Lunatic's avatar

Lunatic

Community Contributor

Member since

Lunatic

I kind of don’t understand the reason for you holding out on outing you a caroler, you may have been over valuing your results a bit. Regardless I am glad you did because it could have saved wryly. Also it explains your town read on her so I can give you a bit of a pass for defending her now

Lunatic
WAIT
I’m so fucking sorry. I meant bulletproof not commuter. I was night immune last night, and I did indeed receive a roleblock message. I’m fucking retarded.

lmao



vtl mago





Lunatic
What if Wryly flips town here?

Probably you or shining, I’m not really sure. Kind of hard to answer since I currently town read so many people, so will have to play it by ear

Lunatic

Wryly/mago or wryly/rex, idk about ref based on the minor character thing but mago has the worst justification for his role and I don’t really like the role with a roleblocker, ascetic add a bomb its just chaos. Also both mago and Rex have been supportive of her so I can see either being her scum partner by association.

Lunatic

Yeah this is basically the same logic I already pointed out earlier. My brain can’t think of a way this makes sense unless we buy into the third party theory, but I just don’t know why that would be more believable then… wryly just being scum. You’d have to buy into a lot of wifom to think wryly is town here. Idk if she is town I’m gonna feel like a real prick, especially after she didn’t lynch me for wifom in lylo last game. But my brain just can’t wrap my head around the third party thing

Lunatic

Come on Rex don’t act like you don’t know why wryly is under suspicion here. Not gonna repeat it for the fiftieth time though, if you don’t wanna read then that’s on you. If she flips scum though I’m keeping tabs on all those who defended her

Lunatic

At the end of the day we still have no caroler claim and to buy all that wifom relies on us buying a third party conspiracy over a classic “looks like scum made a mistake” which does happen literally all the time.


If roles are reversed here what do you make of this situation, how do you treat it? You’re making great arguments and if your town I honestly feel bad for you but you have to understand the position you are in based on the circumstances. Your asking me to buy “I would never do this that and the other thing” over “scum made an oopsie poopsie” and I haven’t seen enough of your scum games to necessarily buy all of that wifom yet. No offense, and again I hope you don’t think I’m calling you bad or anything by suggesting you could be scum and made a mistake. Everyone makes mistakes. Everyone has those days, a great Miley Cyrus once said

Lunatic
I'm fine with it but baffled by what you imagine the scum slip even was. Confusing what a Carol is?


Or you claimed the carol results before talking to your partner, or your partner dropped the ball and forgot they were supposed to claim caroler, or you didn’t account for a mass claim and hoped people would lynch within the results before ever claiming, I mean you likely would have only needed two more mislynches and the results account for three. Multiple possibilities that make more sense than a 3rd party maybe existing and taking a Hail Mary play to take out a town player instead of getting free town cred.

Lunatic

Also I am just not worried about a third party. If they can’t joint win then it’s not balanced, but I see no reason they wouldn’t just try and win with town anyway.

Lunatic

Yall are placing way too much stock in this third party theory. Like sure it’s possible but it seems more likely that she just scum slipped imo. It happens. She’s not a bad player or anything, mistakes happen. Maybe her partner was supposed to claim it and forgot or they weren’t in to coordinate during the mass claim. Who knows. I feel like this would result in a lynch on basically anyone else this happened too though. If she’s town then we can lynch in those carol results but we should have a lot more POE going into next day phase as well as results and confirmables anyway. This is a pretty safe lynch imo

Lunatic
Cause to win, they gotta avoid being NKed 

yeah but with a mass claim we have several other power roles on the table I don’t think the Caroler is the riskiest role for them to kill here. Idk man are you actually buying this?