Magoroth

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 31/08/2026 at 3:04 (post #703)

Originally Posted by wylted on 8/30/2026 at 7:50 PM (post #687)

Let me confirm myself today with Mago’s role. I’ll hammer today. If votes are anonymous tomorrow instalynch me.

I'm open to it. How does his role work again? Or can you link me to the post?

Yes. He stated that if scum hammer or NK him, then the vote tomorrow will be anonymous (ie we will all have to submit votes to Banana).

He didn’t state the name of the role. I’ve never heard of this role.

https://www.debatecraft.com/mafia/c/active-games/posts/83/from-mafia---day-2?commentId=6a934a18ed2d92476e465ab3

Here’s the post.

I said LEADER. I’m sorry Banana chose to make up crazy role cards that are hard to parse for the average person. It’s just title case “LEADER” above “Donna Raines”.

Finding the last Mafia is gonna be wild.

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 30/08/2026 at 17:23 (post #613)

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/30/2026 at 10:17 AM (post #612)

I was speaking hypothetically, setup spec. It’s not a balanced setup because scum can disable two of the town’s investigative roles and they have a Yakuza on top of everything.

If you want to resort to balance arguments, go for it cause this is Banana’s second game. First game she got Mag1c to help her. I don’t think she got anyone this time. But just having a Framer and a Yakuza is not OP for scum against a Watcher, Cop, and Doctor in any scenario

I don’t think she would do this. I do pretty crazy setups with deception and shit and even I would think twice about doing this unless it was a dedicated setup and I warned ppl in advance things could get hairy which she didn’t say lol

I mean not alienating people is one thing but why do you not even suspect Luna/Thoth as evils lol

I was speaking hypothetically, setup spec. It’s not a balanced setup because scum can disable two of the town’s investigative roles and they have a Yakuza on top of everything.

Also no, common sense says you’re scum, you’re acting like defeated scum and your response to Lunatic/Thoth indicates you’re not even scumreading them which is very strange for someone who’s been scumread the whole game.

And honestly that’s ignoring everything else I said about you which you didn’t even address

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 30/08/2026 at 16:59 (post #607)

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/30/2026 at 9:52 AM (post #605)

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 30/08/2026 at 16:44 (post #603)

Originally Posted by Thoth on 8/30/2026 at 1:14 AM (post #579)

Jokes aside, I think this day phase is now old enough that I can legally flip it on its back and raw-dog it.

I am Dani Acosta, Methodical Cop. Justification is that Dani Acosta is methodical and a cop. I submitted a list of players before the end of day 1. Each night, I cop the highest player on the list, skipping dead players, including anyone who dies that night.

I would rather not post my list to stop scum from interfering on the off chance I survive this day phase, but Pie was my first choice and I got a guilty result on him last night. Any defenses I made of him or suggestions we move to someone else were reaction tests.

VTL: ILikePie5

I was the obvious frame target lol. Retarded selection on your part. Wryly, I get cause she’s a noob, but you’ve played forever. You never investigate the scummiest person.

So scum has a Yakuza AND a Framer? And town has a Miller? I don’t believe any of this shit there’s no way anyone does

Town has a Watcher, Cop, Doctor. That combo is brutal. And scum always have a counter to a Cop. Always, whether it’s GF, Lawyer, or Framer. Common sense is to frame me

What if they take the Watcher out by converting him. Then all Town investigates become useless because Watcher can find power roles like the Doctor and shit and Framer frames ppl 24/7. This is not balanced lol

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 30/08/2026 at 16:44 (post #603)

Originally Posted by Thoth on 8/30/2026 at 1:14 AM (post #579)

Jokes aside, I think this day phase is now old enough that I can legally flip it on its back and raw-dog it.

I am Dani Acosta, Methodical Cop. Justification is that Dani Acosta is methodical and a cop. I submitted a list of players before the end of day 1. Each night, I cop the highest player on the list, skipping dead players, including anyone who dies that night.

I would rather not post my list to stop scum from interfering on the off chance I survive this day phase, but Pie was my first choice and I got a guilty result on him last night. Any defenses I made of him or suggestions we move to someone else were reaction tests.

VTL: ILikePie5

I was the obvious frame target lol. Retarded selection on your part. Wryly, I get cause she’s a noob, but you’ve played forever. You never investigate the scummiest person.

So scum has a Yakuza AND a Framer? And town has a Miller? I don’t believe any of this shit there’s no way anyone does

Feels kinda sad knowing the entire original scum will be dead by EoD2, and yet some poor nigga is scum now and coulda won with us lol

Originally Posted by Thoth on 30/08/2026 at 3:52 (post #568)

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 8/29/2026 at 8:42 PM (post #567)

Okay, that means he was telling the truth about having a confirmable role, which explains the NK.

You're waiting for me to answer your question and then agreeing with me about this very obvious game fact, as though I am the authority on how Mafia works? This is so out-of-character for you that it's painful.

I don’t think this is staged. I can’t see Thoth as scum lol

Is anyone around?

Also if I was scum I would Yakuza Lunatic probably. Only person who didnt scunread me yesterday so any defense wouldnt look out of place

There is an exchange somewhere today where Pie tells Thoth he sucks at endgaming bc he would 1v1 him as town and he would lose. In light of Thoths reveal this looks like real frustration at being scum and not being able to do this on Pie’s, which makes Thoth effectively confirmed Town.

I think Wylted is scummiest, I abandon what I said ab Mac1cman. Followed by IMO Mikal for basically stating he wanted to confirm himself noe that Yakuza is dead. This is the type of fake derp he drops as scum. Ofc its also possible its a genuinr mistale, idk how Yakuza works in general.

Lunatic is also a possibility due to how subdued Pie’s responses are to Lunatic, but it looks like Lunatic has no issues talking to pie, its a one sided thing

what I’ll say is, if Pie is actually telling the truth about Mag1cman being his top town read and its not just bullshit, Mag1c might be the one he sent Kohai to recruit yesterday

So yeah my preference is Wylted, Mikal, Mag1c and then Luna; pie goes today obviously

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 29/08/2026 at 8:43 (post #475)

Originally Posted by Lunatic on 8/28/2026 at 8:18 PM (post #441)

Pies been convienently absent so far lmao

Whatever helps you sleep at night.

This shit looks staged.

Originally Posted by Thoth on 30/08/2026 at 8:50 (post #591)

I think that Pie is probably original scum based on his behavior staying the same from last day phase to this day phase.

Fair enough

I’m a bit scared the Yakuza isn’t one-shot and we can’t actually win this game unless we kill the new Yakuza. Like Yakuza’d person keeps original abilities but what if they gain the Yakuza ability too lmao

Originally Posted by Thoth on 30/08/2026 at 8:48 (post #588)

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/30/2026 at 1:46 AM (post #587)

Honestly I wanted to avoid claiming on DP1 cause I thought scum making votes anonymous would be really OP at MyLo, but I asked Banana a bunch of questions and basically she will provide vote counts on request, so all Town has to do is publicly declare who they will vote for and hold off on voting until they reach a consensus

vote counts meaning the number of votes only?

Yes

Originally Posted by Thoth on 30/08/2026 at 8:44 (post #586)

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/30/2026 at 1:43 AM (post #584)

Also have you asked Banana about the order of operations? Would really help tell us if Pie was converted last night or if he started the game as team scum

I asked Banana if Pie would register as guilty if he were Yakuza'd, and she answered that Pie would register as guilty whether he were original or converted scum.

I mean hosts like to interpret this stuff the way they want, could be a truism or it could be what you really wanted answered. I’ll ask her too.

I’m just thinking, if the conversion happened after your check then you wouldn’t spot a convertee.

Originally Posted by Thoth on 30/08/2026 at 8:43 (post #585)

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/30/2026 at 1:41 AM (post #581)

Question is do they kill me or do they kill you tonight. Town feels kinda stacked what kinda abilities does scum have? Other than Yakuza which is one-shot

The only way they don't kill me is if they want to convertedscumpaint me.

Honestly I wanted to avoid claiming on DP1 cause I thought scum making votes anonymous would be really OP at MyLo, but I asked Banana a bunch of questions and basically she will provide vote counts on request, so all Town has to do is publicly declare who they will vote for and hold off on voting until they reach a consensus

Y’all can literally do sth like

VOTE ILikePie5

Originally Posted by Thoth on 30/08/2026 at 8:14 (post #579)

Jokes aside, I think this day phase is now old enough that I can legally flip it on its back and raw-dog it.

I am Dani Acosta, Methodical Cop. Justification is that Dani Acosta is methodical and a cop. I submitted a list of players before the end of day 1. Each night, I cop the highest player on the list, skipping dead players, including anyone who dies that night.

I would rather not post my list to stop scum from interfering on the off chance I survive this day phase, but Pie was my first choice and I got a guilty result on him last night. Any defenses I made of him or suggestions we move to someone else were reaction tests.

VTL: ILikePie5

Also have you asked Banana about the order of operations? Would really help tell us if Pie was converted last night or if he started the game as team scum

VTL: ILikePie5

Originally Posted by Thoth on 30/08/2026 at 8:14 (post #579)

Jokes aside, I think this day phase is now old enough that I can legally flip it on its back and raw-dog it.

I am Dani Acosta, Methodical Cop. Justification is that Dani Acosta is methodical and a cop. I submitted a list of players before the end of day 1. Each night, I cop the highest player on the list, skipping dead players, including anyone who dies that night.

I would rather not post my list to stop scum from interfering on the off chance I survive this day phase, but Pie was my first choice and I got a guilty result on him last night. Any defenses I made of him or suggestions we move to someone else were reaction tests.

VTL: ILikePie5

Nice

Question is do they kill me or do they kill you tonight. Town feels kinda stacked what kinda abilities does scum have? Other than Yakuza which is one-shot

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 30/08/2026 at 2:26 (post #546)

Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/29/2026 at 4:07 PM (post #538)

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 29/08/2026 at 23:06 (post #536)

So how does the voting piece work? If scum hammers you they basically out themselves?

Yes

Whats the name of the role. I don’t think I’ve ever seen it before

I’ll check, but I don’t think I have one unless it’s the TITLE-looking thing above my character’s name, which just says “LEADER"

Originally Posted by ILikePie5 on 29/08/2026 at 23:06 (post #536)

So how does the voting piece work? If scum hammers you they basically out themselves?

Yes

I don’t have a justification. It literally just says people come to me for guidance, “even Boyd”, and I was holding the Town together before Boyd arrived. That’s basically my entire character’s bio.

Then I have an ability that says what I just described

Also my character’s name is Donna Raines

ANYWAY. My claim.

I am the leader of “Colony”. I am female, I will look up my character’s name on request, I can’t be arsed to do it right now.

People come to me for advice

I have the unique ability that, if I die to a nightkill, or if I get voted, if the person who killed me is a member of the Mafia, all votes the following day are anonymous, meaning people have to vote by PMing Banana. You can still tell us who you voted for tho

Although, WHO KNOWS

Like I’d have to.

Though I don’t know how soon

Originally I was supposed to go somewhere

Expect some shit to come soon I got some crap to clear up.

Damn is that all pie could really say?

Interesting