Banana

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 11/7/2026 at 11:07 AM (post #67)

Originally Posted by Banana on 11/7/2026 at 11:45 AM (post #64)

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 11/7/2026 at 10:42 AM (post #63)

Originally Posted by Banana on 11/6/2026 at 11:59 PM (post #26)

maybe i am barking up the wrong tree here. did anyone else think whiteflames post 2 was a strong case for him being a pr?

Nah not in post 2

u think helz was tmi there too?

I don’t think it’s TMI. Different people can read the same thing and come to different conclusions

who do u scum read then?

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 11/7/2026 at 10:42 AM (post #63)

Originally Posted by Banana on 11/6/2026 at 11:59 PM (post #26)

maybe i am barking up the wrong tree here. did anyone else think whiteflames post 2 was a strong case for him being a pr?

Nah not in post 2

u think helz was tmi there too?

Originally Posted by wylted on 11/7/2026 at 7:17 AM (post #55)

somebody give me a post count of everyone up until this point in page 2.

wryly- 79

wylted- 39

thoth- 39

wf- 34

banana-32

pie- 24

helz- 22

rex- 19

mago- 10

Originally Posted by Helz on 11/7/2026 at 1:12 AM (post #47)

Side question for others- Do scum typically get a list of whats possible on this site?

i dont think so

Originally Posted by Helz on 11/7/2026 at 1:04 AM (post #43)

Originally Posted by Banana on 11/7/2026 at 1:57 AM (post #41)

Originally Posted by Helz on 11/7/2026 at 12:38 AM (post #38)

Maybe. I just have very limited time. Will be gone for like the next 24 hours and I am not happy with how the game is going. I want to shove somewhere and get this rolling so we do not have another apathetic D1. I will remind everyone that a no-lynch gives the town another day as well. While I really think I am onto something with Wryly / Banana I do think we should consider this before just fumbling down some road because there is no better option which looks like how D1 went.

so your theory behind me and wryly being a scum team is blatant teaming and not even trying to hide it? also u realize neither of us voted you right? i just pointed out something that seemed suspicious to me is all, wasnt an iron clad case. ur reaction to it is more suspicious than the initial thing ever was. also neither of us even voted you and wrylys comment on it was way lesser than mine, she more or less admitted only that she didnt see the "power role" thing either. you painting us as a scum team over that just seems a bit over reactionary to me.

You are either reading what I said poorly or I said things poorly. I literally argued that you are not W/W and that you are likely T/W. May want to go back and revisit my words.

"To overexplain again (just doing my challenge) if a S! Banana and S! Wryly were teamed and they were in a D2 where they could win D3 after shoving a hammer such an aligned push this early makes little sense. If I was scum I would basically shut the fuck up and let the game be dead right now. Much less coordinate a push with my team mate."

maybe i misread but thats the part i thought you were saying we were scum paired

Originally Posted by Helz on 11/7/2026 at 12:38 AM (post #38)

Maybe. I just have very limited time. Will be gone for like the next 24 hours and I am not happy with how the game is going. I want to shove somewhere and get this rolling so we do not have another apathetic D1. I will remind everyone that a no-lynch gives the town another day as well. While I really think I am onto something with Wryly / Banana I do think we should consider this before just fumbling down some road because there is no better option which looks like how D1 went.

so your theory behind me and wryly being a scum team is blatant teaming and not even trying to hide it? also u realize neither of us voted you right? i just pointed out something that seemed suspicious to me is all, wasnt an iron clad case. ur reaction to it is more suspicious than the initial thing ever was. also neither of us even voted you and wrylys comment on it was way lesser than mine, she more or less admitted only that she didnt see the "power role" thing either. you painting us as a scum team over that just seems a bit over reactionary to me.

helz seems a bit over defensive and omgussy for my taste. hmm will have to think on this. im willing to wait for more ppl to chime in tho, interested in seeing if anyone else thinks that wf was an obvious pr from that statement.

Originally Posted by Helz on 11/6/2026 at 11:19 PM (post #28)

I am not sure what else someone could have taken other than they are a PR. If I was scum it would have motivated me to kill them but putting on a scum hat to break down what I would think; them being some PR would be a lesser focus because a critical role would be more subtle at their skill level. They eneded up being a potentially damaging role to town but I figured someone would recognize the openly voiced claim there.

Like, they were obviously outing themselves to the point I would have been paranoid that they were a vet/pgo or something if I was scum. The scum taking that kill shows either ignorance on their part reading players as well as reading the collective opinion of the town or it suggest they had some way to ensure their move went through.

We should circle back to WF's reads. They were open in their thoughts.

that seems like a pretty big leap, and im struggling to find why town would look into something like that as much as scum would

i think in general, scum have more incentive to be looking into stuff like that and sussing out who is softing power roles also. i dont see much of a reason town would look into that statement by wf...

maybe i am barking up the wrong tree here. did anyone else think whiteflames post 2 was a strong case for him being a pr?

Originally Posted by Helz on 11/6/2026 at 10:55 PM (post #23)

Originally Posted by Banana on 11/6/2026 at 11:51 PM (post #20)

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 11/6/2026 at 10:39 PM (post #19)

The Whiteflame kill is very interesting. I’m curious what everyone thinks about why. I have my own theories

i was just wondering about it.

few options come to mind. 1stoption is the simplest, that he was a fear kill since hes known to be a good playr. 2nd is that they thought he was a power role. the only real hint i can see of why they would think that is he was resistant to wanting the mass claim in his response to wrylys pro con list. the 3rd is more consipiracy based and revolves around one or both of mago or wylted potentially being scum, since he had fos'ed both at one point. if either felt he was a threat they would have incntive to carry the night kill on him.

D1 Post #2 they basically outed as some kinda pr. I doubt I was the only person to notice this. They were not even slightly subtle about it.

i mean all he really said was that his character didn't match his role, idk if that is something that would be interpreted widely as him hinting a pr. but ur thought about that is interesting. almost makes me wonder if its tmi though and provides u with a motive to kill him...

Originally Posted by Wryly on 11/6/2026 at 6:40 PM (post #15)

Originally Posted by wylted on 11/6/2026 at 8:07 PM (post #11)

rex is town otherwise he would have fell for that.

who we lynching.

let's determine who is least white and move on from the. everyone post feet pics of themselves

It was a transparent reaction test my dude, you've done it before. Anyway, it should be Pie obviously, scum would've NK'd him first if he was town.

VTL: ILikePie5

i dont buy agree “scum would nk pie first if he was town”. scum nk prs and strong readers, not whoever looks most town. also i dont think pie looked very town from last dp, again he was just chasing low hanging fruit in thoth. in other words pie could be scum, but probably not for the reason of not being the nk

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 11/6/2026 at 12:09 PM (post #3)

Sorry about my complete inactivity, was fucked by work. Will be home today ad tomorrow so I will have time to participate

what are ur thoughts on the events of last day phase? what did you think of the thoth lynch? who would you have lynched if u were on last dp?

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 11/6/2026 at 10:39 PM (post #19)

The Whiteflame kill is very interesting. I’m curious what everyone thinks about why. I have my own theories

i was just wondering about it.

few options come to mind. 1stoption is the simplest, that he was a fear kill since hes known to be a good playr. 2nd is that they thought he was a power role. the only real hint i can see of why they would think that is he was resistant to wanting the mass claim in his response to wrylys pro con list. the 3rd is more consipiracy based and revolves around one or both of mago or wylted potentially being scum, since he had fos'ed both at one point. if either felt he was a threat they would have incntive to carry the night kill on him.

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 11/5/2026 at 7:58 AM (post #233)

Originally Posted by Banana on 11/5/2026 at 1:44 AM (post #220)

VTL: Magoroth

lack of activity

So is the entire basis for lynching him a lack of activity?

why would he get a pass for it when others dont? thoth at least claimed. idk neither are ideal lynches

Originally Posted by RexFavilla on 11/5/2026 at 6:18 AM (post #225)

Originally Posted by Banana on 11/5/2026 at 7:30 AM (post #223)

Banana is starting to ping me more. Usually my thoughts line up with theirs very well and while I am not looking as deep as normal I am seeing points I do not understand. Its from memory and a gut read so not worth much but they just feel different to me in that I am not constantly reading their words and thinking I could have been the one to say them. The mind meld is just not here this game.

what specifically u talking about.?? i think my only major opinion so far is that the thoth wagon seems like lowing hanging fruit.

Couple hours left boo who we gunna lynch together <3

magoroth?

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 11/5/2026 at 6:57 AM (post #228)

We have 4 hours left folks. Thoth hasn’t even attempted to scum hunt. He’s basically resigned. Town Thoth would push back on me

isnt thoth always kind of inactive? he been mislynched a few times for that

Banana is starting to ping me more. Usually my thoughts line up with theirs very well and while I am not looking as deep as normal I am seeing points I do not understand. Its from memory and a gut read so not worth much but they just feel different to me in that I am not constantly reading their words and thinking I could have been the one to say them. The mind meld is just not here this game.

what specifically u talking about.?? i think my only major opinion so far is that the thoth wagon seems like lowing hanging fruit.

VTL: Magoroth

lack of activity

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 11/4/2026 at 10:24 PM (post #216)

Originally Posted by Banana on 11/4/2026 at 8:34 PM (post #206)

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 11/4/2026 at 7:17 PM (post #202)

Originally Posted by Banana on 11/4/2026 at 8:13 PM (post #200)

yeah on second thought i dont think thoth would claim bus driver like that hmm

He’s claimed various outlandish stuff before if my memory serves correct

yeah but bus driver isnt outlandish, its straight a scum role. by outlandish i would think maybe some off kilter role that he thought would be obscure. do u think bus driver is in that category

It’s not a straight scum role. People including myself have used it as a town role. But think of it this way. What’s the point of Luna giving town a Bus Driver, especially when significantly more often than not, it’s going to harm town. The logical option for a Town BD would be to just waive till later in the game. It has massive utility for scum.

he did mention he could waive. and the point of giving town these roles is for potential mislynches

mago i mean rex claimed miller already i think

Originally Posted by Wryly on 11/4/2026 at 7:48 PM (post #210)

Ah, Pie already said like Masons for instance. Hadn't reread that far.

Aside from Rex and Thoth, basically all I have to go on for anyone else is vibes, and I really hate going on vibes. I always sus whiteflame and Pie, so I don't trust my gut on either of them. There's not much to go on for Helz or Mago, and wylted is eh. I have a good feeling about Nana but I always have a good feeling about Nana.

rex and hhelz are pretty inactive we could push for one of them to post since dp1 ends tomorrow

Originally Posted by Wryly on 11/4/2026 at 6:58 PM (post #197)

We should get a counter-wagon started. Who's everyone second sus?

pies reads are starting to sus me a bit, they dont make a lot of sense

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 11/4/2026 at 7:17 PM (post #202)

Originally Posted by Banana on 11/4/2026 at 8:13 PM (post #200)

yeah on second thought i dont think thoth would claim bus driver like that hmm

He’s claimed various outlandish stuff before if my memory serves correct

yeah but bus driver isnt outlandish, its straight a scum role. by outlandish i would think maybe some off kilter role that he thought would be obscure. do u think bus driver is in that category

yeah on second thought i dont think thoth would claim bus driver like that hmm

Originally Posted by Wryly on 11/4/2026 at 3:48 PM (post #189)

Lunaric just confirmed to me that scum were given no fake role claims.

i assumed as much or he would have said in op

also i find it ironic if we end up voting thoth for his role but on the same end of the spectrum acklowedge him and his strategy of mass role claiming. because while im not a fan of his role i have to admit that it doesnt help him to suggest a mass role claim when he has a role like that

Originally Posted by wylted on 11/4/2026 at 1:40 PM (post #165)

I wouldn't put it past lunatic to make busdriver a town role, but that and miller seems to be going overboard.

well if its a scum role this would be a good argumnet for why the mass claim is a bad idea. i think thoth is prolly lying tho so i am not saying it is, but we should be pretty sure about it because if we think scummy roles could be town then we are shooting ourselves in the foot with a mass claim.

ok caught up. reads since wryly asked me twice lol

thoth: scum lean. the bus driver claim is the main thing. wf and wryly both said its mostly been a scum role here, and rex’s point that a town bd makes a game this small crazy swingy makes it feel even less likely. he also pushed the mass claim then dodged claiming for like a day, no breadcrumbs like wf said, and the timing being outside his normal hours is odd. his rex read also went from “blatant TMI” to moderately sus to soft sus which is weird

wylted: slight scum but less than i thought. he jumped on the mass claim fast then went after thoth for suggesting it, wf already covered that. my vibes vote on him was weak tbh, i dont have a real case

wryly: slight town. most active and the miller reasoning holds up for me.

rex: town lean. miller claim is risky for scum and the phone thing is too random to be a lie. also he put me at slight scum with zero reasoning so thats a null on that read from me lol

whiteflame: town lean. reads are thorough and consistent

helz: slight town. the wryly read was stretchy tho, wf explained why the site meta argument is fine

pie: null. opportunistic on thoth but thats just pie

mago: null. barely posted but hes tired and asked for a catch up so ill give him that

UNVOTE

well dp ends tomorrow so if were doing the mass claim thing we should do soon