Most elo farmers on the previous site were contenders accepting debates from noobs who had written poor descriptions
Being Con also helps with having last word, which in debates with under 3 rounds is deadly, and as Novice demonstrated, if you forfeit a middle round, you effectively turn 3 round debate into 2 round debate.
Anyway, cheating is point of these debates. the main point of formal debate is to exploit a weakness in topic which opponent didnt notice.
there are truly no balanced topics when burden of proof is on Pro.
Pro either establishes a strong position from start by definitions and topic, or he loses to competent debaters who accept as Con and exploit weakness in position.
What people seem to want here is to take away Pro's advantage in making start position, without realizing that would give a lot of advantage to Con.
Con already has enough advantage of first being able to not accept debate in first place, being able to have last word, and being able to exploit any undefined words, or contradictions with definitions.
In fact, being always Con and waiting for debates with weakest structure is probably best way to increase rating, and Novice did that a lot but he eventually screwed up because debates arent always predictable, and sometimes Pro turns out stronger than expected.
And as I said before, Pro doesnt really have big advantage in setting structure in debate, for two reasons:
One, definitions in description can be challenged.
Voters often accept challenge of definitions, even if those definitions are in description. So Pro must make sure his definitions are also from dictionary.
Problem two, Pro must make debate topic be able to be challenged, or no one will accept.
Sure, I can make a debate topic where I say "1 plus 1 is two", and I define "two" as "1 plus 1", but who will accept? No one.
So Pro doesnt actually have any advantage, because any debate structure Pro makes must first be approved by Con for debate to start.