ILikePie5

Welcome to State Attorneys General Mafia. This game is based off of the incumbent Attorneys General of the 50 States, and it is in honor of the best Attorney General in the nation: Ken Paxton (the future junior Senator from Texas). Each of you is an Attorney General from one of the 50 States.

There is a theme split in this game. Mafia will be given the opportunity to ask about 2 characters and 2 roles in the game or any combination such that it equals 4 questions. I will truthfully answer whether they are in the game or not. I will answer any and all questions. Be warned though, sometimes the way I interpret your question may be different than you do. Please try to be as specific as possible in your inquiries. It also goes without saying that my answers are purely HYPOTHETICAL and you shouldn’t rely on them for Catch-22s.

Just some quick rules:

1) No editing or deleting posts of any kinds

2) No copy/pasting your role PM (please paraphrase)

3) No cryptography of any kind

4) No communication outside of the mafia game

5) No liking/upvoting posts after you die

6) No using ChatGPT/AI to paraphrase your PM

7) Votes will be locked on MYLO/LYLO

I reserve the right to add any other rules that are commonplace that I may have forgotten to list.

If you have any questions, please PM me directly. Also, PM me if you would like a vote count at any point in time, though I will try to be proactive in posting counts. All DPs will be 72 hours and NPs 24 hours unless the NP ends with everyone submitting actions earlier.

Remaining Players:

1. Whiteflame

2. Noah

3. Lunatic

4. Wylted

5. Banana

6. REF

7. Thoth

8. Magoroth

9. Kohai

With 9 players alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch. This DP will end Thursday October 22nd at 10:30pm CST. Let the game begin.

PMs going out now

1. Wf

2. Kohai 

3. Noah 

4. Magoroth

5. Lunatic 

6. Thoth

7. Banana

8 Wylted

9 REF

One more person

Can you change the title to State Attorneys General please?

1. Wf

2. Kohai 

3. Noah 

4. Magoroth

5. Lunatic 

6. Thoth

7. Banana

8

9

10

11

12

1. Wf

2. Kohai 

3. Noah 

4. Magoroth

5. Lunatic 

6. Thoth

7

8

9

10

11

12

Originally Posted by Thoth on 10/14/2026 at 1:21 PM (post #12)

I did not know states had their own AGs

bruh

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 10/14/2026 at 9:53 AM (post #4)

Everyone will be an Attorney General from one of the fifty states as of 10/14/2026. Everyone will be an element.

We get to be Attorneys General and elements? Sign me up!

I love copy pasta lol

Join

join

In honor of the best Attorney General in the nation, now running for U.S. Senator from my home state of Texas.

Everyone will be an Attorney General from one of the fifty states as of 10/14/2026. Everyone will be an element. There will be a theme split. Scum will be able to ask about 2 roles and 2 characters for a total of 4 questions, to which I will truthfully answer if they exist in the game or not.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

11.

12.

Originally Posted by Banana on 10/2/2026 at 9:46 PM (post #21)

awe you guys killed me :/

Sorry :/ we thought you were a PR with what you softed

Originally Posted by JenKiggans2026 on 10/2/2026 at 10:15 AM (post #19)

I honestly don't know. VA is such a swing state it's impossible to call it. I didn't think Spanberger would win but she did. Before that I thought there was no way our boy Youngkin would win but he did and was a great governor. I'm not going to get my hopes up but I think Jen has a good chance. If she was a man, we'd be cooked tho.

Its a military district, so hopefully some of Hegseth’s successes help out, but rich white liberals are insane

Originally Posted by JenKiggans2026 on 10/1/2026 at 4:56 PM (post #17)

I didn't even reply directly to the comment smh

on a side note, do you actually think Kiggans is going to win?

Can’t play cause I helped Savant balance the game jfyi

Current Games:

None

Sign-ups:

None

In the Hopper:

Savant - Epstein Island 

Mikal - re zero

Pie

Lunatic

Helz

Rex - Female rappers

Magoroth - Standoff Mafia

Thoth - TBD

Kohai - TBD

Whiteflame - Dungeon Crawler Carl

On Hold:

Wylted - Lulsec

Mag1cman

Casey_Risk

Shining

Originally Posted by Kohai on 9/29/2026 at 11:17 AM (post #222)

Fun fact: I totally lied about my justification

Apocalypse mafia Town Kohai - Zombie apocalypse - zombie apocalypses aren't actually that scary, Shaun of the Dead is the best depiction of zombies, they die so easy we'd probably make them pets. You are the stump. After you die you turn into a stump; as stump you may still talk, including at night, but you don't count toward the game and you can't vote.

Ya that lie saved tou

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 9/29/2026 at 8:46 AM (post #201)

Fwiw, even if we had lynched Pie correctly this DP, there was no way I was lynching Luna next DP. I had assumed one of you had to be real with Vader's Miller claim. You guys had our number.

Ya that was the backup. As long as I wasn’t lynched, we had it in the bag. Me flipping Lawyer and Luna not dying would’ve outted him

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 9/29/2026 at 8:44 AM (post #199)

Originally Posted by Lunatic on 9/29/2026 at 9:43 AM (post #198)

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 9/29/2026 at 7:40 AM (post #196)

Lol, was it seriously Luna/Pie? Did not see that coming.

Yeah lol. I got the whiteflame curse. 3x scum in a row :/

Crazy. Someone's going to have to explain to me how we rolled a Miller this game because, as far as I can tell, there is no role that's affected by it.

Has to be the case cause Dreamer was the fake role

VTL Kohai

Originally Posted by Lunatic on 9/28/2026 at 4:13 PM (post #165)

I've gone back through the Pie/Kohai stuff and I keep coming back to the same thing: I think these two could very easily be partners.

The DP1 fight looks way better as distancing to me now. Pie jumps on Kohai, Kohai fires right back, and suddenly you've got this nice little "look, we're obviously fighting" dynamic between them. But neither one actually needs to go all the way with it. Pie gets credit for pushing scum, Kohai gets to look like he's defending himself. Pretty fucking convenient.

And look at where we are now. Kohai is sitting on my green while also telling everyone that my green might not mean shit because GF exists. Like... pick one lol. If my result is unreliable, then why are you using it to take yourself out of the POE?

Then he gets to sit there and point at me, Vader, Whiteflame, whatever, while he's basically considered untouchable. That's a hell of a position for scum to be in.

I'm not saying "they fought in DP1, so they're partners." That's lazy as shit. I'm saying the whole progression makes sense if that fight was manufactured separation.

Especially if we lynch pie and if Pie flips scum, Kohai is absolutely the first person I'm looking at. I don't think we should keep giving him a free pass because the checks are convenient for him.

I don’t blame you for bringing this back up. I should’ve listened to Mag1c when he called out your shitty logic. You guys really have no choice besides pushing Kohai/Pie

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 9/28/2026 at 12:14 PM (post #156)

Originally Posted by Vader on 9/28/2026 at 12:50 PM (post #149)

I have to analyze behavior and a lot of different things. I see an argument for either Pie or Whiteflame. I don’t understand why we are letting Kohai just slide the way they are though compared to the other characters

I've said it before that I don't think we should let Kohai slide, he's just not the focus of my attention at this point. Neither are you. My focus is on what I know: there are too many investigative claims and at least one of them (Pie and Luna) is supported by your Miller claim. I have a very hard time believing that both a Dreamer and a Cop exist in this game, but one must, so I'm evaluating which of them is least likely to be real.

As for you and Kohai, I can see an argument for either of you being plausibly paired with Pie, though the case of a pairing with Luna is harder to buy for either of you, at least behaviorally. It's part of the reason I'm sussing Pie more than I am Luna.

Regarding why I saw Kohai as town for as long as I did, that's down to him being my only green check up until this DP. Now that I have one on both you and Kohai, I'm reconsidering my read on him, since both of you have the same evidence for you being town from where I'm sitting. The main difference is the green check from Luna and, if it's a given there's a Miller in this game, then it's probably a given there's a GF or Lawyer on the scum team. Pie's own PM where a Miller was confirmed to him apparently mentions a GF. I can't ignore that.

@Vader

This is just pure waffling. He goes from it’s Vader/Pie or Kohai/Pie to Vader/Pie the because it Vader/Pie or Kohai/Pie.

At this juncture in the game. As town, your job is to find your 2 fellow townies and 2 scum. The record speaks for itself. Pie constantly protecting you and preventing you from getting lynched or WF who has been on you 2 days in a row

Originally Posted by Kohai on 9/28/2026 at 2:32 PM (post #158)

A bit over 24 hours left.

Im heavily leaning towards WF right now. Would like to hear where Vader’s head is at before voting.

Where are you at right?

Originally Posted by Vader on 9/28/2026 at 11:50 AM (post #149)

I have to analyze behavior and a lot of different things. I see an argument for either Pie or Whiteflame. I don’t understand why we are letting Kohai just slide the way they are though compared to the other characters

Kohai was double cleared by both Luna and WF. Only way he’s scum is if he’s exactly the godfather/lawyer. That’s hard for them to justify as scum. The idea likely was to get Kohai to join them to vote Pie or Vader, but Vader blew that up with his observation regarding Mag1c’s PM. Thats why you see the shift

Originally Posted by Vader on 9/28/2026 at 11:46 AM (post #147)

I’m honestly thrown for a loop. The Bears play tonight so trying to read through the progressions

WF is literally calling Pie/Vader as basically his top scum pairing. He was pushing you yesterday and today. You know you’re town, so Pie/Vader is never a scum line from your POV.

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 9/28/2026 at 11:34 AM (post #144)

People can feel free to read through Pie’s progression for themselves. It does not read like someone who became aware that Vader was effectively townlocked by the mod early in the DP. It reads like someone who thought there could be a Miller based on his PM, second-guessed it several times, and only came in for the final 30 minutes to argue that a Miller was effectively mid-confirmed to be in the game by his PM.

Seriously, don’t take my word for it. Read through his progression on Vader last DP. ISO him yourselves. See how that sits with you.

This is just wrong. I said Vader2 was likely town based on my PM. Then #204 that WF is saying shows I “sussed” Vader2 is just wrong. That post was in response to Mag1c where I was explaining why Thoth being Vanilla made no sense.

And then at the end, I said I’ll lynch for info but I townread him. THEN I proceed to continue pushing Thoth. So to say that Pie “sussed” Vader2 is just demonstrably wrong.

I agree with him though — go read my responses to Mag1c regarding Thoth.

95% sure that WF is scum with that last post. He’s just straight up misrepresenting what I’ve said and done

Originally Posted by whiteflame on 9/28/2026 at 10:39 AM (post #141)

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 9/28/2026 at 11:00 AM (post #139)

I didn't say you'd complain. You'd be making a huge fucking deal in the DP if attention was put on Vader. I did notice that you mentioned Vader was likely town based on your PM earlier in the DP, but it was a long while after that and a lot of sus directed at Vader before you made the point adamantly. - WF

Read this post. He’s saying I would’ve made a big deal if Vader2 was ever going to be lynched. But I did bring the attention away from Vader2 by saying he’s likely town based on my PM very early on

And then again at the end of DP2, I diverted back to Thoth from Vader2. My Thoth read was wrong, I’ll admit that, but saying I didn’t protect my townread enough is wild.

So let's ISO how you progressed through DP2 on this.

In post 53, you said:

I think he’s town because of something in my PM, unless Bullish is a troll and specifically gave Miller as the fake claim

That indicated that you had asked something about the Miller affecting your role. I'll also note that you were lending some credence to the possibility of Miller being a fake claim here, a point you've since called me out for arguing was a possibility. Then, in post 204, you said this:

Not asked. Miller was specifically stated in my PM.

You can’t do anything about vaccum decay either, but that’s a Miller. There’s an inconsistency

That was just the second time you'd mentioned the Miller last DP and despite evidence from your own PM suggesting there was a Miller, you were sussing his justification. You once again called out the possibility of a Miller fake claim in 231. The next and last time you mentioned it was after he reached L-1 in post 322:

No no no. This is 100% misleading. I was comparing Thoth being Vanilla vs Vader2 being Miller to justify how Thoth being Vanilla doesn’t make sense. I was NOT sussing him at any point.

My role implies a Miller exists. It’s not traditionally how the role works, but Bullish made a point to mention it. I’ll hammer him to get a lynch off for information, but know that I townread him

Yes. And then I diverted to Thoth. You spearheaded the Vader2 wagon, not me. I’ve always supported lynches for information.

So, no, I wouldn't say you were at all consistent in supporting a townread on Vader despite information that's apparently just written directly into your justification. You waffled all over the DP about it until he became one of the lead lynch wagons. I've already admitted that you mentioned the PM support early in the DP, but given what you apparently had mod confirmed to you last DP and your apparent certainty now, it's beyond me why you weren't this adamant last DP.

I was adamant? I literally changed the lynch to Thoth in the last 30 minutes lmao. You’re literally misrepresenting my words and my actions.

I didn't say you'd complain. You'd be making a huge fucking deal in the DP if attention was put on Vader. I did notice that you mentioned Vader was likely town based on your PM earlier in the DP, but it was a long while after that and a lot of sus directed at Vader before you made the point adamantly. - WF

Read this post. He’s saying I would’ve made a big deal if Vader2 was ever going to be lynched. But I did bring the attention away from Vader2 by saying he’s likely town based on my PM very early on

And then again at the end of DP2, I diverted back to Thoth from Vader2. My Thoth read was wrong, I’ll admit that, but saying I didn’t protect my townread enough is wild.