Mestari
Plenty of others have suggested that my character has active incentive to work against the town wincon for my own personal benefit as SJW, so why is this so unlikely?

So this begs the question, do you have a reason to work against the town for your own independent goals?


Your logic is predicated on the mafia structure mirroring the town structure.

Mestari

Eh, a little more while I have a few short minutes.


DP1 341 could be a catch-up provided by scumchat.


Rex was early on the Thoth wagon, but still after I called out the slip.


It becomes harder to ask why the Kohai wagon didn't take off if he's town as I read on because between then and me catching Thoth's slip, almost nobody new joined in and posted, just Casey and Helz. It could be the case that it didn't take off because by the time mafia got involved, it was too late. That being said, both Alyssa and Thoth were around and neither jumped onto the Kohai wagon even though my wagon was clearly a meme wagon that would be easy to detach from.

Mestari

My current town pile is Pie, Wyrly, and Magic. Awesome I've said for a while has to lean town with how much sense their role makes structurally within the setup. I'm assuming all of these players are town in my reread.


Everyone else I'm working from ground up as null reads.

Mestari

DP1 140 is a weird post if coming from s!Kohai. How much does Kohai communicate with teammates in scum chat prior to engaging in day chat?


DP1 202


Vote Count




Mestari 3/9 - Alyssa, Mestari, Thoth


Mag1cman 2/9 - Casey_Risk, Rex


Kohai 3/9 - Mag1cman, ILikePie5, wylted


_____


Given that I believe magic is town because of the NP1 poison, I'm interested in why the Kohai wagon didn't take off here if they are town.


Active players after this point include myself, Lunatic, Wyrly, Whiteflame, and Thoth. Whiteflame not helping get the Kohai wagon rolling looks town if Kohai is town, because it would be an easy push for scum, or looks scum if Kohai is scum.


I have a lot more rereading to do but I have to get ready for work.

Mestari
Yes


Was there any discussion in guild chat about the Mod Narrative event that led to Wylted's death prior to Wylted challenging the king and dying?

Mestari

The thing about the lone wolf argument is that I was still the one who caught a legitimate scum slip leading to the lynching of two mafia members. Even if I'm a lone wolf who doesn't know who his partners are, I still have reason not to point out a very real slip that I have reason to believe will lead to actual lynchings of actual mafia.


Further, the rest of the Mafia typically knows who the lone wolf is, so I still wouldn't be described as a fear kill target.

Mestari

#48


I'm about to move houses (again). I'm going to try to skim through some isos before work and start fresh on my reads. There are a few details in particular I want to look at pertaining to the order certain things happened.

Mestari
ehhh...


It's literally on of his abilities from the show. Kinda a signature one at that. I just forgot about it because he ends up with so many other powers.

Mestari

How are we saying that the only explanation for no NK is the JK then not acting on it?


Also, is it crazy to suppose that mafia could have mechanically submitted their actions incorrectly? Bus driver is notoriously complicated. Could it be that they drove Pie with someone then NK the wrong end of the bus and ended up hitting into the doctor protection?