Thoth

I really wish that Helz had waited for my approval before claiming to be in a chat, or at least before claiming who he was in a chat with. Yes, I am currently chatting with Helz.

Magoroth wrote:

There isn’t one

Sounds like low-effort game design if you ask me

What is the difference between Lazy Mafioso and Lazy Godfather?

Lunatic wrote:

Its theoretically possible casey is scum and claiming dreamer yes. Do you have any behavioral reasons to suspect her or think she is lying? Thats the problem here, just because someone could be lying doesn't mean they are and we should automatically lynch them. If she is a legit dreamer then its between, me mikal and bullish.

I just have bad vibes about it, which have gotten less bad as this day phase has gone on, but I'm not fully comfortable with their Dreamer claim. We're completely fucked if we lynch all three people in that PoE.

Bullish wrote:

Dude lynching casey to confirm the poe is literally useless. Casey flips town we know there's at least 1 scum between me lunatic mikal.

We lynch one of us, say me, and I flip town, WE STILL KNOW there's at least 1 scum between casey lunatic and mikal.

So you are saying that in either case, we still have 3 people with 1 confirmed scum? How is lynching Casey less useful than lynching you in that scenario?

No votes on Casey at the moment. Did I miss something while reading up? Have we tossed out the idea of lynching them to validate the PoE? That seems a priori reasonable enough to me given the lack of hard evidence against anyone so far.

Lunatic wrote:

My role PM justifcation bullet points

I am Krypton which comes from a Greek word meaning hidden/concealed

The meaning is not symbolic, and is based on how I am historically percieved

Im in group 18 on the periodic table

I have a closed shell config "[Ar] 3d¹⁰ 4s² 4p⁶" whatever the fuck that means

The shell makes me chemicaly invert under many conditions

I have high energy ionization

My electron affinity is effectively neglible

My participation in bonding is extremely limited.

I am colorless, oderless, and chemically nonreactive under standard conditions.

I remain undetected unless specific tools like spectroscopy or high energy excitation are used to reveal me.

My discovery came late in chemical history because I resisted easy detection in air seperation.

Due to all this I am a compulsive hider.

That is literally all the information in my role pm paraphrased.

I'm going to admit that I don't really have anything meaningful to contribute to the discussion right now other than gutreads, but I'll try to read up tonight before voting.

Lunatic wrote:

I have a book of justification, but the gist of it is what I said. Want me to copy past it in AI and translate it or something?

The day 1 OP says not to do this

I had no night action that I know of, other than Pie pinging me, but it is possible that I did something without knowing it.

Hi, on now

Is there a specific intent behind this question?

Nothing except a generic desire to get people to think and plan for the future.

Again, I would like to ask everyone: Imagine that any of the three people in the Dreamer PoE were lynched. Imagine that they flip town or scum. That's six possibilities. How would each of those affect your view of the game?

UNVOTE

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=erfSed2MUsA

Lunatic wrote:

That is what I am basing that off of. But Mikal was calling them a he.

I made the same mistake in their Deltarune game because I had only ever heard of Casey as a male name.

Lunatic wrote:

Pretty sure casey is a they/them or a female btw. Also casey was town in solo leveling so I am confused what you mean by that?

Casey told me that they are fine with she/her or they/them pronouns but mildly prefer they/them.

Casey_Risk wrote:

See, this is the sort of super specific, highly technical stuff I see in my own role and the flips we have already. Gives me good vibes.

I'm guessing that scum have similarly technical stuff in their role cards and that scum will design their fake-claims accordingly.

Quick question for everyone: Imagine that any of the three people in Casey's claimed Dreamer results are lynched and flip town. How would each of them flipping town make you feel about Casey's Dreamer claim?

Let me guess: The minor difference is that it works even if you were visited, so you can deploy that defense if someone claims they visited you.

VTL: Casey_Risk

And I am honestly scumreading the fact that you did not instantly claim your element and justification along with Dreamer.

We need a complete full-claim.

Could you please explain to me how exactly your role works?

gutread it* gives me

I am not currently buying Casey's Dreamer claim. The gutread is gives me is too scummy. The way they breadcrumbed would never have been noticed if they hadn't called attention to it, and this line

And I did actually breadcrumb this role. I did it in my very first post, in fact.

comes off to me as trying too hard to convince us. At the bare minimum, I want Casey's element and justification in detail.

I also think that a Kohai kill fits with a Dreamer fake-claim because the whole point of fake-claiming Dreamer is to throw town into disarray, so you would want to get rid of the only confirmed townie even if they are widely perceived as skill-challenged.

It strikes me that Lunatic's justification claimed in post #18 has to do with how Krypton was perceived, rather than its properties.

I buy Rex's claim.

I only got one ping last night. I assume Pie was sending them to everyone.

There was nobody for me to select…

I either don’t have a night action or don’t choose what my target is. Naturally, Pie still pinged me to get my night actions in faster.