SatanLucy

Reported number of rape cases is 128k per year.


If we account for unreported cases, it could be still as high as 500k because around 30 million women report experiencing attempted or completed rape in their lifetime.


If we were to assume 1% suicide death rate among those women, it would be 300,000 deaths among them, or about 5000 deaths per year over 60 year period.


But such suicide rates dont exist, because women in total, all women commit 10,000 suicides per year. Most of those have many different causes. Depression, violence in marriage, caregiving obligations, trans issues...ect.


the claim that rape has 1% chance to drive victim to suicide is only true if you assume no one among 30 million raped women would commit suicide if werent raped.


But with standard suicide rates of 5 per 100,000 for all population of women, it means the 30 million by default would have similar suicide rate anyway, which is about 1500 suicides per year.


So only 3500 suicides can be potentially blamed on rape when assuming 1% suicide rate among rape victims.


that is about 8 times lower than number of people killed or severely injured by drunk drivers.


And when we account for SA too, death rate becomes much lower. So the claim of 1% death rate caused purely by rape is not true.

SatanLucy

Reported number of SA is 500k per year. If we assume 50% is reported, then it becomes 1 million per year.


Number of women who commit suicide per year is 10,000.


Even if we blamed all those suicides on rapists and SA, the death rate would be 1%. But most of those suicides arent due to SA, so the death rate falls under 0.5%.


As I provided before, the injury rate from drunk driving is 76 per 100,000.


Reported rape rates are 34 per 100,000, and SA rates are probably 295 per 100,000 when assuming unreported cases.



That's not per capita though. Drunk driving is much more common than rape.


If everyone in society was rapist or SA, death rates from suicides for women would be 855,000, and this is even assuming current suicide rates from victims, and not that suicide rates change because women adapt.


Even if we were to assume 1% suicide rate, deaths would still be 1.7 million.


If everyone was a drunk driver, there would be 5 million deaths, 5 million severe injuries and 30 million injuries per year, as driving when really drunk increases risk of fatality by over 12x.

SatanLucy
So rape has about a 1.3% chance of killing someone


Almost all victims of rape are women.


Women commit about 10,000 suicides per year.


Even if we were to blame all those suicides specifically on rapists, drunk drivers kill 12000 per year, severely injure over 14000, and injure 270,000 each year.


But many women who commit suicide have other reasons for it.


In fact, the suicide death rate is way higher among men, even tho men are less raped.

SatanLucy

Alyssa


...am I agreeing with something SatanLucy said?


If you check the big issues page on my profile, we are 66% in agreement. So we actually agree a lot.

SatanLucy
All politics is a call for violence. What do you think happens if the legal framework changes and people do not comply?


true, unless the president is Jesus, and he wouldnt be president for long.

SatanLucy

Also, having an age preferance doesnt mean someone isnt heterosexual. If that were true, then anyone who is not map couldnt be heterosexual because he would have age preference too. I really doubt there is any heterosexual out there who doesnt have age preference, because that would mean being attracted to all ages equally, which sounds terribly unlikely because someone attracted to 18 year old usually isnt nearly as attracted to 90 year old.

SatanLucy
The entire Pride movement has clarified that this is why it is wrong to call a homo-oriented pedophile a homosexual because they're actually not into grown adults of their own gender.


It sounds more like emotional reaction than an argument.


And not even true, a lot of maps are attracted to adults too. the idea that one part of population is attracted to only over 18, and another part only to under 18, is probably the most autistic view of society I have ever seen.

SatanLucy
I'm pretty sure there's nothing about the definition of hetero that specifies the age of the person you're attracted to.


RM uses his own dictionary. He doesnt actually speak English. All words he says have different meaning than what reader would think they mean.

SatanLucy
Drunk driving causes accidents *sometimes, and thus causes harm *sometimes. Drunk driving is not directly equated to harm. Irresponsible, stupid, selfish? 100%, but harm is not a given.


Sometimes causes harm = causes harm



Some people aren't harmed by being violated you say? Thats incoherent.


the degree of harm greatly varies. Some people are not affected by it later at all. Some women even send love letters to their rapists.



The CDC cites 125 million instances of driving under the influence every year. Your numbers are vastly overstated


that is per one ride. It doesnt mean 125 million Americans are constantly driving drunk. the numbers which I gave came from a simple statistic that driving when really drunk increases chances of fatal accident by over 12x. So all current US deaths and injuries from car accidents would be multiplied by at least 10, if everyone was constantly driving really drunk.


How do you rationalize the chance of hurting someone as being worse than hurting someone?


thats easy. If I was given choice between punching someone, or pressing button where that same someone has 10% chance to die, I would just punch them. Maybe punch always causes harm, but death rate of 10% is greater harm generally.

SatanLucy
OP was comparing DUI and rape, not drunk driving incidents and rape.


Driving drunk causes drunk driving accidents, and thus harm.



while driving under the influence is always a bad idea, it doesn't always cause harm.


this point is irrelevant. Maybe some women arent harmed by rape, but we are not going to say that rape is never harmful.



If some movie horror scenario forced a choice between driving under the influence or raping someone, the former should ALWAYS be chosen because of this.


If entire US population chose former, result would be 500,000 deaths per year and 30 million injuries per year. In just 10 years, it would be 5 million deaths, and 300 million injuries, rendering entire population effectively harmed to the point that society can no longer function long term.

SatanLucy

I am proud to be straight. I appreciate all the contributions of straight people to society, and a struggle to recognize that being straight is not wrong but cool and something to be celebrated, and that celebrating straight history, straight culture and straight community is good.


While all of us sometimes act a little gay, we wont let society define us that way. We were born perfectly straight, and we cant let people turn us gay, even tho many are trying.


Karl Marx was straight. Many great people were straight, some straighter than others, but all were straight in their own way, and they deserve to be celebrated for that.

SatanLucy

Next topic can be drug dealers vs. rapists.


Rapists are more hated than drug dealers, even tho drug dealers kill 80,000 people per year in USA.


So drunk drivers are next to drug dealers, and both are worse than rapists.

SatanLucy
you continue to minimize inappropriate and unwanted touching


No, the topic is about drunk drivers vs rapists.


unwanted touching as a whole has nothing to do with topic, but lets say it did. I would rather be touched by women without my consent 1000 times than be hit and killed by a drunk driver, or hit and severely injured by a drunk driver.


False reporting is statistically low (2-10%) while un-reported sexuall assault (which includes rape) is as high as 80%.


this is an assumption, because if its unreported, then you dont even know if it happened.


"approximately 1 in 5 women (about 19.3% to 26.8%) in the U.S. report experiencing attempted or completed rape in their lifetime. This translates to roughly 17.7 million to 33.5 million American women."


How many do drunk drivers hurt?


"In the United States alone—where the most comprehensive long-term data is tracked—alcohol-impaired driving has claimed roughly 400,000 lives and caused millions of non-fatal injuries since the mid-1980s."


"That rate corresponds to roughly 260,000 injuries per year (525,600 minutes ÷ 2).

Over 40 years, that would amount to approximately 10.5 million injuries."


"About 1 million people have been killed in U.S. drunk-driving crashes since the mid-1960s. Using the injury estimate from the previous answer (roughly 12–24 million injured), drunk driving in the U.S. over the last 60 years has likely resulted in around 1 million deaths and tens of millions of injuries"


So drunk drivers injure more people than all murderers and suicides combined.


the rate of injuries from drunk driving is 76 per 100,000. this is higher than homicide rates, suicide rates and rape rates combined.


The yearly reported forcible rape rate in the United States is roughly 37.5 per 100,000 inhabitants.


So I am afraid drunk drivers still injure more people than rapists.

SatanLucy
You're defining "right-wing" exclusively as capitalism?


Right wing is pro free market capitalism. Historically, most fascist dictators were not pro free market. Hitler was even a socialist.


So you confuse fascism with right wing, when really, it can be left wing economically too.

SatanLucy
That in no way equates half a million sexual violence cases to ~500k cases of butt grabbing.


Oh sure, 400k cases of butt grabbing, titty slap, or trump's "grab by pussy" - none of that is rape, its sexual assault. If you look at number of rape cases, its about 128k, assuming no false reports of course.

SatanLucy
You are conflating sexual violence to butt grabbing.


You said 500k victims per year. those are numbers of sexual assaults, not rape, and yeah, grabbing butt without consent is considered sexual assault. I dont see what confuses you here.

SatanLucy
Anarcho-fascism is considered right wing because of the authoritarianism and ultranationalism it embraces.


Sorry, you dont know what fascism is. Authoritarianism isnt right wing, as all commies are authoritarian. Nationalism is something different, its not what defines right wing.

SatanLucy
There are nearly 500k victims of sexual violence in the US each year.


Moving the goalpost, sexual assault isnt rape. Someone grabbing your butt would be sexual assault, but its still way better than entering a car with a drunk driver.

SatanLucy
negligently driving under the influence (which doesn't necessarily cause harm)


Oh yeah, it only harms over 200,000 people in USA each year. No biggie.

SatanLucy
Your categories suck, and the fact that you're insisting that they are the only two that are defendable is dumb.


I mean, you can say that logic is dumb, that math is dumb, sure.



Idk where you got "equally" from anything I've said.


Because there are only 3 possible options:


A. Rapists are worse than drunk drivers

B. Drunk drivers are worse than rapists

C. Rapists and drunk drivers are equally bad


So pick and choose what you want to defend. A defends drunk drivers. B and C defends rapists.

SatanLucy
If they were the same category, they'd be saying similar things


No, they would not be saying "similar things", they would be proving same category.


Both equally suck = Drunk drivers are not worse than rapists


Neither suck = Drunk drivers are not worse than rapists.



Also, on this particular topic, person either defends rapists or drunk drivers, because society's default position already is that rapists are worse than drunk drivers. Should society be convinced to change their mind, rapist's position would improve in comparison.


So if someone says "they both equally suck", he is actually defending rapists.

SatanLucy
You're presenting a false dichotomy. Within B is a myriad of other positions that aren't the same.


thats not false dichotomy. those are just sub-categories of same category. Any of them true makes category true. In same way word "rapists" includes all rapists, and none of those rapists are same, but category includes them all in one.

SatanLucy
A. Drunk drivers are worse than rapists
B. Drunk drivers are not worse than rapists
C. They both suck


C is not a 3rd option. If they both suck equally, then its B. If drunk drivers suck more, its A. And if rapists suck more, its still B.


Personally, I would rather enter a rapist's house than enter in a car with a drunk driver. If rapist rapes me, I can tell myself that it didnt actually happen. But if die in car crash due to drunk driver, then I die and cant tell anything anymore.

SatanLucy
Nothing in the site's rules that disallow me from expressing a different opinion.


I mean, sure, but there are only two possible sides of the topic:

A. Drunk drivers are worse than rapists

B. Drunk drivers are not worse than rapists


Because the options are mutually exclusive, there is no "both", and because those are only logical options possible, there is no "neither".


But I checked your profile big issues, and we are in 66% agreement. So I cant see why we cant agree here.

SatanLucy
Lets have neither of them.


the topic doesnt allow option "neither". the topic is comparing which is worse, with only 2 sides available. You either side with rapists or with drunk drivers. Society loves drunk drivers more, so it is expected for more people to side with drunk drivers.