Guild leaders wont test it? Why not?
tl;dr it accomplishes the same thing as just lynching him. If we succesfully recruit him we find out he is scum. If that happens whatever person recruited him is an automatic disadvantage against the other guild, since we need to be the biggest faction AND kill scum to win. If we need to get a lynch anyway, it just makes more sense for that person to be thoth. It gives us a lot of information from associative tells and will heavily implicate alyssa if he's scum, and if hes town its not the end of the world, its not like a mislynch dp1 is extremely uncommon. There is at least a lot of support both behavioral and mechanic going into thoths lynch, its not like we are doing it blindly.


