SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Again, I'm fine with banning child labor and even using the government to coerce companies for the greater good. There are cases where exploitation is bad. If we're both in favor of mixed economies, then I'm not sure we have a material disagreement, I'm just saying exploitation is not inherently bad.


Again, what is good or bad depends on comparison. Saying exploitation is better than nothing is not saying exploitation is good, when better systems can be made which reduce exploitation and improve life quality more. Mixed systems are so far the only functional systems, and debate is more about which is correct mix than choosing between exploitation or nothing.

SatanLucy

After reading a bunch of heated exchanges on Tik Tok regarding the age of consent, I realized those arguing to raise age of consent are actually winning argument after argument.


And then I thought about it, why should age of consent be 18?


As far as I remember, at age 18 I was extremely stupid. The fact that other 18 year olds were impressed by my intelligence at the time, tells me that they were even dumber than me.


I don't think that an 18 year old can consent. If you compare knowledge of 25 year old to that of 18 year old, it's like whole world of difference.


But one more important thing. People at age 18 aren't ready to have kids, so letting them consent just increases risk of pregnancy which is going to be higher likely a defect or abortion.


Ideal age to give birth is 21 to 26, so there is no point in setting age of consent below 21.


Another thing, person shouldn't really be in relationships at age 18. First, because those relationships are virtually guaranteed to be a disappointment and failure. Second, because relationships take away free time and reduce time left for thinking. A person should first take plenty of time to think and develop before making any big decisions which at same time risk reducing reasoning ability.


I think relationship is a big decision, and comes with countless consequences average 18 year old is just not ready for to deal with, when they at same time have to focus on education.


Biggest issue about relationships which I realized is that being alone builds intelligence, while being in relationship takes away free time and leaves less time for thinking.


With all the technology out there, average person doesn't even have a need to be in a relationship. And I don't really see any benefits of 18 year old being in a relationship. It negatively affects education, reasoning, takes away free time and carries a significant risk of pregnancy.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

But would you have similar problems with a society that gave the same amount to charity and just exploited less? Assuming the exploitation was consensual and improved people's circumstances on top of the charity?


I mean, it largely depends on what we consider to be exploitation. If we are talking of less exploitation in form of child labor and extreme working conditions, then I wouldn't have issue with society having less of those.


This is because banning certain forms of exploitation doesn't actually leave people without options. When child labor was banned, it didn't leave those children without options. This is because society adapts.


You can quite perfectly reduce work hours legally to 7 per day, 5 days a week, and employment won't drop.


This isn't "exploitation or no exploitation". This is just banning forms of exploitation which are severely harmful to society long term.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

If your point is just charity is good then fine I agree. Maybe people are even obligated to give some amount. But above that I think exploitation is justified cause it is helping, just a limited amount. I don't think everyone is obligated to sell every organ they can and work long hours to maximally help.


My issue is more with society which maximizes exploitation. I don't have issues with society where there is exploitation, but also a lot of charity to improve lives of all, even the exploited ones who are at the bottom of society.


And I agree that person doesn't have obligation to donate organs or work maximally long hours, because that would make good person's life way worse. But I do think one should donate to charity a lot, and the rule about this is usually first secure yourself financially, then donate extra to charity.

SatanLucy

I have read code of conduct again, and I don't see any issues in it. Seems fine. The only issue regarding AI posts which I saw is that it's a bit too strict, that's all.


Other than this, a perfect code of conduct.

SatanLucy

As I said on discord, I am not sure the AI rule is good. I mean, being limited to use AI 3 times per week only?


That's not enough. Sometimes I need to use AI 3 times a day. I am sure there are other users who also use a lot of AI. I don't know, the number seems a bit too strict.


But if thats the median vote, fine.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

If every American donated 20% of their income, the amount would be enormous.


Using the latest full-year figure available, U.S. personal income was about $26.1 trillion in 2025.


Calculation


$26.1 trillion × 20% = $5.22 trillion per year


So roughly:


💰 $5.2 trillion per year


💰 $435 billion per month


💰 $14.3 billion per day


🇺🇸 About $15,300 per U.S. resident per year, using the 2025 population of 341.8 million.



That's roughly one-fifth of all personal income in the United States being redirected to charitable causes every year.


For comparison, $5.2 trillion is more than 20% of U.S. GDP, so it would be an extraordinarily large redistribution of resources—not simply a modest increase in charitable giving.


If you want, I can also .estimate **what $5.2 trillion/year could accomplish globally** (poverty, hunger, housing, healthcare, education, etc.)



If the hypothetical $5.2 trillion per year were coordinated and spent effectively on global development, it could have an extraordinary impact. The key point is that $5.2T is so large that money alone would stop being the main constraint in many areas; infrastructure, governance, skilled workers, conflict, and logistics would become major constraints.


For scale, the ILO estimates that low- and middle-income countries need about $1.4 trillion additional spending per year to achieve universal social-protection floors and essential healthcare.


A plausible allocation of $5.2T/year


Area Annual funding Potential impact


🏥 Healthcare $1.2T Massive expansion of hospitals, clinics, medicines, vaccines and preventive care

🍚 Food & nutrition $700B Large-scale food security, nutrition programs and agricultural investment

🏠 Housing & basic infrastructure $800B Housing, electricity, clean water, sanitation and roads

🎓 Education $700B Universal basic education plus huge expansion of secondary/vocational education

💵 Poverty/social protection $800B Cash transfers, pensions, disability support and assistance to extremely poor families

🌱 Clean energy & climate $500B Renewable electricity, grids, storage and climate adaptation

🕊️ Humanitarian/refugee assistance $200B Enormous expansion of assistance during wars, disasters and displacement

🔬 Science/technology $200B Medicine, agriculture, energy and other technological development

Total $5.1T



That would leave roughly $100B for administration, emergency reserves and other priorities.


The humanitarian side alone would be transformed


For perspective, UNHCR's entire 2025 global appeal was about $10.25 billion.


So $5.2 trillion is roughly 500 times that amount.


The UN's humanitarian system has recently been operating with dramatically less funding; humanitarian funding fell from about $47.5B in 2022 to $33.3B in 2025.


So $5.2T could theoretically fund humanitarian operations on an entirely different scale.


Healthcare could be particularly powerful


The WHO/World Bank report says approximately 4.6 billion people lack access to essential health services, while 2.1 billion experience financial hardship from healthcare costs.


And the World Bank currently estimates that government and donor spending in low-income countries is less than one-third of the $60/person benchmark considered necessary for essential health services.


A sustained $1+ trillion annual investment could therefore dramatically expand:


Primary-care clinics


Maternal and infant healthcare


Vaccination


Malaria/TB/HIV prevention and treatment


Clean-water infrastructure


Medicines


Emergency medicine


Mental-health services


Medical training


Hospitals and laboratories



Poverty could potentially be reduced enormously


The ILO's estimate is especially striking: $1.4T/year is estimated to be enough to close the social-protection financing gap across low- and middle-income countries.


That includes support for:


Children


Older people


Disabled people


Unemployed people


Mothers


Essential healthcare



So even allocating $1.4T annually could theoretically address a huge portion of the basic social-protection deficit.


Over 10 years


If the money were sustained:


$5.2T × 10 = $52 trillion


That's enough to potentially finance a generational transformation of living standards in poorer countries.


It wouldn't mean simply handing everyone money. A more effective approach would be to build productive capacity: electricity, clean water, schools, hospitals, roads, agriculture, housing, internet access, businesses and education.


In other words, the most powerful effect might be moving billions of people from "helping them survive" → "giving them the infrastructure and human capital to become economically self-sufficient."


And importantly, $5.2T doesn't mean $5.2T of pure benefit automatically. Dumping that much money into the world economy could cause inflation, corruption, waste, asset-price increases and shortages if spending outpaced the ability to actually produce goods and services. The challenge would shift from finding money to deploying it effectively.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Also, the idea that a lot of money is needed is actually not true.


If each American donated just 10$, they would raise around 2 billion dollars, enough to solve all homelessness in USA.


I don't even need to say what they could do if each American donated 10$ each month.


Also, I am a big fan of cost-effective charity. I don't think all charity is equal. Homes for homeless and shelters for homeless are really two different things.


But as far as I know, average American donates less than 1% of their income to charity. To put things in perspective, if average American donated 20% of their income to charity, they would raise 12 trillions each year, and that's pretty much enough to solve any damn social issue in whole USA. Right now they only raise about 600 billion, but a lot of that goes to church building.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Except exploitation isn't harm since it's better than nothing.


I think it is harm, because the goal of eliminating poverty cannot be achieved by maximizing exploitation.



In fact, not exploiting would be helping less than you could be since you wouldn't have the money to help others.


If your goal is helping others, then surely money you make can be used to help the people you exploited first, so it stops being exploitation.


The problem in "maximizing profit to help others" lies in the fact that each extra money can be further used to make new investments and maximize profit. So maximizing profit actually never ends in cycle and money never reaches people.


At some point, person must stop re-investing money, and instead donate it.


However, opening a business and donating extra from business income is usually easier and doesn't necessarily require exploiting anyone.


Owning non-exploitative businesses and also helping others with extra income is the most optimal approach, because no one in that system lives in poverty.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

You said until poverty is eliminated.


Yes, but it doesn't mean you give all your money to others. You still need part of money for your own food and house.



I was asking if individuals, without state backing, were obligated to give all their excess money to charity.


I think both individual and state have obligation to help others. If you wouldn't let a child in front of you drown, why would you let child somewhere else starve? Starvation is probably worse than drowning. I say if individual earns 100000$, but only needs 50000$ to cover basic expenses and secure long future, the idea of keeping 50000$ for personal use seems terribly selfish. One can donate to charity or invest in business to create jobs, or just help people he knows need the help. However, if someone is entirely self centered, then who will solve poverty?


I guess you think they are, so I guess from a hard utilitarianism view, exploitation is suboptimal.


Well, there are different forms of exploitation. Some is a lot worse than other.


But I still think the optimal utilitarian path might involve exploiting some people in order to use the profit to help others.


I don't believe in "harm one to help another" approach. Maybe some exploitation is necessary for economy to function, but such must be so minimal that it can be barely called exploitation.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Yes—donating money can improve the donor’s quality of life, although it depends on the person and how the donation is made.


Research generally finds several possible benefits:


Greater happiness: Giving to others can produce a “warm glow” and positive emotions.


More meaning and purpose: Donating to causes you care about can make life feel more meaningful.


Better social connection: Giving can strengthen relationships and a sense of belonging, especially when done through a community.


Less focus on oneself: Generosity can shift attention away from personal worries and toward helping others.


Life satisfaction: People who regularly give to others often report higher overall life satisfaction.



There is an important limit, though: donating money that you genuinely cannot afford can reduce quality of life because financial stress can outweigh the psychological benefits.


A useful principle is:


> Donate enough to meaningfully help others while keeping enough financial security for yourself.




Interestingly, the benefit doesn't necessarily require giving a huge amount. Even relatively small donations can provide psychological benefits when the donor feels that the money is genuinely making a difference.



Yes, donating can improve social relationships, particularly when the giving is connected to other people.


It can help by:


Building trust: Generosity can signal that you're cooperative and caring.


Strengthening friendships and family relationships: Giving to people you care about can reinforce bonds.


Creating social connections: Donating to a community, charity, or group can introduce you to people with similar values.


Increasing reciprocity: People may be more inclined to help and cooperate with someone they perceive as generous.


Improving your reputation: Generosity can make others view you more positively.



However, there is a distinction between healthy generosity and giving to gain approval. If someone repeatedly gives money mainly because they fear rejection or expect something in return, it can actually create unhealthy relationships.


So, in general: generosity tends to support social connection, but the quality of the relationship and the motivation for giving matter.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Pretty much anyone who tries that will go broke long before poverty is eliminated.


Not really. You don't have to give all your money, just extra. So you won't ever go broke. And the nation will not go broke. In fact, nations with more donations consistently rank better in life quality, because apparently helping others somehow rewards the person who helps too.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

So everyone is obligated to give all their excess income to charity?


No, just give all extra until there are no more poor people. After you eliminate poverty, there is no one to give extra of income to, and nation enters golden age.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

No one in this thread is denying that, the argument is that exploitation is better than inaction.


Exploitation includes inaction. Read The Little Match Girl I mentioned.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Yes — some of Hans Christian Andersen’s fairy tales can reasonably be read as criticisms of capitalism, wealth inequality, and bourgeois society, although it would be anachronistic to call Andersen simply an “anti-capitalist” writer.


Andersen lived from 1805–1875, during the rise of industrial capitalism and modern urban society. His stories frequently focus on poverty, class hierarchy, wealth, exploitation, status, and the way wealthy or powerful people treat those beneath them. Scholars have specifically noted his criticism of social conditions and class inequality.


The clearest example: The Little Match Girl


This is probably the strongest Andersen story for a capitalist/inequality interpretation.


The girl is:


extremely poor,


forced to sell matches,


surrounded by people who have food, warmth and Christmas celebrations,


unable to participate in that prosperity,


and ultimately dies in the street.



The important contrast is between abundance and deprivation. She can see warm houses, food and wealthy people's Christmas decorations, but cannot access them.


The fact that she is literally selling a commodity to survive makes the story especially interesting from a capitalist perspective. Her economic value matters more than her wellbeing: she must sell matches or face punishment at home.


However, Andersen doesn't present this as a Marxist argument like “capitalism is the problem and socialism is the solution.” His response is primarily moral and humanitarian: society has become so indifferent to poverty that a child can freeze to death while surrounded by people enjoying prosperity.


The Emperor's New Clothes


This one is less directly about economics but strongly attacks status, hierarchy and social conformity.


The emperor has enormous wealth and power, yet he is essentially a fool. The people around him are afraid to tell him the truth because of his position.


Andersen is mocking a society where:


> wealth + status + authority = assumed superiority




That's a broader criticism of elite society rather than capitalism specifically.


The Swineherd


This is another strong example of Andersen mocking the aristocratic/bourgeois obsession with luxury, status and artificial sophistication. The royal court values expensive and fashionable objects while failing to appreciate genuine beauty and simplicity. Andersen's satire of the court has been interpreted as criticism of superficial upper-class culture.


The Ugly Duckling


This can also be interpreted economically/class-wise, although that's not necessarily its primary meaning.


The protagonist is rejected because he doesn't fit the standards of his society. His eventual transformation into a swan changes how everyone sees him.


That can be read as criticism of a society that judges people according to appearance, status and social value.


But there's an important complication


Andersen's stories aren't consistently anti-capitalist.


His own life is actually an interesting counterexample. He was born into relatively poor circumstances and eventually became wealthy and famous. One modern scholar specifically notes that his success coincided with the rise of capitalism in Denmark — and that his rise from poverty to wealth was itself enabled by the new capitalist society.


So I would characterize Andersen as:


Critical of:


extreme poverty


wealth inequality


exploitation of the powerless


social indifference


aristocratic/bourgeois arrogance


obsession with material status


treating people according to economic/social value



Not necessarily critical of:


private wealth itself


commerce


entrepreneurship


social mobility


capitalism as an economic system in the modern ideological sense



In other words, Andersen is much more clearly a critic of social inequality and human cruelty than a systematic critic of capitalism.


And that distinction matters. A modern reader can legitimately find anti-capitalist themes in The Little Match Girl, but saying “Andersen's fairy tales are anti-capitalist” would be too broad. His deeper recurring message is closer to “a society that possesses wealth but lacks compassion is morally corrupt.”

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

In any case, society where people help each other without seeking personal benefits each time is way better.


As far as I see, exploitative society necessarily produces exploitative parents, and then kids get worse living conditions and less opportunities.


Exploited is simply something all creatures despise to be. Such is the teaching of Taoism, which people will never understand, so their lives are cursed.

SatanLucy

I don't really see point in AI regulation, because it is literally impossible to regulate. Even if you manage to regulate all of online AI in your country, local AI is simply impossible to regulate, and AI outside your country is impossible to regulate.


AI is simply technology which is immune to regulation. That is reality.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

A lot of people think Karl Marx was some lazy philosopher who just didn't want to work.


But they didn't see what Marx saw. In an unregulated capitalism, children as young as 4 were working 12 hours a day in a factory. Bosses were regularly sexually exploiting female workers. Capitalists intentionally reduced wages to force families to send their children to work as well. Working conditions were so horrible that you were lucky to merely survive a job without losing hand or finger.


That's what Marx saw, and just because after hundreds of years of government regulations, these types of exploitations reduced, it doesn't mean they wouldn't happen again if capitalism was less regulated, because it still happens again today in each country where capitalism is left to itself.


Maybe some exploitation is unavoidable, but government pretty much had to intervene to reduce exploitation for countless times in past few hundred years, because when left to itself, capitalism maximizes exploitation.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Altruistic transaction is demanding person to do something but paying way more than its worth. So person learns work ethics and it isnt just free money.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

How many examples can you think of where exploiters in first world countries are creating problems just to sell the solution?


Wars, housing, healthcare, products designed to break down to increase sales rate, lobbying, pollution, obesity, depression, addiction-based design of products to increase sales rate.... Really, how many examples do you need?



Technology has improved and people are richer now than most earlier times in history


Some people are richer now, yes. The homeless arent.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Transactional relationships with people can also be altruistic.


For example, paying a poor person 1000$ to wash your car. Surely, thats transactional, but it benefits poor person much more and person pays a lot more than he has to for car washing.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Most big companies are inventing new products rather than causing problems to create a need.


I appreciate the opinion. I just disagree with it.



Some people being exploited is better than no one being exploited.


Not really.



I don't see how you can just blame capitalists for all the pre-existing issues in society.


Its not the capitalists I am blaming, but exploiters, who as I said before also create new ways of exploitation.



The conditions exist whether the capitalist helps or does nothing.


Its not help if its exploitation. Exploitation is conditional help with aim of getting most personal benefit out of it.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

So either that involves active harm (which people have incentives to do anyway)


Way more incentive when you can profit greatly from it by exploitation later.



How does a sum of positive numbers equal a negative number?


Because total system doesnt include just positive numbers. What you see as positive exchange also includes elements outside that exchange: degradation of human relationships, those who arent helped because they cant be exploited good, and so on.


If all doctors were exploitative and only working for money, and you were sick without money, no doctor would help you. You would die from sickness, resulting in a negative number.


Also, exploitative conditions themselves harm health and mental health, so not all so positive in this capitalist exploitation utopia.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

If exploitation didn't help the people being exploited, they wouldn't agree to it.


It helps them, true.


So, stealing?


No, creating conditions where people end up in situation where they are easier to exploit.



Both sides gain value or neither side would agree. It's a positive-sum game.


Individually, yes. Long term, no.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

Inflation benefits the rich, so rich would actually seek higher inflation. Poor people benefit the rich as cheap work force, so rich would actually prefer more poor people. Poorly educated people are likewise more likely to be exploited.


Exploitation is based on someone being in a bad situation, so exploiters would seek to create society with plenty of people in bad situations which they can exploit, and plenty of bad situations they can exploit.


Same applies to politicians who exploit bad situations for political gain.


Exploitation only happens when exploiter takes greater value for him than what he gives, so long term it leads to concentration of power and wealth in few hands because exploiters always gain more than the exploited, enabling even more exploitation because increased wealth and power enable more of it.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

I think this is another special case


There are bunch of such cases where exploiters are actually making situation worse long run, because they profit from bad situations so they seek to create more of them.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

I think system based on exploitation rewards exploiters the most, and causes more exploitation in the long run, because exploiters will also seek to create exploiting situations, not just exploit when such chance appears on its own.


System based on goodness and helping others will always yield better society in the long run. Exploiting system in long run ruins mentality of people.


This is simply because human relationships are greatly formed by helping others, where hate and resentment is formed from exploitation.


Man might say to a homeless woman: "I will give you shelter for one day if you have sex with me.", and she might even agree because she has no other options, but she will still hate him for it.


On the other hand, man who offers shelter but asks for nothing in return, she will be grateful to him and consider him a great friend. She might even fall in love.


Exploitation doesn't work in the long run. It merely makes person who does it be despised by all creatures.


It is only one step above doing nothing, and in some cases, not even that, because people will usually hate more the one who exploits them than the one who does nothing.

SatanLucy

Exploitation

SatanLucy · 2 months ago

"To the self-serving, nothing shines forth. To the self-promoting, nothing is distinguished. From the viewpoint of Tao, this self-indulgence is like rotting food and painful growths on the body. All creatures despise it."


- Tao Te Ching