And believe it or not, I am and have been considering you are town.
The thing I can’t get around is the way you just outed your character out of the blue. I especially don’t think it aligns with the incentives of an investigative.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
And believe it or not, I am and have been considering you are town.
The thing I can’t get around is the way you just outed your character out of the blue. I especially don’t think it aligns with the incentives of an investigative.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
i really do think he just wanted to give his fake character for town cred, and was just awkward about trying to justify it. And I also think there may be another investigative out there hiding, not wanting to claim. Which is fine I suppose.
this was from my scumread of Magoroth from yesterday
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Remember my theory that there was a cop, hiding somewhere, that didn’t want to claim?
Called it, and I knew it was you.
I figured it was you the second you spent so much time arguing there could be three investigatives. In addendum, you felt a lot of need to ask Magoroth if he were a dreamer.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Yeah
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
I double checked your questions with Vader.
Tailors can edit:
-flips of lynched townies, provided the flip hasn’t been revealed to town yet
-flips of townies that are about to die in the night (duh)
-roles
-characters
-justifications
Tailors cannot edit:
-affiliations
-flavors*
*he defines “flavor” as a prefix to role- like paranoid, weak, etc. idk why roles can be edited but modifiers can’t, but whatever
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Thoth and Wryly are town confirmed btw
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Bleeder can make sense with a bodyguard, yes. I don’t think they’re mutually exclusive. Not necessary to have both, but it can be done.
based on my setup philosophy anyway
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Dunno, Tracker makes a kind of sense with a Ninja.
ah. Duh
So we can safely rule out Pie’s flip being altered. Rex’s- not sure.
I asked why he just wouldn’t claim DP1- he said he had a reason and we’d see it upon his flip.
The only thing I can think of with Bleeder is that he wanted to refuse to claim so the mafia would think he’s a PR (pretty sure that’s what you were doing in Kohai’s game, right?) and get night killed. Then he’d survive as a bleeder with no one else having been killed- could be helpful to town for solving. Not sure exactly how, but maybe it could be.
But why submit to being lynched then? If he were a bleeder, surely he’d give it up. And if he wanted to keep with such a plan of baiting a night kill, claiming he’s a PR (or even outright fakeclaiming a specific one) would be better than just giving up and letting yourself be lynched, no?
And if he were town roleblocker (assuming Shining used tailor on him), it would be a scummy claim, yes. But is that not better than giving up?
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Provided the townie’s flip was not already revealed, yes
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Tailor can edit a lynched townie’s flip
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Claims:
Living:
Whiteflame - Cairo Santos’s blocked field goal - Bodyguard (protected Wryly both nights)
Wryly - Drafting Mitch Trubisky over Patrick Mahomes - ??
Magoroth - Cody Parkey’s Double Doink - Sensor
Thoth - Decision/Event - Governor
Mag1c - Choking against the 0-3 Broncos that just lost 70-20 to the Dolphins - Vanilla
Graveyard:
Rex - Aaron Rodger’s 2nd half comeback down 21 - Bleeder
Pie - BJ Raji’s Pick Six - Tracker
Kohai - Matt Eberflus’s Thanksgiving Clock Management - Hated
Shining (Mafia) - Zach Miller’s injury - JOAT (ninja, 1x tailor, role cop) (fake claimed Cobb’s 4th and 8 touchdown, Roleblocker)
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
I mostly agree with that; although a mafia tracker (stalker) isn’t unheard of.
I’m asking if tailor can edit a lynched townie’s flip.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
What was your character again?
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Claims list above.
remember that Pie’s flip (maybe Rex’s?) may have been altered
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Whiteflame - decision - ??
Wryly - Drafting Mitch Trubisky over Patrick Mahomes - ??
Magoroth - Cody Parkey’s Double Doink - Sensor
Thoth - Decision/Event - Governor
Mag1c - Choking against the 0-3 Dolphins that just lost 70-20 - Vanilla
Graveyard:
Rex - Aaron Rodger’s 2nd half comeback down 21 - Bleeder
Pie - BJ Raji’s Pick Six - Tracker
Kohai - Matt Eberflus’s Thanksgiving Clock Management - Hated
Shining (Mafia) - Zach Miller’s injury - JOAT (ninja, 1x tailor, role cop)
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Full claim please
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
The presence of a tailor means mafia were almost certainly given character claims btw
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Did shining claim role yesterday? Hold on.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
That’s not what you said when I told you ask Vader again.
scumslip
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Because he wants to be flexible.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
K
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
I don’t care what you vote me for.
I’m confident you’re scum.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
I’m keeping my vote where it is.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
lol ok bud
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
well I get scum giving up vibes from this
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
the insistence of a godfather is crazy. Like not even questioning it, despite that he was told his results are 100% accurate, apparently. Goes with my theory that there’s another investigative that doesn’t want to claim. And that Magoroth is faking the whole thing knowing there’s a godfather and therefore another investigative.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
I feel a little worse about Whiteflame after that post. I’ve seen the “cast my vote in 30 thing” before. Ace Attorney Mafia.
I’m a little shocked Shining isn’t defending his lynch harder. Like screaming how bs it is. Could he know it’s correct? But scum has an incentive to defend harder, no?
hmmmm
I still think Shining is a little worse than Whiteflame.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Kind of a beetlejuice there tho
Im thinking Shining-Magoroth with a bus/ distancing involved
hmmm
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
wait, Shining went to a VTNL while Thoth has claimed a vig that could shoot at twilight. (I think?)
Thoth was sussing Shining. would shining really go with a VTNL knowing Thoth could vig there?
I might be misinterpreting the situation but hold on
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
After looking it over, Shining is the second scummiest person, behind Magoroth. I think there could be a bus there.
But I still am more confident on Magoroth.
I’m voting there. If you guys overrule me, fair, but I think Magoroth is just worse. For reasons I’ve stated. And I think you should join me.
VTL Magoroth