I'll be on later tonight after I catch up
I'll be on later tonight after I catch up
Promise I'll weigh in more tomorrow, brain is too tired to play Vizzini right now
Definitely a wild conclusion to jump to when there is still three an unclaimed people in this game, and we had the least incentive of any to claim considering we could confirm each other at almost any point, but you do you.
Two town chats is just so loaded
Somehow I've made myself accept the idea of two identical passives -- sometimes I feel like I'm an idiot to have done so, but mechanically it seems to check out -- but two town chat roles is pushing it. My bet is either Luna or whiteflame are scum.
While I townread whiteflame
Why do you townread him?
Thoth would have been a great one to pump favor into in hindsight.
Didn't sound this sinterpretative in my head.
Thoth would have been a great one to pump favor into in hindsight. Sigh. This is going well for scum.
I have no reason yet to townread whiteflame, Pie, Banana, or awesome5000/Kohai. Lunatic I like behaviorally so I'm putting him aside for now. It feels almost useless to push for claims since full fake claims were provided, but we can start with Kohai's claim.
Lunatic has done more to scumhunt than several people outside your POE. Mechanically we have nothing on him, so he's not out of consideration, but I think your tunnel vision on him is largely due to the bias formed DP1.
Did you get a justification for your roles btw? I see Fuca Langhua is a major antagonist in the show but the fandom wiki is ass
In addition to the behavior read on Thoth, see Lunatic's POE breakdown.
The issue of me and Shining's similar passives remains unresolved, as does the wacky Poisoner that visits one person while poisoning another. I can only assume "Shadow Poisoner" is some custom shit that visits several people but only poisons one. I wonder if it's justified because of some poison-themed deception madness in the show.
I appreciate the claim but unfortunately it doesn't move the needle for me on Banana, she's still null, considering scum were provided with fake claims and fake roles, although she has not divulged her roles yet.
At least she broke the pattern of everybody claiming their roles but not their characters.
So nice knowing I don't have to update any personal claims list on notepad
I wonder if Rex sent scum videos for their fake claims as well
I should probably remind myself that I have no reason mechanically to townread Lunatic, but behaviorally he is reading as muy bueno.
I would like a claim, yes
Im townreading WF because I didn’t see the scumtell even though he had the opportunity to
Unfortunately those credits don't transfer to the rest of us, and scumtells aren't 100% anyway.
Regardless, I don't think if you and WF were scum partners you'd be defending him with so shaky a pretense.
You are assuming we are dealing with a conventional poisoner. I assume we are not given its chuuni name
Also, I should have a double vote, so VTL Thoth to prove it.
I know you're traveling Rex but can we get a vote count
Great breakdown, tyvm
I'd like to hear some input from Vader but so far I'm in agreement with your POE
Shining said the Poisoner specifically visited him
Yeah my brain isn't braining
I really need to read back through this DP cuz I'm falling behind too, but it is just so tempting to crash for the day... games, TV, a little Dungeon Crawler Carl.
At this point I'm townreading Shining. Wylted's claim supports his role and no one is CCing his Empress claim. I'm totally baffled by the similar passives. If I'm townreading Shining I kind of have to townread Wylted as well.
Pie and whiteflame are null to me, with Pie being null-by-suswest. No one will know what I mean by that, I don't know why I said it. Based on his reads and analysis I think I'm townreading Lunatic. Mago I've already decided was town.
So that leaves Banana, awesome5000, Thoth, with Pie and whiteflame in the maybe's.
Can you explain your POE to me
Here’s the issue. Shining says the Poisoner visited him. Mago is saying the Poisoner visited him. If both are town, we’re missing a very important piece of puzzle.
If someone redirected the poisoner, Shining would see a visit but Magoroth would be poisoned.
So I was right, you're the Empress
Do you win with town?
The Google doc claims list has totally spoiled me, I am dependent on it now
What are your characters and what are the justifications for them?
Idk if you're just really busy at work but you seem like you're not keeping up as much as you normally do. No idea whether to scumread it or not
We're like Ghost Hunters rn running around with our EMF equipment trying to capture an awesome5000 sighting, can you please give us a little bit more dude
Why did you give whiteflame favor and why do you regret it
My fellow bitches and hos, I'd have to be dumber than shit to CC Shining as scum.
I would like for anyone to tell me if there are more possibilities than:
Obviously I know #3 isn't the case, but I see no alternative to 1 and 2.
You confirm you received favor last night then
I thought women never farted!
Doesn't count when you're approximately as feminine as Toph Beifong.
So, re: Shining
Wylted has claimed Miller and Shining is the only claimed Cop; no one has CC'd him. The only way I see Shining could therefore be lying is if the real Cop doesn't want to CC or both Wylted and Shining are scum, and I don't see that.
So I will Unvote Shining unless someone shows me a flaw in my reasoning here. The issue of our identical roles remains unresolved but I can't rationalize a VTL against him rn until I've figured more out.
Leaving aside her info, something about Wryly has seemed off this game to me. Shining feels shiny. Not enough to go off of.
You've been saying this since DP1 and I still got no idea what you mean, nor is there really much here to even mount an argument against, so I'mma just gently let a fart in your direction -- it too is just a waft of stinky air with nothing to it.
jk jk I've never weaponized a fart except at family, who really have it coming if they're being honest with themselves
Well share with the class and I'll address it tomorrow. For now headed toward my sleep routine of Rick and Morty > TikTok > fall asleep with phone in hand > hear a thud as it slides onto floor > jolt awake put it back on the table > finally fall asleep properly > IS IT HEALTHY NO DOES IT WORK YES
I’m turning into a conspiracy theorist and I don’t like it
When you've made a big board on your wall with pics and newspaper clippings connected with red string you know you've gone too far, my therapist the lizard man in a mask said