SatanLucy

I dont know how many people here even play roblox, but I figured if anyone does, this might be of some interest.


I dont play as much anymore, but I have items I dont need. Now, the reward pool is limited, keep that in mind. Its first come first served.


Available rewards are for: Adopt me, grow a garden games only.


For adopt me, available rewards are 5 cracked eggs, da vinci propeller (for flying around map), ultra rare tiara item.


Basically, next who casts a vote on ultrarated debate can request to receive 5 cracked eggs in adopt me roblox. Person after who casts a vote on ultrarated debate can request to receive da vinci propeller and ultra rare tiara item.


I dont have as much items anymore because I already donated a lot to random people when I quit playing, so rewards are limited in supply right now.


But if this reward system gets more popular, sure, we can expand the reward supply by having multiple players donating rewards.


Right now about 2% of world's population plays roblox, which isnt much, but anyone seeking to start playing it can likewise find this a useful boost.

SatanLucy
Unless they pay us in chocolate or cash


there could be cash rewards too. We will see how it goes. Site can set up a system where if you earn enough virtual currency, you can exchange it for some cash. tho people are also crazy for virtual items like in roblox. Maybe this site can make its own game similar to most popular games in roblox, but where doing activity on site earns currency, currency can be traded for items in game. this is long term thinking, but I think social games with virtual items are current hot thing. We must follow hot things.


tho of course, cash is biggest motivation for most people, and I think this site can make a currency system where people first have to earn a lot of currency by quality site activity, and then after earning required currency, can exchange it for some cash. Nothing much. Just enough to spark interest.


tho a combination of cash rewards, elo rewards, currency rewards, and virtual items rewards covers needs of greatest number of people.

SatanLucy

Every person likes seeing their virtual stick grow. No one likes seeing their virtual stick shrink. I will keep pushing for innovation until this site has some quality reward system for almost every type of action done on site. People need reward systems, even if imaginary or virtual. Roblox proved this. You have 200 million people on Roblox trying desperately to obtain virtual items. We need something like that as well. Long term this site should be turned into more of a game type site than merely a debate site. We must add some sort of a gameplay to this site to exist along side debating.


I have many other ideas, such as adding live chat, voice chat, maybe even video chat, channels, live group chats...ect. Maybe long term even enable posting of shorts videos on site if site reaches some very high growth.


Site needs to be everything for everyone. It even should have its own "educational classes" like chess.com has for chess. People want education too, not just debating. Site should provide education, not just place new people in debate arena to be punched.


But this is long term strategy. Currently, we first need a better reward system.

SatanLucy

The biggest problem for Christianity is claiming moral high ground. Modern Christians care more about to tell you how you are so bad sinner, while they themselves live an immoral life.


Trump is best example of this. A literal Satan in human form elected into power by Christians. Same with Hitler, Stalin, and bunch of corrupt politicians in between.


Christianity has no moral superiority, it never had it. That's why covering up gay sexual abuse in Churches was so common.


Imagine preaching against homosexuality while covering up for priests who fill mouths of boys in their free time.


Jesus objectively achieved none of the main goals a Messiah would. In fact, he did more to harm Jews than save them or bring them to promised land, and Revelations in Bible seem to not treat Jews as relevant anymore at all even upon second coming.


New testament is such a mess that Christians use excuse of "don't take it literally".


Christianity went from burning gays and witches, hunting vampires in 15th century, to being some washed down religion which reminds gays how they live in sin, while Christians themselves live in such sin that they made up excuse for not following Bible by "not taking it literally".


You know your religion is dead when you seek excuses not to follow it.


And somehow Christians today are nothing like Christians in 1980s, and those are nothing like Christians in 1940s, and those are nothing like Christians in 1900, and so on.


The reason why no generation of Christians matches any previous generation of Christians, and none generation like other, is because it's religion built to justify anything.


When they were condemning gays and witches to death, they were saying "Bible justifies it".


Today, they say "Bible tells to endure and not return evil for evil".


Bible can justify anything because it's 2000 pages of nonsense, and yes you can always find some verse to justify just about anything. From justifying wars, rape and genocide, to justifying some peace-loving pacifist Life style.


When same book justifies both pacifism and genocide, you know that it's nonsense.

SatanLucy

I think the world as a whole has become more retarded. Its not just USA. Europe too became retarded. After covid, everything became a lot worse everywhere. I dont think smart people trust in politics at all anymore.


If a lot of people trust some politician, it just means politician is skilled liar.


"But he is different" - yeah, he is a better liar.


the world has become so fake that I am really starting to believe NPC conspiracy theory, and a lot of conspiracy theories in past which to me seemed insane now suddenly begin to make sense.



The NPC (Non-Player Character) conspiracy theory posits that

a significant portion of the human population lacks consciousness, internal monologue, or true free will, functioning instead as "background characters" or "empty vessels" in a simulated reality. It suggests only some people are sentient "players," while others follow pre-programmed behaviors.

SatanLucy

But the remaining isnt true for ultrarated, because no direct reward for voting exists. You can cast as many votes as you want. You gain no elo, and even get punished and lose elo if you dont win debates. Currently, voting only pays off if you actually win a debate, which for 50% of people isnt true right now on leaderboard.


I am not saying this system I propose is perfect. I am sure there are many better systems possible which I am not aware of, or like the virtual currency ranking system we discussed on discord. But site needs a push towards something new, and merely proposing a system often leads to new innovations even if original proposed system isnt accepted at all.


We simply need 3-4 things:

reward for wins

reward for votes

reward for activity

reward for effort / quality


Right now we are:

Rewarding wins

Not rewarding votes

Punishing activity

"Not rewarding" or punishing effort and quality

SatanLucy

Also, this system of elo should focus on only displaying positive values on user's profile, to encourage motivation. it shouldnt show win rate, but it should show number of wins person has and number of votes person casted in total.


Displaying negative values, such as "loss rate, number of losses", acts as negative for motivation.


Avoid displaying negative values. Only display what is positive. there is a reason a lot of sites removed dislike button,

SatanLucy

Right now, on debate craft, we have 2 systems for elo: Rated and ultrarated


Rated currently doesnt reward voting at all. It also doesnt reward quality effort. Someone who loses a debate will lose elo even if he put in a lot of effort in debate, he gets punished. And someone who placed a lot of effort to vote doesnt get any benefit in elo.


So, to put it simply:


Reward incentive for voting in "rated debates" is basically non-existent.


People who put in a lot of effort in debate, but lose, get punished and it becomes difficult to recover from loss.


there are no elo rewards for participation in a debate.



Ultrarated didnt solve the problem, because elo still only rewards wins in debate. Someone can cast many good votes in ultrarated, only to find it to be of no any elo gain, and losing debate places person lower on leaderboard irrelevant of quality of votes person gave or effort put in. System only rewards debate victory in elo, not quality of votes.



Current ultrarated was shown to be very slow, and rated was shown to make users quit the site, because once person starts losing elo, it becomes more difficult to recover it, and person feels punished for participating in a debate.



NEW Elo system - "Advnaced Elo Debate"


What I propose is not removing rated or ultrarated, or changing them. Just leave them intact for now.


What I propose is introducing a 3rd elo rating system, so when people choose "debate type", there is "advanced elo debate" among options.


What is advanced elo debate system?


It is a system designed to reward both quality and activity. Winner in debate would get most elo. But loser in debate would get elo as well. And people who vote on debate would get elo as well by voting.


Elo distribution looks like this:


Winner - 100% of Elo


Voter - 60% of elo


Loser - 40% of elo



So lets say that gained elo is 10.


Winner gets 10 elo.


Each voter gets 6 elo.


Loser gets 4 elo.



Why this system works? Because once people compete in it, debate leaderboard looks like this:


On top of leaderboard, you will naturally have people with most wins and most votes. So to be on top of leaderboard, you must not only win a lot, but also vote a lot, to be on top of leaderboard.


Behind them, there will be people who win a lot, but dont vote a lot.


Behind those, there will be people who lose a lot, but vote a lot.


Behind those, there will be people who lose a lot and dont vote a lot.


Behind those, will be people with very little activity.


Behind those, will be people with almost no activity.



this elo system creates a hierarchy where both activity and quality matters. And inactive debaters who are inactive voters end up on bottom of leaderboard eventually even if they are on top now, while active debaters and active voters who also win a lot and provide quality end up on top of leaderboard.


this elo system forces activity to keep elo ranking, while rewarding quality and activity the most.


this elo system also rewards voting. People have more reason to vote good vote on a debate because their own elo benefits from it.


this elo system rewards participation as well. People have more reason to participate more because their elo gets rewarded a bit by participating instead of being punished for participation.



this elo system is a proposed experiment. Similar elo systems exist on Modern day debate discord where more activity means you rank up more.



the proposition is to simply add a 3rd elo system. those who want ultrarated can still do ultrarated. those who want rated can still do rated. Nothing changes there. Elo in rated and ultrarated is unaffected. Users just get a 3rd option of elo system, "advanced elo", and in this elo system, people gain elo for all acceptable votes they cast on any debate in "advanced elo debate" type, and they also gain elo for participating in debate under "advanced elo debate" type, and they get elo for winning in such debate types, obviously.



this proposed system is merely a proposed experiment. If it works, we can expand it, so that other elo systems start rewarding votes as well, or that votes on any debate in rated, ultrarated or advanced elo debate, count towards "advanced elo" rating.



this elo system is simply designed to reward "winning and voting" more than anything else, but also to reward voting. We currently lack sufficient rewards for votes. A lot of debates wait too long for votes. A lot of debates end up without votes, and that works against site's activity. Quality votes currently dont carry any elo rewards, and elo rewards are only gained when winning a debate, not when casting a quality vote.


Our site needs plenty of voters as much as it needs debaters, for any elo system to work in the first place.


Its time to start rewarding voters for their votes, with rewards which matter.


Someone else suggested paying voters to vote, and that is a somewhat working idea, assuming owner can afford that. If we payed 1$ to people per vote, sure, we would suddenly get a lot of users on site who seek to earn money off this site. But that would be very difficult to afford long term, would cost thousands per month if userbase increases.

SatanLucy
sluts (while shaming virgins)


I never quite understood virgin shaming, but apparently, it happens everywhere, not just on left. there are worse things than a virgin man, and one should keep that in mind before doing virgin shaming.

SatanLucy

I trust AI a lot because it provides me with quick information. And speed is important. It saves time. Of course, I watch a lot of YouTube videos for education, and that is when I want to research a bit more about something. But you can't even fully trust YouTube videos. Reality is, you can't trust anything with certainty, but you can use many different things, so if one thing messes up, the other thing makes up for it. I find AI useful, but I am not naive to think AI is flawless. Far from it. AI is just good at brainstorming quickly, and giving me data I need quickly, as well as giving me many points quickly if necessary. For deeper research, I am more likely to use educational YouTube videos. I write down a lot, and I have many notes. I have a habit of writing down things. I have my sources of information, and I use many sources of information.

SatanLucy

What most people fail to understand is that often the only reason they hate some people is because better people appear.


this is usually called "relative value" affected by comparison.


But the comparison actually only begins to show truth once you apply worst case standard for comparison.


to person who has many friends and plenty of options in life, such person naturally moves to best available options.


But to a very lonely person, almost any other person is welcome to be friend because alternative is no friends and no one to talk to.


this is also true in relationships. Women pick from what is best among available. But if the only available men are bad men, women will pick them.


Person who has plenty of money usually chooses other people who have plenty of money, to be friends with, and can be picky about who to hang out with, and doesnt need to be kind to most people.


Person who is very poor, on the other hand, will happily be friends with anyone generous enough to provide help.


Standards are usually made by comparison.


there are things person would never accept under any circumstances. these are "worst case" standards. Anything above them is generally accepted depending on circumstances and available options.


And people often have wrong idea about what their "worst case standards" are. But best way to establish what they are is by experiencing lack.


Experiencing lack of all better options truly shows if some option is then acceptable or not.


Same with people. You might hate trump, but if he and you were last people on Earth, you would quickly become friends because alternative would be eternal loneliness.


People often experience severe drop in standards once they actually experience a complete lack. And people who have abundance usually experience rise in their standards.


this is why stoicism is about experiencing lack, to find out if things have value when no better options exist.


Because value is a very relative thing, and depends entirely on what is available in the first place. For example, I can set my standards very high, but if nothing in reality matches them, then my standards fail and leave me in complete lack of anything to satisfy them.


So standards naturally move as reality moves. Person who lacks food for a long time appreciates food more. Person who lacks water for a longer time appreciates water more. Person who is poor appreciates more any display of kindness. Person who has complete lack, appreciates almost anything to remove a lack.


Once you realize that the only reason you hate a lot of people is because better people exist, and if those better people didnt exist, you would actually stop hating the people you hate, you begin understanding stoic philosophy more.


Because value is found in lack. Sure, if I have million dollars, I wont appreciate at all someone giving me 10$ randomly, I might even feel insulted. But if I am on streets starving, no money for food, and someone gives me 10$, I begin to see that person as my savior. Exactly same action valued completely differently due to available options.

SatanLucy

Dont make the mistake of overmoderation. Any punishment for activity discourages activity as a whole. this site will only grow good if it can please greatest variety of users, and forcing all users into one same behavior type loses a lot of users. One can only afford to raise standards once one can afford to lose users, and right now I would welcome even worst trolls on this site because almost anything is better than a site with no activity.


Also, I have said this before, someone should program live chat for this site, similar to discord chat where you can see who is typing, who is online...ect. I mean, just tell Claude AI to do it. this site needs innovation and variety. We need to be more like discord or tik tok with their group chats, and less like some forum from year 2000.

SatanLucy

We can still talk to our AI girl on debate art. Its not all lost yet. I knew debate art will still prove itself to be useful.

SatanLucy

I think human plus AI does a lot more than just human. And it also depends on what group are you working with. Sure, I get good ideas from humans too, but there must be careful selection and fact check by AI as well. Merely listening to other humans gets you nowhere, because you have no time to listen to everyone in the world. One must be picky and also lucky not to fall victim of terrible advice.

SatanLucy

the problem with community votes still remains same: slippery slope.


they ban debby, it doesnt fix the problem (obviously). So they either admit they were wrong about banning users to solve problems (which they wont do), or they keep going down slippery slope thinking banning even more users will eventually fix problem (which it wont).


It feels like a lot of users are playing some form of mafia game with user bans. Of course, its good to have democracy on site, but not good if it will turn into two wolves and sheep voting whats for dinner.

SatanLucy

Women and rape

SatanLucy · 8 months ago

It’s just the same topic over and over again with this guy


I honestly hope he is not into rape, because thats such a bad kink to have in life. there are much better and easier ways to get sex. Just get a hooker. With enough money, she can even agree to roleplay rape if thats the kink. But being into rape eventually gets person in trouble, and women arent worthy of risk of years in prison.

SatanLucy

Also, I am a bit drunk as writing this, so sorry if it doesnt make complete sense. I just feel bans should be only done in most obvious cases of harm to site and harm to debating principle.

SatanLucy

Humans are very bad at fixing their mistakes. At this point, I wouldnt oppose to AI government, because AI is simply better than human politicians.

SatanLucy

Debby was spamming a lot, which I assume is reason she was banned.


Now, here is what I dont understand.


Site has option to hide someones posts. So anyone who hates debby can just hide her posts so he doesnt see them anymore.


I am not saying banning debby was a mistake. Having each thread be ended with AI post at some point probably gets annoying to a lot of people.


Personally, I dont care that much about Debby's spam. Its easy to scroll past it.


And maybe new users will be more entertaining, but we know from experience that new users are mostly just temporary. Getting a permanent new user is difficult, irrelevant of how many permanent users you ban.


to me, it seems pointless to ban permanent users in an attempt to gain more of permanent users.


But once you start blaming some users for site's slow growth, you enter a slippery slope. Because if site's growth keeps being slow, then you must logically ban even more users because you start from assumption that current users are responsible for that.


And as Debate art showed, even when all users from it moved to new site, debate art didnt magically gain new permanent users.


Because to gain users, you must be a hot search. When someone types "debate site", if your site doesnt come up in first 3 results, you are not a hot search.


If someone types "good debating site", and your site doesnt come up, you are not a hot search.


Being a hot search is important, because thousands of people every day search for a good debate site, and they usually get dragged into few first search results.


Algorithm is simply everything. And algorithm favors sites which payed a lot to google to place them there.


So instead of trying to attract new users which might never come to stay permanently, a better strategy is to maintain current user base.


Not everyone is happy with Debby being banned. I can understand the arguments for her ban,


but question is, will her ban make current users more active?


Will her ban make new users come more?


We know from experience once debate art started with bans and punishments for users, it didnt increase its user base, but quite the opposite.


I am not saying no one should ever be banned, but to me, it seems like ban should only be used when its obvious that it must be used.


Because that is most reasonable approach. If you are focusing on imaginary probabilities, miscalculation easily happens. Bans should only happen when its most obvious undeniable harm to site. Anything other than that risks being a miscalculation.

SatanLucy

I am not a moderator, nor I wanted debby banned. I assume for AI spam, because she was spamming a lot. I think banning her is essentially a slippery slope, and also unnecessary and doesnt achieve anything. Moderators are basically punishing active users to please inactive users, thinking inactive users will become more active once active users are gone.


I personally dont care for debby, she was even getting annoying with spam nonsense. But now site gets less active, and honestly, it never ceases to surprise me how many people here have complete inability to just ignore users they dislike.

SatanLucy

Creatine

SatanLucy · 8 months ago

I can already feel its effects. My workout did get slightly better today. tho I was eating a lot of this. Chatgpt told me to eat 20 grams per day for first week, then 3 to 5 grams for rest of time. But I can definitely see advantage. It also gives some placebo effect. I was definitely missing creatine in vegetarian diet.

SatanLucy

Project Mkultra lasted for 20 years, where US government did experiments on humans to see how to create alter personalities, in other words, entirely new people who no longer remember past, and who act according to command.


https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MKUltra


https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/sites-default-files-hearings-95mkultra.pdf


After being caught in doing this, most of documents regarding project mkultra were destroyed. You can understand why.


However, project Monarch is believed to be a sub-project of Project Mkultra, and it is believed that these projects didnt simply stop after 20 years of research.


Project Monarch is named this way for one specific reason. It creates alter personalities through trauma.


While many rejected this as just another conspiracy theory, there is a strong suggestive evidence that trauma based behavior control is applied today on mass scale.


For example, Israel's "Dahiya doctrine" is meant to control behavior and produce terrorists through causing trauma to civilians.


And the entire system in the world is put in place to cause trauma related to disobedience. It is clearly observed that once you stop repeating what news tell you, once you start thinking for yourself, you experience rejection, disapproval, condemnation...ect.


the system is designed to deter outliers.


And US didnt stop researching human behavior after project Mkultra.


two facts are most obvious in this case:

One, project Mkultra researched a lot more than what is publicly admitted. We know this because the only documents we have on project Mkultra are those which were publicly shown, with majority of documents being destroyed, what else was there?


Fact two, US had every interest to continue project Mkultra in secret. Even today, USA has "top secret" projects where money goes to, and no one knows what those projects are.