Pinging on you 376 cause I wanted your input on something specific there
I may ping you for more
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Pinging on you 376 cause I wanted your input on something specific there
I may ping you for more
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
I have a had a light Sus on Shining all game long though
I no point have I townread him.
so there’s no sudden distance. It’s either all game long or not at all
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Bro I just posted before finishing my iso fml
im not even sure if I hard scumread Shining yet that’s just my thoughts on some early posts of his
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Shining ISO:
I am comfortable with buying Kohai's hated claim. I remember someone fakeclaiming Popular, but it takes a strong player to pull it off and while Kohai is good, I'd expect him to slip up eventually if scum.
None of this makes a point on whether hated is believable or not. Basically just “I don’t care whether or not he’s lying, we’ll catch him later if he is.”
Which isn’t completely invalid but I’d expect someone who’s town to say, “it’s a very risky claim that Idt scum would go for- unless it were given to them.” Y’know analyzing the incentives instead of just saying I trust it and then justifying it.
Did not even consider the idea of a fake role claim. I’ve been theorizing a fake character claim, and if that’s correct then scum could completely ignore the possibility of fake role claim.
I can't really fault you for REF. I did notice last game he sat back and was really quite passive. It was only during the final DP he got up and questioned my wagon. I think you were fairly obvious scum, but he also made your job a bit easier. With this game, hes also a bit passive. I don't have much to talk about him. I suppose he wants a Kohai lynch and hasn't really said why. I get why you say I'm scummy lol. He hasn't said much. Null for me.
I don’t have a problem with this.
Kohai is someone I will believe. Its not like a miller who might trouble town the entire game, with proper gameplay, Kohai might never get a single town vote on him the entire game. We don't need to immediately buy his claim, but should the need arrive, we have flips to check him on. Hes more than a lean town for me.
How does getting a few more flips make Kohai townier or scummier? Why wait to read him? Am I not understanding something about your stance on Kohai here? @Shining
Wryly(/Wylted) just popped in and I think it might be a mistake letting them pass by thinking about it now. Wryly just popped in, softed their character and basically has done nothing else. Its still early for Wryly, but I will keep an eye on them for now. Not their fault Wylted was inactive fwiw.
I felt this was bad logic- Wryly had only just popped in- give her time to do something useful before posting this! Again, just feels like a forced read.
I typed that before I saw Wryly's new posts. The new posts were pretty good. They are getting to a lean town for me
I will acknowledge and give credit to this, however
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Im going to take a step back and look at Thoth later
Shining read coming soon
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
The shitposting in this game gonna go crazy
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Forget too scummy to be scum
I might just go with too retarded to be scum
No offense Thoth but that was a crazy gambit
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Alr you guys can have this argument imma go look at Shining rq
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Question: This has been on my mind for bit but I got distracted thinking about Magoroth.
Does scum Thoth really spend all that time withholding his Whiteflame read on just a “trust me bro?”
Cause at the time I was growing a Sus on him from DP1 stuff but still townreading him because of it- even though I wanted him dead on policy
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
I just looked up governor and Thoth is able to stop a lynch in twilight
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
** VIG
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Dude I was gonna ask “wait, you can use your big intwilight?”
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Governor, so you can stop a lynch, correct?
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Bruh
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
We’re gonna have you trigger it before the day phase ends
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
*as in this day phase
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Today is in this day phase
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
I meant today not tonight
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
That works for me.
We’re not lynching anyone.
We’re just forcing Thoth to use his day vig, and we’re voting on his day vig target.
it’s like lynching but we confirm his role while doing it
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
No don’t VTNL yet we wait for Thoth to use his dayvig
sorry I may have confused you for a sec
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
we verify his role (and 99% townlock him) if we force him to use it tonight.
*today, not tonight
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
The Coup game was awesome btw
we could actually run it here
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
*lying and doesn’t have a vig
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
It’s the plan I just came up with
we verify his role (and 99% townlock him) if we force him to use it tonight.
we vote on who he uses it on, making that our lynch
then we VTNL because we just used Thoth’s in place our lynch
and if Thoth is lying and didn’t say big well know when we tell him to use it
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
interesting.
I don’t think it matters though. If he’s a day vig he’s going to use it today or get lynched.
So if he’s fake claimed it we’ll know when we tell him to use it
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Navy SEAL copypasta LMAO
Its been a while
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
We don’t have reason to doubt Thoth’s claim- we’re making him confirm it by using it instead of our lynch
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Gun to head is Magoroth but I want to look over a few more people first
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
You were dead set on three investigative role being plausible, but you had no examples in Vader’s games. So I checked his games.
Mag1cman · 10 months ago
Look for yourself please
im I’m busy with extended family
bought a card game called “Coup” at a consignment store and we’re gonna try it