Signups
- Magoroth
- Shining
- RexFavilla
- ILikePie5
- wylted
- Banana
- (Helz?)
- Kohai
- whiteflame
- awesome5000
Damn I had good gutreads for once
I thank Magic for voting me lol because otherwise I would have had to ISO whiteflame in more depth in case my gutread on Magic was wrong
Originally Posted by Hyper on 8/5/2026 at 5:58 PM (post #152)
I kind of think Thoth is town now but I'm not sure where that'd leave a partner for awesome5000 if I'm right with my vote. Perhaps Mag1cman?
Disregarding that Hyper was so townread, check out this post and tell me Magic had no incentive to kill Hyper.
#188, why insinuate distancing from whiteflame and then write off the possibility of him being scum?
I should add that Casey/Thoth kills me because I am sleepy and would rather crash than defend myself.
Re: #189. Mag1c out here tryna argue that they kill anyone other than the most townread person. That aint how Mafia works
VTL: Mag1cman
And suggesting that WF or Hyper was Magic’s likely scummate was before I correctly pivoted to Casey as likely scum.
Obviously from my perspective scum!whiteflame hammered me, hence it has to be Mag1c.
Originally Posted by Mag1cman on 8/8/2026 at 10:34 AM (post #189)
I mulled Whiteflame over. I just don’t have any concrete proof.
assume Casey/mag1c:
people are saying I’m a strong pairing with Casey if Casey flips scum after the NP.
at least one person (Thoth) was saying Hyper or Whiteflame could be paired with me if I flipped scum.
Casey/Mag1c’s play would then be to kill Mag1c, keep Thoth, Casey, and Whiteflame/Hyper alive for f3.
Instead we have Mag1c, Thoth, Whiteflame. After a Casey scum flip.
If I’m scum I just threw myself into an endgame designed to screw me. I’m town. Think on the incentives, please.l
I was open to the possibility of you/WF and you/Hyper because I was pretty sure you were scum. I never considered them top scum candidates. Magic/Casey just kills Casey because they are probably less able to make a good case than you are.
Hope they kicked you off before leaving the airport
there meaning whiteflame
Imma have to ISO both of you and see what each of you said about Casey. If it's Mag1c, that's annoying since I have much more to work from there. I know I could have contributed more too.
Call me a scumlord, but I would like to end this game today, i.e., after I wake up in the afternoon Central time, so that I don't have to wait another day to run Blood on the Clocktower.
Originally Posted by whiteflame on 8/6/2026 at 8:11 PM (post #161)
I’m unclear. Why would Casey be the obvious kill with that pairing? I can see a basis myself, but it’s not 100%. Would you say you’re sussing Magic more than me right now? Is this your only reason?
Yes, I am. I should have explained my reasoning. I could be wrong, but I think that Mag1c is an overall stronger player than Casey, so it would make more sense to keep him alive.
Now that I think about it, I figure you are probably better than Casey, and Mag1c too, so that reasoning can go out the window.
I can't say for sure that it's Magic/Casey, but I can say that a Magic/Casey would have 100% killed Casey rather than Magic. Possibly irrelevant now.
VTL: awesome5000
I'm willing to swap to awesome. whiteflame would be a hard sell
VTL: Mag1cman
I will be very surprised if it's whiteflame
Originally Posted by Hyper on 8/5/2026 at 5:53 PM (post #143)
Is it solely based off his post trying to get you voted?
That and the fact that Mag1c gives seemingly good analysis like that as both town and scum. I know it sounds self-centered, and I suppose it is, but he knows damn well that I can make a convenient scapegoat.
Originally Posted by whiteflame on 8/5/2026 at 5:30 PM (post #123)
Originally Posted by Thoth on 8/5/2026 at 6:29 PM (post #122)
Originally Posted by whiteflame on 8/5/2026 at 5:21 PM (post #113)
Yes, I’ve seen him as scum several times. Generally speaking, he tends to draw attention to himself the more he posts
More as town than scum lol
Lord it over me why don’t you?
I will admit that the reason why I am lynchomagnetic as town is usually due either to bad plays or karmic inertia from bad plays in past lives
Originally Posted by whiteflame on 8/5/2026 at 5:33 PM (post #127)
Well, I’m sorry sleep was so elusive man. That sucks.
I actually have an easy time getting to sleep, I just have a fucked-up circadian rhythm that violently resists segregating sleep to normal sleep hours, as adults often need to do.
I have played with awesome a few times and found his posting style utterly alignment-unreadable. No point for me to rank possible scum teams there.
I would like to lynch Mag1c. If he's scum then I think his partner is likely WF or Hyper
they*
Sorry if I used the wrong pronouns, awesome
Originally Posted by Hyper on 8/5/2026 at 5:43 PM (post #136)
Does Casey also posting early mean anything to you? I can see the read, though I'm not sure how much stock I put in it.
Possible towntell in that Casey is smart enough to not post very early around the same time as their scummate unless as WIFOM. I take it they say WIFOM on your home site. I don't know awesome as well as Casey, but I don't think he would miss a glaring connection like that either.
I have a bad gutread on Casey despite sympathizing with their problems mentioned in #40. Something about their posts strikes me as fake contribution.
Given that I saw Mag1c as scummy, it strikes me that he talked more about WF than Hyper despite Hyper posting more (I think, I don't have time to crunch the numbers). Makes me think that Mag1c's partner is one of those two if Mag1c is scum.
If you want to give me benefit of the doubt, I would rather that y'all give me 19 minutes to add any additional thoughts