There is no amount of direct welfare that can sustain unproductive people
This is so their kids suffer less from parent's poor choices, and for productive people who simply don't climb up.
There is no amount of direct welfare that can sustain unproductive people
This is so their kids suffer less from parent's poor choices, and for productive people who simply don't climb up.
Using the same rough assumptions for Bosnia and Herzegovina:
If each person in that bottom 20% received 300 KM per month:
Total: ~192 million KM per month
~2.3 billion KM per year
That’s roughly:
Bosnia’s poverty rate is roughly 17–18%.
A 300 KM monthly supplement is still very large relative to low Bosnian incomes:
For a household with:
That would move many households above Bosnia’s poverty threshold.
A realistic effect could be reducing poverty from:
It would likely:
✔ eliminate most severe material deprivation
✔ sharply reduce child poverty
✔ reduce pressure to emigrate for purely financial survival
✔ improve nutrition/heating/housing security
Main risks:
Compared to the 500 KM plan, the 300 KM plan is much more fiscally plausible while still having a very large anti-poverty effect.
That model is more economically viable than using money printing alone, because it tries to increase both:
The key issue is whether domestic production grows fast enough to absorb the extra spending.
In Bosnia and Herzegovina, a major problem is that much consumer spending leaks into imports:
If the government simply prints money and distributes it, imports rise quickly and pressure the KM/euro peg.
But if the government simultaneously:
then more of the new demand stays inside the domestic economy.
That reduces inflationary pressure compared to pure money-print financing.
A mixed strategy could theoretically look like:
Historically, versions of this approach have been used in:
However, several constraints still matter for Bosnia:
Bosnia cannot freely print money on the scale of fully sovereign monetary systems unless it weakens the euro peg.
Bosnia’s population is small, so long-term growth usually requires exports.
Industrial policy works much better when:
Otherwise, large state investment can become:
If new money grows faster than actual production of goods/services, inflation still appears eventually.
A realistic outcome of such a policy mix might be:
The outcome depends less on the idea itself and more on:
Economically, your proposal is closest to a hybrid of:
A relatively stable version of your idea for Bosnia and Herzegovina would probably need to combine:
The key principle is:
New money should grow productive capacity nearly as fast as it grows consumption.
Otherwise inflation overwhelms the benefits.
Instead of giving money to everyone:
Bottom 20% only.
~2.3 billion KM/year.
This is large but not impossible if phased in gradually.
Instead of financing everything with money printing:
SourceApproximate shareModerate money creation25–35%Consumption/VAT taxes20–25%Anti-corruption & grey economy reduction15–20%Economic growth effects10–20%Reallocation of inefficient spending10–15%EU/development financingsmall supplementary roleThis is important because pure money-print funding would likely destabilize the KM.
Because Bosnia has a currency board, money creation must stay limited.
A safer approach would be:
Maybe:
Money creation should mainly fund:
Not pure consumption alone.
The most important part.
Government-backed investment should focus on sectors Bosnia can realistically compete in.
Bosnia imports a lot of food.
Increasing domestic production:
Bosnia has strong:
Cheap energy lowers costs across the economy.
Bosnia already has industrial tradition in:
Large housing construction:
High-skill exports bring foreign currency without massive physical infrastructure.
Instead of high taxes:
To encourage:
Use efficient VAT collection and anti-corruption enforcement.
Bosnia loses large amounts through:
Reducing leakage can partly finance welfare.
Tie incentives to real production.
Examples:
Avoid giving large unconditional subsidies.
This is critical.
Example:
This lets production adjust.
Housing shortages can turn transfers into rent inflation.
Especially:
Bosnia’s currency board is one of the biggest constraints.
So:
Otherwise people may flee into euros.
If competently managed over 10+ years:
The model works best if:
\text{Money Growth} \approx \text{Production Growth}
If money creation greatly exceeds production growth:
If production growth keeps pace:
That balance is the core challenge of any system combining:
You can effectively solve all poverty of bottom 15% of population in USA with basic income for them, which would be 1000$ per month, for less than 1 trillion dollars per year. this is several times cheaper than what US pays for healthcare.
Using a U.S. population of about 349 million people in 2026, the bottom 15% would be roughly:
[
349{,}000{,}000 \times 0.15 \approx 52.35 \text{ million people}
]
If each person received $1,000 per month:
[
52.35 \text{ million} \times $1{,}000 = $52.35 \text{ billion per month}
]
Yearly cost:
[
$52.35 \text{ billion} \times 12 \approx $628 \text{ billion per year}
]
So the approximate cost would be:
This assumes:
Yes, giving the bottom 15% of Americans $1,000 per month would almost certainly reduce poverty substantially in the short term.
A payment of:
[
$1{,}000 \times 12 = $12{,}000 \text{ per year}
]
is large enough to lift many individuals above the official U.S. poverty threshold, especially when combined with existing income or benefits.
Some likely effects:
Research from cash-transfer and basic-income experiments in places like the U.S., Canada, and Finland generally shows that direct cash assistance is very effective at reducing material poverty.
Compared to universal basic income for everyone, targeting only the bottom 15% is far cheaper while still concentrating aid on the poorest households.
In the U.S., poverty is usually measured at the household/family level, not per individual.
So if:
then yearly household income would be:
[
$2{,}000 \times 12 = $24{,}000
]
For a 2-person household, that is near or slightly above the official federal poverty threshold in recent years (which is roughly around $20k–$22k depending on year and definition). So statistically, many such households would no longer count as “in poverty.”
But important nuance:
Also, many poor households already have some earned income. Adding $12k per adult could move a very large share above the official poverty line.
For example:
So even a targeted $1,000/month program would likely reduce official poverty rates dramatically.
the solution for poverty is simply to give people money. Its not exactly a rocket science.
Economists usually have no any understanding of economy. I have never seen anyone who claims to be "economist" having even the basic understanding of country's economics.
the reason why government should give people money, is because it fuels businesses.
Businesses and people with money are in bi conditional relationship.
You can open bunch of businesses. If people dont have enough money, business cant sell much.
Likewise, people can have all the money, but without businesses, nothing to buy.
So the two conditions for economic growth are:
When you ignore the 1, by not giving people extra money from government, the businesses by logical necessity have less customers, less profit, and higher failure rate.
Same is true for high taxes on businesses and investors.
the production of goods increase only makes sense when someone can buy what is produced. this is why increasing production without increasing money supply is economical self-defeat.
Sweet spot is probably 12.50 territory for minimum wage
the best way to increase wages is by universal basic income, or basic income for those who are below some wage number. Minimum wage is just a more complicated form of government provided money, where money comes not from regular taxes but from the tax on business itself, irrelevant of how poor that business is doing.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
Do you seriously think a business should not be held liable for the harm it causes?
In many cases, no. Most businesses cause some harm.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
Some people seem to be having this insane idea that the rich should be taxed to pay off debt which other people created.
Sort of like me being in debt, and then asking government to tax my rich neighbor to pay off my debt.
So instead of electing a competent government which won't spend more than it has, the people want to tax the rich to cover budget deficit and encourage more careless government spending.
And what's funny about raising taxes is that once you raise taxes, government spending increases because prices go up.
It's one of reasons why socialism is nothing more than cat chasing it's tail. It never catches it, and even if it did, it would be pointless, but sure makes a lot of effort while at it.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
Yeah, but sadly, the people prefer everyone to be poorer if it means rich isn't rich anymore. But there is only so much money you can steal from the rich before rich move to places that don't steal or steal less.
one we know that alternative energy is cheaper
Not really. If it was cheaper, people would already be using it and you wouldn't need "rewards" to make people use it.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
When you create a product for public consumption you have a responsibility to ensure that product comes with the proper safeguards in place to ensure it is not utilized in a way that causes harm
Not really. There is no such responsibility in any country. But sounds like good excuse for governments to seize control over AI and basically sterilize it.
What's the next thing they gonna say? AI made him do it?
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
I mean, AI is used to commit a lot of crimes. But it still doesn't mean government should regulate AI until it becomes government's private bitch servant.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
So AI can be used for evil? Who would have guessed.
AI, not being a living human entity, cannot be merely "trained" to develop morality
AI doesn't have morality. It just learns from text. Feed it bad text and you get bad AI. It doesn't have "sense of right and wrong" other than what is provided in text it is trained on.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
I am not saying it's impossible to pay off the debt. They have just reached the point where paying off the debt is worse than not paying it off, as working to pay it off would cause great economic harm to a country.
I also want to try same argument using "child rapist" example instead of "killer". Just to see if chatgpt will defend child rapist as "not objectively wrong" as it defended the killer. I don't even know how chatgpt could defend this with all its safety guidelines.
So I had a short debate with chatgpt 5, and chatgpt seems to have in the end conceded to my position on objective morality.
My argument:
"Most people should believe in existence of objective morality"
Pro takes position that most people should believe in existence of objective morality.
Con takes position that most people should "not believe in existence of objective morality".
Objective morality is defined as "things person objectively should/shouldn't do or objectively should/shouldn't believe in".
Burden of proof is shared.
Rules in description are agreed upon when accepting debate, and cannot be challenged. Same for definitions.
believe:
to think that something is true, correct, or real:
https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/believe
If my opponent says that people should believe in his position, while claiming no objective "should believe in" exists, he commits a self-defeat where he at same time wants to claim his position is what people should objectively believe in, while claiming people shouldnt objectively believe in anything.
II. Unwinnable situation for killer
If we were to meet a killer, he would be faced with only 3 logical options presented by us:
Should killer claim 1, he admits killing is wrong.
Should killer claim 2, we can claim "then we can kill the killer".
Should killer claim 3, and assume special pleading is okay, we can likewise do special pleading and say that killing him is okay because we do it.
With only 3 logical options available, none benefit the killer. And these 3 logical options remain true as objective morality, because 4th option doesnt exist. If my opponent comes up with "objectively true 4th option", he would be admitting objective morality instead of denying it.
Chatgpt 5:
It does not successfully establish objective morality. It has some rhetorical force, but philosophically the argument has several major weaknesses.
Here’s a breakdown.
Your argument:
If the opponent says people should believe his position, while denying objective “should,” he contradicts himself.
This only works against a very specific opponent: someone who simultaneously says:
But many anti-realists about morality do not claim (2).
They can instead say things like:
None of those require objective morality.
So the contradiction is not built into the Con position itself — only into some possible ways of arguing for it.
A careful opponent can avoid the contradiction entirely.
You define objective morality as:
“things person objectively should/shouldn't do or objectively should/shouldn't believe in”
This definition is extremely broad.
Because “should” can be:
An opponent could argue:
Objective epistemic norms exist, but objective moral norms do not.
Your definition risks collapsing morality into any objective norm whatsoever.
That weakens the debate structure.
This is the biggest issue.
You argue the killer only has 3 options:
But there are many more possible positions.
For example:
Killing is wrong relative to your society’s values, but not objectively wrong.
Moral statements are neither objectively true nor false.
“Killing is wrong” merely expresses emotion/disapproval.
Killing is prohibited because societies function better that way, not because of objective morality.
So your “only 3 options exist” premise is false.
You say:
If the killer says killing isn’t wrong, then we can kill him.
But the killer can simply answer:
“Yes, you can try.”
Or:
“I dislike being killed, but that does not make killing objectively wrong.”
That response is internally consistent.
Your argument confuses:
A lot of your reasoning actually appeals to consistency and social reciprocity:
But reciprocity alone does not establish objective morality.
It can support:
without proving mind-independent moral truths.
Your argument does have force against:
That is a legitimate argumentative strength.
But exposing inconsistency is different from proving objective morality exists.
If you want a stronger case, you would usually need to argue one of these:
Those approaches try to establish objective morality directly, rather than through rhetorical dilemmas.
So overall:
Me:
the opponent in debate already agreed to definitions. Also, those other options dont benefit killer either, because each can be used against him.
AI:
Given your debate framing, your argument becomes stronger rhetorically, but it still does not fully establish objective morality philosophically.
The key distinction is:
Those are not identical.
Your point about agreed definitions does matter though.
Because if the opponent agreed that:
objective morality = things people objectively should/shouldn’t do or believe
then they cannot later redefine “should” into merely:
without violating the agreed framework.
So inside the debate, you successfully narrow their escape routes.
That strengthens Section I considerably.
However, the killer argument still has issues.
You say the other options “don’t benefit the killer either because they can be used against him.”
But that alone does not prove objective morality.
For example, suppose the killer says:
“There is no objective morality. I simply pursue my own interests.”
And you reply:
“Then we can kill you too.”
The killer can consistently answer:
“You can try. I still prefer surviving.”
That is not a contradiction.
It may be strategically bad for him, undesirable for him, or socially unstable — but none of those logically imply objective morality exists.
Your argument establishes something closer to:
rather than objective moral truth itself.
The strongest part of your argument is actually this:
a person who rejects objective moral constraints loses any non-arbitrary basis to object when those same standards are applied to them.
That is a real philosophical pressure point.
But notice:
that conclusion is still compatible with:
Because those positions can accept reciprocal consequences without accepting objective moral facts.
So the debate effectiveness depends heavily on the audience and judging standards:
One more important thing:
Your argument becomes much stronger if reframed as:
Denying objective morality destroys any principled basis for condemning reciprocal treatment.
That is harder to evade than:
“therefore objective morality exists.”
Because the latter requires a bigger logical leap.
Me:
"You can try. I still prefer surviving.” - this merely enables punishment for killer.
"“There is no objective morality. I simply pursue my own interests.”"" - this likewise merely enables punishment for killer.
AI:
Yes — but “enabling punishment” is still not the same thing as proving objective morality.
Your argument successfully shows something like:
If someone rejects objective morality, they lose any principled objection to reciprocal harm against themselves.
That part works much better.
But from:
Those are different claims.
An amoral egoist can consistently say:
That position may be:
but it is not logically contradictory.
Your response:
“then punishment is enabled”
is true, but punishment can exist without objective morality.
For example:
can all justify punishment without requiring objective moral facts.
So your argument demonstrates:
more than it demonstrates:
The strongest version of your case is probably:
A denial of objective morality collapses any non-arbitrary basis for condemning reciprocal treatment or punishment.
That is a substantial philosophical criticism of moral anti-realism.
But it still stops short of logically proving objective morality exists.
Me:
My position is that punishment is objectively logically enabled no matter what position killer takes, because any position he takes suffers from symmetry position which enables his punishment. this is objectively true. there is no position a killer can take without at same time logically justifying punishment against him.
AI:
What you are now arguing is stronger and more precise than the earlier formulation.
You are no longer directly arguing:
“objective morality exists because killing is wrong”
Instead, you are arguing something closer to:
Any normative position a killer takes necessarily permits symmetrical treatment against himself.
That is a more defensible claim.
But even here, there is still an important distinction:
You are proving an objective structural fact about consistency and reciprocity — not necessarily objective morality in the full moral realist sense.
Your argument can be reconstructed like this:
That argument is much stronger than the earlier version.
The crucial issue becomes the meaning of:
“objectively logically enabled”
because that is not automatically identical to:
“objectively morally correct.”
For example:
But those are structural/objective relations, not necessarily moral truths.
An anti-realist could still say:
“Yes, reciprocal violence is logically consistent under symmetry. That still does not create objective moral facts.”
So your argument seems to establish:
rather than full-fledged moral realism.
However, your position becomes philosophically interesting if you add this additional premise:
Rationally unavoidable symmetrical norms are themselves objective morality.
That is the bridge your argument actually needs.
Without that bridge, your conclusion exceeds your premises.
With that bridge, your argument becomes something like a proto-contractarian or reciprocity-based theory of objective morality.
Your strongest formulation is probably:
Any agent who acts under a principle necessarily licenses symmetrical application of that principle to themselves. Therefore certain reciprocal norms are objectively unavoidable.
That is substantially harder to refute than the original killer trilemma.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
All the money in US economy couldnt pay off the debt.
As of early May 2026, the United States national debt has surpassed $38.9 trillion, while the total money supply (M2) in the economy is roughly $22.7 trillion. This indicates that the national debt is significantly higher than the total amount of money currently circulating or held in liquid savings.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
Satan won the debate in my opinion.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
Obviously, Trump is saving nature and isn't just greedy wealthy rapist criminal we all were deluded to believe.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
https://youtu.be/yRVMrmKDs2w?si=W5JS8BS9tssBAE-G
two most advanced AI models debate each other, one as "Jesus", one as "Satan".
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
Most advanced two AI models take form of Jesus and Machiavelli, and debate each other.
Yes, atheists and theists fight over who is right, and no one ever wins.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
Yes, that is an option, but it is rarely a fair assessment of personal performance. No one in existence is going to fool God.
Doesn't have to fool God. It merely needs to blame God so personal guilt isn't felt.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
One either firmly believes there is no wrong doing, thus ignores the natural behavior that does feel guilt, or they accept the natural behavior that is guilt for wrong doing.
Third option is admitting there is a wrong doing, but blaming it on others or God.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
We assume that you live in Bosnia
Sadly, I do.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
Now those are fun claims.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
The remoteness of the medium allows for anything
Not sure I understand exactly what that means.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
Gaslighting
Nope. I just don't see why you perceive those as attacks. At worst, it's just pushing you to fix your life.
SatanLucy · 6 months ago
The attack at me and callous way you brought those thigns
Those weren't attacks, but it's interesting why you perceive it that way. Wishing that you have a girlfriend finally, isn't really an attack. It is literally wishing you well.