But my gut says Luna because he also had egg on his face from the Mago lynch, was damaged goods, and is good in a cagefight
Not this game, I don't have the time atm to put up a good cage fight.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
But my gut says Luna because he also had egg on his face from the Mago lynch, was damaged goods, and is good in a cagefight
Not this game, I don't have the time atm to put up a good cage fight.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
lol
Lunatic · 6 months ago
It would help if there was legit behavioral reason to sus them besides inactivity which should be NAI for her given her past few games
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Helz wrote:
Lunatic wrote:
Yeah I made this same point earlier. They were suspicious of each other for like 5 seconds then magically town read each other lol
Yeah. The way its voiced gets me a bit. Like Bullish's last comment:
Anyone still stuck on "3 investigatives is too much" is being obstinate.
To be fair they have a point citing a game where 3 invests existed. But the messaging of not just saying they disagree its the case but invalidating it as a concept that it is even reasonable for people to consider.
I was really hoping to see at least one of the three sorta clear themselves responding in the opposite way a scum would obviously be inclined to.
I mean if it weren't for the way Mikal set his POE up I would probably be equally suspicious of bullish here. I am like 40% Bullish, 60% Mikal. I don't think Bullish has done anything extremely townie either, but Mikals push on casey just reeks a bit scummy to me.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Helz wrote:
Something I was hoping to see but have not is the Invest roles to treat the situation as more of a CC. Im not seeing that at all. Instead of being suspicious of etchother they seem to be circling the wagons and supporting the existence of multiple invests. Thats the exact position I would expect scum to make deflating concerns about their claim while pivoting elsewhere but it’s like they are all doing it. I was really hoping to see at least one pop up and shove that its a reasonable potential as a strong town indicator..
Yeah I made this same point earlier. They were suspicious of each other for like 5 seconds then magically town read each other lol
Lunatic · 6 months ago
VTL: Mikal
Still busy hopefully can post more tonight, but if its a 1 v 1 with him and bullish I choose him.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Thoth wrote:
Lunatic wrote:
Pretty sure casey is a they/them or a female btw. Also casey was town in solo leveling so I am confused what you mean by that?
Casey told me that they are fine with she/her or they/them pronouns but mildly prefer they/them.
That is what I am basing that off of. But Mikal was calling them a he.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
whiteflame wrote:
So I'll just be clear about my thoughts on Casey as well.
I can't say I'm outright scumreading Casey, but I can see Mikal's point that lynching Casey would either verify their result or take down one scum. I'm balancing that against the likelihood that scum Casey claims this role before knowing what so many players did during the NP, which places them at great risk of being told they were visited. As Luna has already mentioned, he's taken that kind of risk before. It's absolutely not unheard of. We are also unaware of the roles scum has, which could give them some indication of who visited whom and at least narrow the field to a few unknowns. Still, I've been slightly townreading Casey, but I can see the value in lynching them and I think it should be considered seriously.
Also casey taking the risk of claiming dreamer right off the bat when she was the number one other major wagon is another thing to factor in. Me risking it was still risky in Russia mafia just because I am an active player and a likely visit, but her claiming it as scum would be basically throwing, she should have assumed as scum someone would have visited her. Extreme amounts of risk for for extreme amounts of reward, but that reward isn't paying off since shes still being talked about being lynched. I think their just town, and its probably mikal. I know he's gonna throw a bitch fit about it so I probably won't engage much with him. I'll read his arguments and if there is anything new or convincing, I will take it with a grain of salt, but just spam repeating the same shit and using expletives, calling people dumb for not seeing it, etc, probably isn't going to do much to convince me.
For me it's him or bullish this day phase.
With a heavy lean on mikal.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
My analysis and playtime is going to drop off a steep cliff fair warning. Will do my best to play and be active but got stuff going on (nothing bad) thats kind of distracting me a lot from mafia.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
I think one, not both of whiteflame and mikal are scum. Their claims being so similar doesn't make sense if the yare on a scum team. Or its just a weird uncalculated play that they would have known would have drawn suspicion. I am leaning towards that being mikal based on the POE he's pushing, as well as being on the dreamer results.
The only reason to suspect casey seems to be hardline paranoia they are pulling a gambit, which is kind of dumb to me. I agree with banana and bullish that the fact that Mikal is pushing that way so hard looks like he is trying to set up mislynches for an easy LYLO based on mechanics.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Meant to tag you
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Pretty sure casey is a they/them or a female btw. Also casey was town in solo leveling so I am confused what you mean by that?
Lunatic · 6 months ago
I am lynching between bullish and mikal today. I think there is decent reasons to lynch both, just need to sit on this. Casey being scum is a very real possibility I will consider as well. I just have some mental reservations as to whether they are the type of player to do that after seeing me do it in Russian Mafia. Kind of a copy cat play. Not sure if they do that or not.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Mega*
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Whiteflame and Mikal suddenly maga town reading each other is so odd given everything. Maybe bias towards being in a private chat? Just logically doesn't sit well given the way actions and claims have worked. There should be some natural suspicion regardless of a bit of town vibes.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
whiteflame wrote:
I'm going to knock off earlier tonight and read through the DP fresh tomorrow. I'll say I'm pretty split between Bullish and Luna atm for very different reasons.
Its strange to me how you are now completely town reading mikal.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Lunatic · 6 months ago
UNVOTE
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Motion detector- Dreamer- Tracker
One of these is probably lying.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
As for Luna, I was townreading them about as much as anyone going into the last NP, but I can't say I've got a solid read on him this DP. I get confusion in response to all this, but not so much the shrug that he gave in his last post. I still want to townread him, but it's moving towards null.
Hardly just "shrugging it off". I have asked both of you what your thoughts are on the mess and neither of you have a clear answer towards it but "All I know is I am town". I don't really see the point in talking to just you two about it, I would like to see others comment, banana, shining, helz, magic, rex, etc.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
I dislike Lunas post above. It's very unlike him just to throw his hands up and rely on other people for reads
I do better with behavioral analysis. I dont know what to make of this mess with night actions. Also I will be posting more in detail posts when I can, I am in the middle of a big war on conan exiles, so kind of distracted atm.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Idk I kind of wanna hear other peoples thoughts about this mess. Don’t really know what is going on.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
whiteflame wrote:
Lunatic wrote:
Pretty sure this is whiteflame, has the most conflicting results with a claimed tracker and being countered by mikal is not a great look.
If you want to prove it to yourself, go ahead and push for my lynch. I can only speak to what I know happened. If you want to believe that I’d go through the trouble of making up a Vanillaizer, claiming a redirection role in a game that apparently has several, chose to visit Shining with a role that clearly wasn’t the NK, and somehow got added to a separate Mason chat in the mix, so be it, but I can’t remember a game where I was willing to take so many risks simultaneously as scum.
I just need some other solutions to this to make it make sense. If its not you, are you and mikal both town redirectors? I realize your slightly different, but still seems interesting. Are you not suspect of mikal if you are town? Do you think rex is lying about his results? Why or why not? Sure there could be other explanations for this but prima facie there are still questions, and barring no answers I have to assume someone is lying in all this mess.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Bullish wrote:
Reading the last DP, I think Mago OMGUS voted 4 separate times lol. I think it was a town-led wagon.
You are the only person on the dreamer results who has yet to claim. Its your turn.
VTL: Bullish
Lunatic · 6 months ago
So we got bullish and Whiteflame, just need to figure out the third maf. Down to lynch either today.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Pretty sure this is whiteflame, has the most conflicting results with a claimed tracker and being countered by mikal is not a great look.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Only unclaimed individuals at this point are, Banana, thoth, shining, bullish and magic. We know one of these is role confirmable as putting mikal and whiteflame in a pm together.
And Bullish being implicated on results means he at bare minimum should claim.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Only unclaimed individuals at this point are, Banana, thoth, shining, bullish and magic. We know one of these is role confirmable as putting mikal and whiteflame in a pm together.
And Bullish being implicated on results means he at bare minimum should claim.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
Hmm yeah two town redirectors would be wild, I know they function slightly differently but still.
Lunatic · 6 months ago
All these redirect roles make a much stronger case for a strengthener existing in hindsight lol