Originally Posted by Wryly on 11/4/2026 at 12:30 PM (post #131)
Originally Posted by wylted on 11/4/2026 at 11:05 AM (post #126)
I worry we sus Thoth and Kohai out of habit more than anything.
good let's get him claimed so we can quickly move him to the town pile and this won't be an issue in the endgame
He's already at L-2. I imagine we'll be getting a claim from him before EOD.
Honestly just lynch him if she doesn't claim as soon as he gets on he had all last night to do it.
iLikePie5 - null
Magoroth - slight scum too quiet
Whiteflame - null
Wylted - =|
Wryly - null
RexFavilla - obvious town
Thoth - slight scum reaction to being pushed for a claim feels off
Helz - slight town vibes
Banana - slight scum vibes
Originally Posted by Wryly on 11/4/2026 at 1:05 AM (post #116)
Like to hear your reads
Ugh been so concerned with the midterms and honestly not a lot to go on. I find Thoth being hesitant to claim to be a bit sus, I didn't like the mass claim to begin with but most people who propose one are perfectly fine with popping off first with a claim. Would like to hear more from Banana. Will probably reread tomorrow.
Originally Posted by Wryly on 11/3/2026 at 10:05 PM (post #104)
Originally Posted by Thoth on 11/3/2026 at 9:29 PM (post #97)
Originally Posted by Wryly on 11/3/2026 at 8:12 PM (post #91)
To be clear, are you scumreading it?
Moderately
It was highly speculative of him, but it's not sus enough to overpower the Miller claim. Don't you agree? There were a few games where scum had roles that required them to guess the PM of a townie, like Ted Lasso mafia.
Ted Lasso was what I was thinking of, especially because that was also a Luna game.
Originally Posted by whiteflame on 11/3/2026 at 1:35 PM (post #68)
Originally Posted by RexFavilla on 11/3/2026 at 9:15 AM (post #43)
Actually I just read my role PM and I have to SOP claim - I'm the miller.
Not sure why you'd wait this long to read your own role PM, but I buy it.
Don't have discord on my phone because it's run by satanic retards, so sometimes I just roll with it and start posting in the DP until I have time to get to my dedicated shitposting laptop.
Worth mentioning that Thoth won't even be on till like midnight or the wee hours of the morning, so we'll just be doing nothing for ~12 hours but building a wagon.
Seems as good a reason as any
UNVOTE
VTL: Thoth
Actually I just read my role PM and I have to SOP claim - I'm the miller.
Mass roll claiming is dumb. Luna disclosed an anticlaim built into the structure of the fake claims. There could be hidden role elements as well - scum could have a role that requires them to guess the targets role, for example. Luna famously hates mass claims and prizes behavioral analysis.
Love that anticlaim mechanic.
VTL: Helz
Welcome back!
/in
Originally Posted by Lunatic on 10/29/2026 at 9:42 PM (post #9)
Why did you guys quit?
I left it up to Banana as she was the one surviving and she basically saw no way out of being lynched tomorrow. My thoughts for night actions were to commuterize Wylted and therefore roleblock him, so if I had lived that would have helped but alone she was pretty much fucked.
Yeah I wasn't expecting the lynch to shift so quickly on to me. Was hoping the spotlight would stay on other people as I had some stuff come up IRL. We killed Luna because he always scumreads me in every game midgame and I figured that he would shift town that way and make DP2 more volatile - and then he replaced back in. Which I get if someone quits but was annoying as scum when you explicitly targeted a slot to get rid of the player. I think if Kohai had toughed it out we would have had much more of a fighting chance. I regret not checking in as much, DP2 Banana claimed a Dem before I could raise the issue of Dem claims having come up the previous day. Definitely wasn't my best scum performance.
Was planning on faking a watcher result and then I would bus banana, use Thoth's stolen ability to RB + 'protect' people, and fake claiming a mimic role who could copy abilities if they knew a player's character and role.
Did not see WF being the governor though, that one threw us for a loop. Wylted played super well too.
Originally Posted by Thoth on 10/26/2026 at 5:52 PM (post #157)
I am Keith Kautz, 2x Adjudicator. I can commute someone at night. Justification is that I have reviewed a metric fuck ton of decisions and often reconsidered them or given someone a second chance, and can also make someone leave the proceedings (not sure if that means escorting someone out of the courtroom or not).
To my surprise, Pie said this would even block Strongman or strengthened actions, which makes me think scum do not have strongman since that rather defeats the point of Strongman imo.
I used this on whiteflame last not and was told that my action failed. Possibly useful information since whiteflame’s claimed role would not do that.
Does this also cause the commuted player to be roleblocked since they 'leave town'?
Originally Posted by whiteflame on 10/26/2026 at 4:25 PM (post #153)
Originally Posted by wylted on 10/26/2026 at 4:20 PM (post #152)
Part of me thinks there is potential that the scum team wanted him in chat and that's the reason for the NK. I know Kohai's reaction almost clears him, but it could be me misreading it, and to top it off if anyone was going to specifically kill lunatic so he was in the scum chat it would definitely be you, so it's fucking with my head but I don't want to consider a whiteflame lunatic team right now,
Kohai would pretty much have to have known my role existed in the game for him to be scum.
Why? He could have just been blitzed at the end of the DP, hence the outsized reaction to being suddenly lynched. Usually he's lynched as town all the time and doesn't react like that. When your lynched as scumit usually feels worse. Scum would know his slot was surviving, because the lynch was announced as Noah. Then they had all NP to basically pick Kohai's replacement via the NK.
Originally Posted by wylted on 10/26/2026 at 4:20 PM (post #152)
Part of me thinks there is potential that the scum team wanted him in chat and that's the reason for the NK. I know Kohai's reaction almost clears him, but it could be me misreading it, and to top it off if anyone was going to specifically kill lunatic so he was in the scum chat it would definitely be you, so it's fucking with my head but I don't want to consider a whiteflame lunatic team right now,
This actually makes a lot of sense. I was considering if there was scum between you and Kohai/Luna (Whiteflame is confirmed, considering Banana in my town pile for that claim) but killing Luna because kohai was your teammate and ragequit and you wanted a competent replacement is making me reconsider the game a bit.
Just reread DP1 and the Banana wagon seems sus to me now. Everyone should reread especially the last few pages. People are saying she's sus for being apologetic about the lynch/hammer when it's literally in response to Kohai talking about how he's going to kill himself irl if he gets lynched. It's not an 'oh I feel bad if you're town' deal.
Banana, just claim so we can move on.
I'll be able to reread a bit more tomorrow during my commute but that's where I'm at right now.
Luna kill points to that too - either points to extreme caution or a fear kill.
The fact that Mago, Kohai, Noah, and Banana have all been the big lynch discussion targets does make me think that the scum team might be experienced players who are just sniping off the easier players.
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 10/25/2026 at 10:10 AM (post #78)
Btw @Ref why are you saying it’s my meta to act scummy? You haven’t played with me in a while so how can you know this is still true?
Because I've wanted to lynch you in literally every game I've ever played as far as I can recall. You and Kohai both have that effect on me - you just always come off as scummy to me.
Originally Posted by wylted on 10/24/2026 at 11:41 PM (post #46)
Do you think bananas change of heart is at all suspicious.
Absent most of dp1 until we try to get a lynch going near the end. Comes on to say she town reads Kohai.
As time is about to expire makes a lame excuse that we must lynch with odd players. Not exactly a fact banana would ever care about and then hammers?
I would say if banana is scum it clears Kohai/lunatic2 and it's a strong possibility here.
I'd say it's more likely Magoroth is scum than Banana. Checking in at the end of the DP and seeing your vote is needed to push a lynch through isn't necessarily suspicious. I do that all the time cause I hate no lynches on principle; I've hammered players I've townread before because I think getting into a no-lynch slump is deadly for town. Besides if Kohai is innocent it's not like he's a hard mislynch, she could easily have convinced me for instance to hammer him and I was logging on to do just that - hammer if needed, no matter who it was. Magoroth on the other hand was hard defending Kohai in a way that made little sense to me - literally nothing in his behavior screamed town. And now he seems to want to lead town over having 'called it correctly' - that seems way more like scum leveraging inside knowledge. So if Mago is scum all his behavior makes sense and it would also confirm Kohai as town, as there was no way he could know the governor would come into play and so it couldn't possibly be a distancing gambit between scum/scum. If he's town he's just acting bizarre and scummy, which tbf is kind of his meta, and Kohai's affiliation remains up in the air. At least that's where my brain is right now. Could Banana be scum? Yeah my town read on her is pretty weak. But I think the events of last DP make Mago look way worse. But I have also been busy all day and am just going off of memory, will have to reread tomorrow night.
Yeah bit of busy weekend. Strange kill. Mass claim sounds retarded. WF is town. I think if Mago is scum then Luna (Kohai) is town as his bizarrely impassioned defense is a bit much and seems almost like inside knowledge. Vig is also a textbook scum fakeclaim.
Luna, who were you scum reading last DP? Figure it's easier to just ask you rather than doing an iso.
Originally Posted by Kohai on 10/22/2026 at 11:44 PM (post #723)
Originally Posted by RexFavilla on 10/22/2026 at 11:43 PM (post #722)
Sorry I got here so late. Phone died on the way home. Anyone got a cliffnotes of what's going on?
I got lynched
Well that was anticlimactic.
Sorry I got here so late. Phone died on the way home. Anyone got a cliffnotes of what's going on?
Originally Posted by whiteflame on 10/22/2026 at 1:12 PM (post #318)
Originally Posted by NoAhLeEcLaRk on 10/22/2026 at 12:42 PM (post #317)
I'm confused on what Kohai is asking, could you elaborate please?
Give an indication of what defines your character. A soft is just “my character belongs to this category.” So for example, we’ve mentioned how some Republicans are RINOs, meaning they are often derided as not towing the party line. Some are MAGA, meaning they fall in line with the president and his ideology. Which of those describes your character?
Did Pie say anywhere that all character claims are Republicans? Why one or the other?
Originally Posted by NoAhLeEcLaRk on 10/22/2026 at 11:00 AM (post #301)
Just clarifying why I did what I did?
Why? It feels like a very panicked and unnatural response to being questioned on something as innocuous as a vote.
Originally Posted by NoAhLeEcLaRk on 10/22/2026 at 10:27 AM (post #299)
I thought I had voted for wylted at the start and I put my original vote and meant to put unvote after.
UNVOTE
Explain? This feels like an odd thing to post.
I don't love that my main vibe scumreads are Kohai and Magoroth. This is why I hate DP1.
