Originally Posted by Lunatic on 17/08/2026 at 22:20 (post #96)
I say we all either just ignore magoroth the rest of the game or policy lynch him. Kind of tired of his shenanigans
I literally haven’t played a game in months, how about I do all of you and myself a favour and replace out if that’s really how you feel about me being in the game
I don’t even think Shining is scummy this game, why not vote literally anyone else
NO USELESS CLAIMS, DONT GIVE SCUM INFORMATION
DONT BE DUMB
If anyone claims you will die tonight btw
I’d rather vote you for making such a suggestion
I feel like, if there’s a scum in Shining/Mag1cman, there’s only one scum; they aren’t paired. Shining seems to have made a seamless transition between saying I was probably Town to considering what Mag1cman had to say about me and then expessing doubts at his previous read. Yes, it’s not a very strong read, but it strikes me as the type of thing you wouldn’t do with a partner, it feels too organic/real/not fake
VTL: whiteflame
Originally Posted by whiteflame on 17/08/2026 at 20:09 (post #79)
It’s one thing to be skeptical; if someone acts scummy and they flip town, yeah maybe there is room for doubt, even if they flip town and act towny you can allow some doubt, but saying you can’t trust flips is just anti-town as fuck
So... you just don't like that she was being absolutist with the statement? How she said it doesn't really bother me.
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/17/2026 at 12:46 PM (post #75)
Like I said this is the type of statement that 1) sows confusion and 2) scum would say to keep themselves involved and appear to be interested in the game/solving the game. Please vote her.
I legitimately do not understand how this is meant to sow confusion. All of us have played with Tailors before and everyone else gets what she was trying to say. I'll admit that it's not the kind of thing you have to actually post for people to get it, but I can't say I see it as performative.
Because if we can’t trust flips then that removes a huge amount of information from the game
Originally Posted by Banana on 17/08/2026 at 19:23 (post #76)
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/17/2026 at 10:14 AM (post #72)
Originally Posted by Banana on 17/08/2026 at 17:38 (post #70)
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/17/2026 at 9:28 AM (post #69)
I think she’s scum and the statement and the way she said it pings me, there’s nothing else to go on and its early d1, I don’t think I’m making a mountain out of a mole hill. Could I be wrong? Yes; I don’t think so at all, but even if I am at least it gives us something to talk about, and yes I do really think that statement is scummy as hell, nobody else said it btw
someone says there is a tailor, i say to not trust flips. unless there’s a reason to believe he’s lying for some reason seems a reasonable response to that
If we don’t trust flips, might as well not play the game anymore. Someone acts scummy and they flip scum, I will assume they are scum, barring serious evidence of the contrary. This is literally a recipe for destroying the whole town. I’ve seen people lose games with this mentality. And you’re just saying that’s what you’d do? Nah, you’re scum
u r blowing this out of proportion lol. how about I rephrase it to “take flips with a grain of salt” if it’s the wording that’s tripping u up. if there’s a tailor it’s a given
Then why didn’t you say it like that at the start?
Like I said this is the type of statement that 1) sows confusion and 2) scum would say to keep themselves involved and appear to be interested in the game/solving the game. Please vote her.
So yeah vote Banana pretty please?
It’s one thing to be skeptical; if someone acts scummy and they flip town, yeah maybe there is room for doubt, even if they flip town and act towny you can allow some doubt, but saying you can’t trust flips is just anti-town as fuck
Originally Posted by Banana on 17/08/2026 at 17:38 (post #70)
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/17/2026 at 9:28 AM (post #69)
I think she’s scum and the statement and the way she said it pings me, there’s nothing else to go on and its early d1, I don’t think I’m making a mountain out of a mole hill. Could I be wrong? Yes; I don’t think so at all, but even if I am at least it gives us something to talk about, and yes I do really think that statement is scummy as hell, nobody else said it btw
someone says there is a tailor, i say to not trust flips. unless there’s a reason to believe he’s lying for some reason seems a reasonable response to that
If we don’t trust flips, might as well not play the game anymore. Someone acts scummy and they flip scum, I will assume they are scum, barring serious evidence of the contrary. This is literally a recipe for destroying the whole town. I’ve seen people lose games with this mentality. And you’re just saying that’s what you’d do? Nah, you’re scum
I think she’s scum and the statement and the way she said it pings me, there’s nothing else to go on and its early d1, I don’t think I’m making a mountain out of a mole hill. Could I be wrong? Yes; I don’t think so at all, but even if I am at least it gives us something to talk about, and yes I do really think that statement is scummy as hell, nobody else said it btw
Originally Posted by whiteflame on 17/08/2026 at 15:11 (post #62)
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 8/16/2026 at 5:30 PM (post #43)
It also feels like “we can’t trust flips” is the type of thing scum would say to fit in after someone revealed Tailor is possible
I don’t understand this. So speaking to the obvious is scummy? I’m pretty sure it’s something we’re all thinking.
No, its not true, we can mostly trust flips, there’s literally like one flip maybe that we can’t trust, saying otherwise is anti-town as hell
Originally Posted by Shining on 17/08/2026 at 8:23 (post #57)
Okay, I'm reading Mago's posts again, and maybe I am just retarded, but he should be sussing Mikal harder than Banana if he cares about flips being trusted.
I don’t think Mikal is necessarily lying, and he didn’t say anything about us not trusting flips, he said there’s a Tailor. There’s a difference between that and saying we shouldn’t trust flips
@Mikal
is there any explanation why you would know a Tailor exists? seems like an oddly specific piece of information to have
And yes by this I am confirming I am not third party and if anyone ever says that I am or if I claim this later it will be a lie
I too think third party should reveal but they probably won’t, it depends on their win condition, they could be pretty much anything that doesn’t have to see Town lose in order to win
It also feels like “we can’t trust flips” is the type of thing scum would say to fit in after someone revealed Tailor is possible
I can never read Wylted, feels like hes always throwing out this “bleh, screw the world” attitude regardless of alignment
Banana is 100% scum she’s acting totally different from last game and her THROWING SHADE ON FLIPS IS SUS AS FUCK
VTL: wylted
/in Standoff 9p
/in
Originally Posted by Kohai on 14/08/2026 at 5:35 (post #233)
Originally Posted by Thoth on 8/13/2026 at 11:34 PM (post #232)
I'mma be fa'real. Nobody seems to be enjoying this, myself included, and it's looking like a completely failed experiment. I am open to dumping this game altogether and rerolling a Mafia game instead if enough people support it.
I am ok with that esp if wf is the demon
Same
