Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I quickscrolled Whiteflame


small things I do and don’t like, he’s not my lynch today.


ill elaborate tomorrow if I’m alive by then

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

There is a possible tinfoil that she waits for something to happen then jumps on it. But it’s not my main thought when I look at her behavior

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I quickscrolled Wryly


So many small things telling me she’s town, the way she investigates things.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Because everyone has sussed everyone at some point.


But I’ll admit you’re correct about the ones revolving around “if Magoroth is telling the truth” those are mechanical.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

It’s 11. Reading Thoth took longer than I wanted. Gimme 30 mins to quick scroll Wryly and Whiteflame

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Doesn’t matter because you were analyzing the pros and cons of outing your character while you did it. You can talk all you want about how low risk your claim ended up being, but at the time it doesn’t appear you knew it was low risk.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

We’ve reached a stage of the game where everyone has sussed everyone, to varying degrees, at one point or another.


In my book there are no unpairings anymore.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

If Magic or Shining flipped town or scum, where would y’all be looking for scum based on the flip?

if Shining was lynched and flipped scum, it doesn’t change much for me.


I’ve seen many buses of different severities in my time. I’m still gonna go for who I think is individually scummy.


I got burned in game shows mafia, townread Banana mostly because Mikal was on her all game long. And I had felt they were the two individually scummiest in a vacuum. Not making that mistake again.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I don’t think a governor can stop their own lynch.


as for shining, I guess, but I still prefer Magoroth.


i don’t think an investigate outs his character so early. Especially since you can tell he was thinking about the pros and cons of doing it, while he did it.


i really do think he just wanted to give his fake character for town cred, and was just awkward about trying to justify it. And I also think there may be another investigative out there hiding, not wanting to claim. Which is fine I suppose.


The OMGUS, the malding, the character claim timing, the having a strong role while downplaying the frap out of it, suddenly joining wagons, and the over-friendly performance (:D:D:D:D:D) before the OMGUS all strike me as scummy. The fact that his claim is plausible (especially with no third investigative claim- 2 are most common in Vader games) is the only thing giving me some form of pause, but the behavior is just so scummy.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

> Be Thoth
> Suggest something we could soft-claim
> Expect people to discuss the merits of this soft-claim
> People just soft-claim


From Thoth. This was when he suggested we pick from softs. I remember townreading this post when I first read it. But I do feel little conflicted here, because this is a great way to fake contribute. I don’t know what he’d think is towny or scummy from the responses, but I can least buy the idea of him having something in mind for a towny or scummy response.


There's another soft I would like us to do, and this thought crossed my mind because I've never seen my role before. I think this one is good enough that it could be meta for future games.
According to the MafiaUniverse role database, is your role frequency Common, Occasionally, Rarely, or not in the list, at least not under that name?
My role is Occasionally. Again, I've never seen it before, but I haven't been around as long as some of you have, and roles may be more or less common in different sites' metas. I think this should make role fake-claiming much harder for scum while not giving them a dangerous amount of information.


This was pretty bad idea. One that I really don’t like. As Wryly said, those with common PRs would out that they have a major role that scum would nuke on the spot. This is where we have to ask a question: Is scum Thoth too afraid to post something like this?


I think Kohai is townlock. No way he just suggests that we lynch him as scum


>That also makes it a scummier claim because wagons won't build on him out of caution and it's only confirmable by lynching him.
Also agree


Two posts. Appears to be a bit of a pivot, but actually quite understandable given that Kohai seems down with his own lynch. But I don’t understand the logic of thinking it’s scummy claim in the first place. No mafioso is going to claim hates off the rip when they don’t know what else is in the game. In my mind, the only way Kohai can be scum is if hated was a provided fake claim.


My only real scumread so far is Mag1c and even that's not especially strong. I'm getting null vibes off of WF and Pie as always. Null on Rex too. Solid town on Wryly and Kohai, a bit less solid on Magoroth. Slight scum on Shining.
I don't like Pie's, "claim or your head on this pike", act, but from him that's NAI if not townie. Pie's initial "softclaim" was negative on the Mohs scale, even though he claimed event later. Typical hypiecrisy.

Is it towny or scummy that Thoth’s reads didn’t change much? I think both sides have an incentive to change reads as TJ game goes on; town, as they learn more. Mafia; to appear town and take advantage of situations that arise. I think the difference here is that town doesn’t have to change reads quite as much as mafia. So I’m gonna say this post is towny.


I found an instance of my role, with the same name but slightly different mechanics, within about ten minutes of Ctrl+F'ing through endgame threads on DebateArt, so maybe it's not as rare as I thought. That, or I'm just saying this in hopes scum will waste their time.
W I F O M
Did you know that, during World War II, the British put complicated-looking devices that did nothing on their airplanes so that, if the Axis downed a plane and recovered the device from the rubble, the Germans would waste time trying to figure out what it did?

I don’t know if he thinks he can manipulate scum somehow, but I don’t think giving an obvious hint as to what he’s doing helps. Could’ve reaction baiting, like how he wanted people to discuss softclaims.


At any rate, this does check out with governor. I’ve noticed this while doing archive work, but hosts here tend to call roles different things than what MU calls them. Governor, politician, magistrate (really just roles with names along that line) are all a source of confusion iirc.


im gonna end the ISO there and switch to memory.


The vig fake claim is completely insane if you’re scum. You’d know town would try and test you with on it. You’d at least run it by a teammate who’d veto it. I’m not shocked at the idea of whole claim being reaction baiting, because it seems like a lot of what I think he’s been doing.


Last thing: Thoth is weird. And as I’m remembering now, he has said his style is to do things so weird that no one could possibly think he’s scum. So unfortunately, too scummy to be scum isn’t actually that good. But then, is there a higher level, a level of craziness he still wouldn’t cross, even though that’s his strategy? Sigh. I think my big key here is that his reads haven’t changed all game long, and his refusal to out his read on Whiteflame for so much time.


was that a reaction test, too? And I don’t see a place where he’s found a reason to townread someone off a reaction test.


eh. I think his reads change a bit more to circumstances and opportunities if he’s scum.


There’s so much I hate about him, but imma go town for now.


as for his role, I’m not gonna tell him how to use it.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

you know what happens when people get stressed, right?


anyway I won’t take too long looking at everyone else. I plan to done by 11 cst/ noon est

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Oh and there’s a thread summary button at the bottom to help you find things

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

early on maybe. But iirc he was in the top half of people in plays counts by the end of that DP1


You can find it one MU. It’s in “manual games” and Kohai hosted it

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Also worth noting that the only person in the MU game who ultra combative with me like this was Awesome, and he was scum.


It’s actually funny because I was correctly scumreading Awesome, then listened to an argument from Wurzel (“what is Awesome’s plan with all this”), then started townreading him.


So I was reminded that game that scum doesn’t need a big brained plan to mislynch someone. They just need a plan to look towny and let town destroy each other.


Which is why I’m not buying Magoroth’s “what is my plan by discrediting my own results” BS. He doesn’t need to use his claimed results to push for someone; he just needs to have them and then put up a towny smokescreen. Gonna note here that by not having good results, he remains very flexible with who he can push.


Anyway I’m done playing with my food here. I’m probably gonna vote Magoroth but imma check everyone else one more time rq


Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

I accused you LONG before you accused me 😂 You literally made a defense of your OMGUS earlier


I just wanna say for the record that Magoroth was not like this at all during the MU game, even as he was about to be mislynched there

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

On evens, how to use your claimed day vig would’ve been more of a debate. It’s obvious on odds.


You lynch one person, then get info from night actions, instead of going for a second lynch and gambling the game in the spot. Assume mislynch to be prepared for the worst case, even if you’re confident in the lynch. If it works out it’ll be even better.


Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

"When Wylted shows up (if?) we may need to get a claim out of him."
A lot of Mag1cman’s early D1 stuff is very noncommittal. Doesn’t really want to be seen as pointing fingers, except at me, the popular LHF.

LOL are we fr?


I threw hard susses at Pie, Rex, and you. Two of them were proven false, but I was committal.


Meanwhile you joined those wagons out of nowhere.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

So I checked Vader’s games. This would be the first instance of a town roleblocker in his games, but town redirectors are actually quite common in his games.


So I think it’s plausible at least.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

So I checked Vader’s games. This would be the first instance of a town roleblocker in his games, but town redirectors are actually quite common in his games.


So I think it’s plausible at least.

Mag1cman

HCBM Mafia DP2

Mag1cman · 10 months ago

Nothing else specifically struck me as towny or scummy for the rest of DP1


Or at the start of DP2



Pretty odd claim. I really find it hard to accept his play this past DP. I think Mharman already pointed this out but it really was odd that hes bouncing back and forth how reliable his claim is. I can't believe Vader would say his role is 100% reliable and would also give the number of scum on the Rex lynch. His role is busted. Even without Pie, I don't know he expected mafia to win this. Hes lean scum for me

Yeah Magoroth has been weird about his role. As for the modpsych, I found exactly one game of Vader’s in the past where he has a sensor. I don’t hate the logic but it ends up being partially wrong. Still, no problems here.


THOTH
Thoth is also playing bizarrely. When he said hes confident WF is scum, he proceeds to afk for hours after numerous attempts to explain and only then gives a fairly contrived scumtell WF supposedly created. WF might actually be scum, but I really don't like how he tried to hide it. Thoth also explains that WF made the same tell as town, so how reliable is it even?

This frustration is understandable. 


Whiteflame has been afk all game. I remember him being more active and while he never really drove town like Pie does, he does help town when he can. Maybe hes busy from the holidays, but its frustrating because its making me scum read him, especially when Thoth and Magoroth are sussing him.


Eh. This read feels off- if Whiteflame helps town when he can there’s no reason to believe he isn’t doing that this game and is simply busy.


Mharman claim stands out to me because while I'll behavior read him as town, he claim as vanilla stand out because counting him, we had 3 vanilla like roles (Hated, bleeder and now vanilla). I could buy it, but its worth taking into consideration.

Feels hedgey. And I don’t see how a few low power roles are a conflict with vanilla.


I'm not gonna believe it til I see it. I'm the Roleblocker. My justification has a lot of football shit I don't understand, but the gist I got is that someone eliminated the Bears from playoffs and kicked them from NFC North. idk

there’s been a few town roleblockers recently so it’s plausible??? Not in any of Vader’s games that I saw, although I’ll have to double check. Justification makes sense cause I know what game he’s talking about. I would have expected a blocked field goal kick to be roleblocked though. Didn’t someone claim that? Feels genuine and towny the way he said it though.


Final thing: There’s a lot of posts I didn’t include here because they weren’t anything special individually; but, collectively they might mean something. Stuff like “you guys can figure that out” and “just narrow things down so we can move on.” Hard to explain, but they all vibe towny. And he’s made so many of them.


So the question is: Does the occasional bad logic and a theory about character fake claims trump all the posts he made that just sit well with me? Well, towny vibe posts can be faked, and towniest can have bad logic. But a few of these reads I think he should know better, and while fake role claims for mafia is possible, I see a lot pointing me in the direction of character claims, and a few of my thoughts on him.


So Shining kinda just stays where I had him last DP: Slightly scummy and floating around. But that’s not exactly a red ink sign telling me to lynch him. I think there’s better options.