SatanLucy
if inductive argument is allowed, it would mean other forms of argument than deduction are allowed


They aren't two separate forms. They go together. Induction on its own is usually useless unless it is part of deductive argument.



a 500 word argument to several thousand words if everything is put in terms of deductive logic


Not everything needs to be in form of deductive logic, but framework needs to.


You can make argument:

P1. Smoking is harmful

P2. If something is harmful, then it shouldn't be done.

C. Smoking shouldn't be done


Then you can go with proving P1 and P2 with observations, logic and whatever.


It is very difficult to make framework or main argument without deductive logic.


You can make smaller sub-arguments without deductive logic, but something still needs to connect them to topic, and induction alone rarely does that.

SatanLucy

Christians and Muslims love making fun of pagans.


In paganism, God can be considered evil.


However, Christianity and Islam both claim maximally good God.


At same time, they claim evil exists in the world.


Problem with these two claims is that if evil exists in the world, it is caused by their God.


For start, their God, maximally good God, stands and watches while somewhere in the world, children drown or starve. This happens every day in this world.


God who is maximally good seems to be completely okay with not stopping any horrible thing.


But is God merely "not acting"?


No, God also caused all evil in the world.


All evil in the world is caused by God's design. It is God who designed animals to devour each other. It is God who designed world where people can not only hurt each other, but find countless ways to do it.


Also, God gave many people evil urges, making them gain pleasure from doing evil.


It's impossible to divorce God from evil.


Not even free will can do it, because it is still God choosing to create evil out of someone's free will. Why should free will of one man be able to cause harm to another? Because God created the world in such way that these things are guaranteed to happen.


God cannot be good. It's not logically possible. This is mainly because God also chose to create evil people, and is as result indirectly responsible for their evil.


God isn't merely inactive. He is enabling evil at the very least.



Evil =\= good


Evil = causing bad things, enabling bad things, (all which God does)


God = evil


God =\= good

SatanLucy

I think if someone isn't making a deductive argument, he is not making argument at all. A lot of people would improve their arguments if they actually placed them in form of premises and conclusion. It's also easier to make counters if you place opponent's case in premises and conclusion as well. Sure, it's more work, but it's better.


And yeah, people often get this bias about certain groups. Just because they see one video of trans person failing to defend their view of gender, they think each trans person fails.


However, anyone who is a long term debater shouldn't really have such bias.


Tho I sometimes start to wonder if debating is a productive activity. At some points, it does feel like it leads to nowhere.

SatanLucy

tho Markov chain chatbots still face a problem of basically detecting no sentence structure. My INFINI models are based on detecting sentence structure through words which remain same in sentence (constants) and words which change (variables), so variables can be replaced for something else.


Markov chain, however, relies on words it generated so far, and only up until certain number. It doesnt pre-generate sentence structure. Its why it sometimes gets stuck in a loop.

SatanLucy

For those not familiar, markov chain chatbot is a chatbot which predicts next word based on (for example) 5 previous words it already generated, so when those 5 words are found in text, the word which comes after them becomes generated word.


Now, what is problem with markov chain chatbots? their main problem lies in the fact that their developer must pick a number of previous words to base current generation on.


If chain is too long, such as 12 previous words, chatbot will merely repeat from text and generate no new sentences, no creativity. If chain is too short, such as 3 previous words, chatbot becomes creative but incoherent and its grammar starts to suck badly, there is simply no ideal chain length. You are always going to have either mostly pure repetition either mostly incoherence, always sacrificing either creativity or coherence.


In past, I used to address this problem by creating randomized number for chain, so sometimes it uses 3, sometimes 10 previous words....ect.


However, recently I was also coding my INFINI chatbot models, and they are based on structures of sentences, their constants and variables, rather than chain of previous words, and they work much better than markov chain.


However, then I realized how my INFINI models are actually predicting a variable, and variable can have more than one word. So they are not predicting word by word, but possibly even groups of words.


I realized, why not try something similar with markov chain chatbots.


Why should markov chain predict word by word?


Wouldnt a much better way be, lets say to predict next 5 words based on previous 4 words?


So I put the idea to the test. And the result of rest was very surprising. Markov chatbot still maintains creativity because it only predicts based on 4 previous words, however, because it generates words 5 by 5, it also maintains coherence.

SatanLucy

Maybe there needs to be some reward system for voting. I mean, it's been months and my debate only got 1 vote. I don't mind losing a debate, but this voting process seems to be getting slower and slower over time. It is as if most people are waiting for someone else to vote. I only got one more debate to vote on, but there are still 2 unfinished debates after that which are gonna need to be voted on if we are to start next round at all.

SatanLucy
Hence thousands of years of different denominations going to war. You have to infer using context, but it's probabilistic, not deterministic.


I guess. There was a time when I was Christian and practiced Sola scriptura. However, I quickly realized that my interpretation of Bible was making me evil, and I simply couldn't justify anymore believing in that. Tho maybe some other interpretations are better than mine. It's just not something I would bother with anymore.

SatanLucy
even without all of the modern access to criticism, I think much of the Bible was widely interpreted non-literally


I mean, non-literal interpretations raise issues. Who decides when something in the Bible is non-literal?


Someone might interpret Jesus's advice to poke own eyes out as "non-literal", someone else might interpret it as literal. There is really no telling which is right, because how would we know what Jesus meant by that? We can't ask him, and Bible doesn't explain it either.

SatanLucy
This isn't really a modern argument. Atheists are generally agnostic, so it's not like they have more evidence for their position today than they did before; their argument is just that Christians don't have sufficient evidence, and I don't see how this would be a bigger challenge today than in the Roman Empire


It is bigger challenge today because today, conditions are different. People are different, smarter, differently educated. In past, education wasn't really something popular.


If conditions were same as they were before, Christianity wouldn't be facing a decline. We would have same world as before, but we don't.


My original premise was simply that without persecution or some type of forcing it on people, Christianity is never gonna be an interesting religion.


Even Roman Empire had to use force to spread Christianity and eradicate polytheism. Maybe Constantine didn't use force, but later government did, and Constantine himself was actually using a lot of pressure on population to push Christianity. Economical pressure at a time when average person has monthly income of 100$ is a big deal.

SatanLucy
Under Constantine, Christianity was neither persecuted nor forced upon people, and it spread pretty rapidly.


Constantine was government spreading the religion and basically being it's sponsor. Also, outlawing other religions happened pretty quickly in Roman Empire.


Another factor is that at that time, Christianity was a new religion and most people were illiterate.


Today, Christianity is much older religion and I don't think there are illiterate people anymore. Anyone can easily read the Bible.


Also, debates are much more common now, and atheists are destroying Christians in debates virtually everywhere.


I don't even need to say that we are yet to even prove existence of intelligent creator, let alone Christian version of him.


It's easy to conclude that something created us. However, saying it was "Christian God" is a huge leap of faith which atheists dismiss easily.

SatanLucy
Which usually stems from a general lack of purpose. Atheism brings solace in a world with no purpose.


It's not really a lack of purpose. It's just a lack of purpose of reproduction.


There are still other purposes to base actions on, such as getting drunk.

SatanLucy
It's more like people naturally choose atheism to justify not reproducing.


There are wide number of options to justify not reproducing, one of most popular being "And why should I reproduce?".