Wryly

"Nothing gets past me" is just very different than "nothing gets to me".


But I could see Mikal making you an Ascetic with that justification. Hmm.

Wryly
I poorly rephrased my role PM. I will try rephrasing it again



During my time as a moderator I''ve endured countless criticism, complaints, reports, name calling etc. and nothing seems to affect me. That's the justification for being ascetic once recrutied


This jibes a lot better, but also is very different than what you originally said. Trying not to be paranoid and read this as a revision crafted by your scummates.

Wryly
The same world where thoth claims leprechaun despite his scum partner advising him against it multiple times.


He's got you there mate. Drawn up short by your own history of wacky antics.

Wryly
Alyssa, for reasons that I have discussed mostly in my mason PM, but a few I have discussed publicly already.


Would you possibly mind publishing these ideas outside the country club newsletter

Wryly
I would like someone to name one possible world in which scum!Thoth would defend that supposed slip with a mixup between Mestari and Helz instead of having asked Mikal during signups who Mestari was.


WIFOM, but I agree it's a poor defense. I suppose the Mikal-told-me angle might not have occurred to you at the time.

Wryly

Vote count


Thoth 5/9 - Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Wylted

Shining 5/9 - Kohai, Wryly, Casey_Risk, Helz, Thoth

Kohai 1/9 - ILikePie5

Wryly

People still aren't buying your slip story or your claim and you're the hot ticket for the noose, that's whazzup

Wryly

VOTE COUNT


Thoth 5/9 - Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Wylted

Kohai 1/9 - ILikePie5

Shining 3/9 - Kohai, Wryly, Casey

Wryly

VOTE COUNT


Thoth 6/9 - Kohai, Mestari, Lunatic, Alyssa, Rex, Wylted

Kohai 1/9 - ILikePie5

Shining 2/9 - Kohai, Wryly

Wryly
VTL Shinning

Thotj has been the center of attention this DP. I’m not buying he has no thoughts on Thoth


Valid actually.


VTL Shining

Wryly
I mean, how much more movement do you expect us to make at this point? We already have a ton of posts to analyze for reads. Somehow I doubt that this day is going to end other than a Thoth lynch. Maybe we wait for Max to appear or get replaced, but what's the point of dragging this DP out all the way to Sunday?


With very little from Banana, Vader, Shining, with nothing more from Kohai or Thoth when both are under the crosshairs, and with nothing at all from Max, I'm baffled you guys don't want more time. What do we have to gain from cutting our time short? We're just giving mafia an early out from the police lineup.

Wryly
My god, only 37 pages and 1,000 posts to slog through after the flip? The horror! The humanity!


In a game with this many players it's hard to grill everyone who needs grilling in just two days, or to even get all the players to post a decent amount of content for examination. I want all the time I can to put every single fucking slide under the microscope and I don't care about the post total or reread tedium it creates. I don't care, I say!

Wryly

You're putting him at L-2. We have two days left to go in this thing. Let's be careful. Mikal said he wouldn't consider replacing Max until at least tomorrow.

Wryly
I do actually prefer they/them, though most people here use she/her for me. I don't really make a big deal of it either way. But if you ask me what my pronouns are, I'm going to say they/them.

Good reads post overall. You make good points regarding Alyssa, I have to admit. I find myself agreeing with you in that it's difficult to find the scum motivations behind her actions (I don't buy that she's partnered with Thoth, unlike Rex), but her behavior still feels off somehow. All I can think of is that maybe she's a Lost Mafia like Vader in Retro Games? Just a thought.


They/them it is.


I have yet to play a game with a Lost Wolf and it's definitely not something I tend to account for. I feel like even in the case of a Lost Wolf it doesn't make sense though. She wouldn't have been able to tell him about Mestari if they weren't sharing scumchat.


Right now it's looking like Thoth is going to be the lynch today. I'm okay with that, but I'd like to ask everyone here a question. If you had to vote for someone else, who would your choice be, and why?


I would be open to literally anyone outside my town pile. A shot in the dark is better than not shooting at all.

Wryly

What about "as a moderator nothing gets past me" fits with Ascetic exactly? Wouldn't that be a better justification for Cop or Lie Detector or Roleblocker or something?

Wryly
Mikal also told me that if there are 3P that exist they would get fake claims, just wanted to share that with town.


He was more cryptic when I asked. He said they could be given fake claims, but it's situational.

Wryly
Yes. And I imagine part of his reluctance to post after the fact ('I'm nocturnal) could have been his scummates subjecting him to intense invective in the scum PM and telling him to shut the fuck up.


"His scummate(s) wouldn't let him do that" reasoning has screwed me before, I do concede. I remember how hard it was for me to conceive of whiteflame being scum in Andor mafia because Kohai threw out that Strengthener claim. Couldn't believe whiteflame would let him do that. And as it turned out, he definitely didn't.

Wryly
Another point is that as scum Thoth has a tendency towards overextravagant, indulgent fake claims that blow up in his face.


You think he yolo'd his own fake claim idea without consensus from his team then? And that Mikal did not provide fake role claims?