and I am not. If he is telling the truth, then I must be innocent- he said godfathers hinder his results (post #525 DP2). Since Wryly copped me innocent, I can only be mafia if I am a godfather. But then, Magoroth's results would've said 0 scum between (Kohai, Mag1c, Whiteflame). His results say there is 1, so in this case, Whiteflame would have to be the scum on Magoroth's sensor- not me.


DISCLAIMER:

Technically, I could be a redirector, and pulling some gambit where I redirected Wryly knowing she was cop and would investigate me. If you want to argue that, good luck. Because now I can only be *one specific role*, AND I decided to bring little miss "MOTHERFUCKER YES MAG1C IS SCUM" into the next DP with me. And before you go on about "muh wifom" keep in mind that *if* you accept I could be wifoming, I would have outed my own wifom just now and reduced it to a 50/50- a risk that even you should admit is quite stupid for mafia. That's not how I play these games as scum, past teammates can attest. And before you argue something else, the only reason I found this is by steelmanning against my own argument. So yeah, technically this is all possible, but it relies on the stars aligning for me to be doing one specific gambit with one specific role. Like I said, good luck arguing that.


BTW: For the same reason I cannot be a godfather, Thoth and Wryly also cannot be a godfather. So you can't argue that either.


POINT THREE: Either Whiteflame is scum, or Magoroth is scum.

Given 1 and 2, We are down to two remaining. Whiteflame does not have any innocent result. Magoroth, however, could be a godfather. Magoroth's results are not useful to clear him of being godfather like they were for me, because he could just be making them up. I am comfortable asserting he is one- a cop indicates the presence of a godfather, plus he was the first one this whole game to bring up a godfather- at times asserting it was me. Of course, if you trust Magoroth that much, Whiteflame is your lynch.


We have two DPs to lynch both of them, so this should be an auto win for town. You can go for either, but I'm going with Magoroth because I think he is behaviorally scum- more than Whiteflame for sure.


VTL Magoroth