Ok the last is (/s). I haven’t yet decided if a mass claim is something we should do.
I just think, with how weird our roles are, I think it will be hard for scum to even know what questions to ask.
Ok the last is (/s). I haven’t yet decided if a mass claim is something we should do.
I just think, with how weird our roles are, I think it will be hard for scum to even know what questions to ask.
Originally Posted by wylted on 24/10/2026 at 22:46 (post #32)
Why in the hell would we mass claim?
It's dumb
Although since mago called for one he should claim.
Anyways let's press banana. If mago is going to push for one I am cool getting him to start it. We can popcorn it if there is enough support but the guy openly asking for it to be done 9/10 is scum hunting for something or someone specific.
Nah, I won’t claim.
I will shoot any who doesn’t tho
We could do a mass claim. With the amount of bizarre roles we have in play it may actually be hard for scum to come up with reasonable role claims.
Whoever killed Luna is a kind of a dick, his first town game after 4 scum games and you kill him n1? Let him enjoy the game ffs
Originally Posted by whiteflame on 24/10/2026 at 20:09 (post #8)
Not sure why Wylted was so quick on the jump here, but no, I’m not ready to VTL him yet.
I can’t tell if hes scum but if he is I want to find out as soon as possible, either way his influence on this game must be limited the whole Kohai thing was an ego trip on Wylted’s part, I don’t even think he was genuinely scum reading me
VTL Wylted
If anyone follow Wylted’s vote I will SHOOT YOU TONIGHT THIS IS NOT A THREAT
I don’t really like surface reading too much but Thoth looks Towny at a glance. IIRC he doesn’t do this type of analysis as scum
Originally Posted by wylted on 23/10/2026 at 13:36 (post #741)
My most confident read was on Noah who your vote absolutely should have been on but I had to go with a reasonable lynch I felt more wishy washy on.
Kohai's VTNL was sus more so than the original person who did it and he just felt off. He didn't feel like his normal self to me at least and given his statements after being lynched maybe that is due to something going on in his personal life, but him acting out of character with his frustration after that is kinda confirmation that he was behaviorally different and I was picking up on somebody and he seemed to be on everyone's radar anyway.
You know it's not a mistake to lynch a town player early in a game where they are a good mislynch target at MYLO or LYLO right?
He wasn’t on my radar at all, but I also didn’t really see what went on between the time I went to sleep and Kohai got lynched. He didn’t seem super different to me. He pushed me and pressured me something he has trouble doing as scum.
It is always a mistake to Lynch a Town player unless they’re inactive or throwing. Why are you trying to justify lynching a Town player after the fact?
Idk how you can state a confident read on most of the players here, let alone Kohai who in retrospect was kinda in his Town meta, I had no read on him either way
Originally Posted by wylted on 23/10/2026 at 12:42 (post #737)
and I honestly didn’t think you were scummy so you being lynched is a ??? to me
If he flips town this is an incredibly scummy message, given that he was doing enough to make anyone's scum radar go off. Thinking he doesn't come across as scummy implies insider knowledge.
What was he doing that was so scummy then?
Originally Posted by Thoth on 23/10/2026 at 5:22 (post #701)
I am almost concerned that Kohai's justification makes too much sense
As we saw in the Periodic Table of Elements Mafia game, where I lied about my justification for that reason, most if not all of the justifications were reaches that would leave Mister Fantastic in disbelief
Thank you ChatGPT
Actually, my justification isn’t a reach at all! It makes sense
and I honestly didn’t think you were scummy so you being lynched is a ??? to me
Originally Posted by Kohai on 23/10/2026 at 5:26 (post #710)
Originally Posted by Thoth on 10/22/2026 at 11:26 PM (post #709)
Originally Posted by Kohai on 10/22/2026 at 10:25 PM (post #708)
When have I ever not been”dcummy”
After you flip town
Exactly. And why I feel I should stop playing the game. I’m probably just too autistic for mafia
I don’t mind playing with you tbh, I was about to say the game’s gotta die down now because you help keep the game alive
How did we even Lynch Kohai there were 0 votes on him when I was awake, there’s no way this is a town driven train
I go to bed and y’all Lynch Kohai????
Originally Posted by Kohai on 23/10/2026 at 2:49 (post #518)
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/22/2026 at 8:47 PM (post #517)
One thing I’ll say -
If Noah is scum why does he keep openly asking Kohai for advice?
He did that in the last game also.
I do kinda remember my first and second games. My first game I was Town, and the person who invited me was scum and I openly looked to him for advice.
In my second game I was scum and he was Town, and I kept popping in to say a few things and would mostly be absent in between. I most certainly did not ask him for advice. In fact, I remember I was pleased he misread me as Town, and I went “off-line” for a while once I saw that.
In this respect alone at least, Noah is acting more like town me did in my first game, not scum me. Scum me was literally watching town fight each other.
One thing I’ll say -
If Noah is scum why does he keep openly asking Kohai for advice?
Actually my role is kinda scummy, maybe I should claim it lmao.
I also have an odd role but I believe I’ve seen it/heard of it before though perhaps not with the particular name given to it by Pie.
Closest thing I can think of is the Snitch role in my Standoff setup, targets a player at night and if they die that night or the following day, the role of that person is publicly revealed to the entire Town.
Ngl I’ve never heard of such a role
Originally Posted by NoAhLeEcLaRk on 23/10/2026 at 2:33 (post #499)
I choose a player to have their role public to the group after me and that person are alive after 2 days of me choosing that player
So on N1 you choose a player, and if you’re both alive on D3, the role gets revealed?
What did Noah claim as his role again? Producer? What the fuck is a producer?
Also, it would be funny as fuck if Rex was scum and we lynched him instead of Noah, who is basically outed at this stage if he’s Mafia.
Originally Posted by Kohai on 23/10/2026 at 2:27 (post #490)
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/22/2026 at 8:26 PM (post #488)
Originally Posted by Kohai on 23/10/2026 at 2:23 (post #484)
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/22/2026 at 8:23 PM (post #482)
Originally Posted by Kohai on 23/10/2026 at 2:22 (post #480)
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/22/2026 at 8:22 PM (post #477)
Originally Posted by Kohai on 23/10/2026 at 2:20 (post #475)
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/22/2026 at 8:19 PM (post #472)
Originally Posted by Kohai on 23/10/2026 at 2:18 (post #470)
Please explain your progression. It makes zero sense at all.
Look at the early pages. Noah and Rex have no trouble sussing each other yet they each have greater difficulties in sussing anyone else and their “jokes” are only addressed to each other.
Why push a lynch on ref over noah when noah was closer to being lynched?
TO BE HONEST I don’t like how everyone is pushing the Noah Lynch. I think them being scum together is possible but I just don’t want to vote there :)
So you god read solved the game but don't want to vote there?
Yeah, I'm not buying this. CFD on Magoroth anyone?
Feel free, I would rather get lynched than claim.
Do you really think ref / noah is the team? Please walk me through your process right now
I don’t want to go back through the posts I read so I’ll just do it off of my memory.
Rex randomly says hes getting slimy vibes from Noah. Then Noah proceeds to scumread Rex kinda out of the blue. Then they finish by both posting a joke addressed to each other (I’m gonna cry to my gay tranny lover or whatever Rex said).
Really, it’s hard to condense a post into words. But if you go back and read you’ll notice their interactions were with each other and their interactions with one another were far less “aggressive” or “awkward” than their interactions with anyone else. They know something we don’t, and they both know that they know it. So scum or Masons, I guess
Fair. But then again, why not noah first since he was closer? Please walk me through that slowly since what you're saying isn't making sense
IDK I just wanna be a rebel and lead my own Lynch lmao
Also Rex being scum would help explain why scum!Noah would claim a Democrat AG.