Like I told Pie in a group chat I think there’s a possibility Whiteflame is Town IF all 3 evils decided to make up a lie about him, independently or something. It’s not likely, though.
Admittedly looking at all the evidence against him it’s pretty unlikely he’s Town, but I still feel uncomfortable with having a hard red check on someone already.
Originally Posted by awesome5000 on 12/08/2026 at 23:22 (post #205)
WF is probably scum, if not demon
hopefully the game ends
we can test Rex tomorrow if necessary
Feel like you’re way too confident for what’s happening rn
This game is confusing and even with all the combinations that Banana posted I don’t see what’s so obvious lol
Thoth has posted so obviously Rex is either not Virgin, Poisoned or Whiteflame is Scum if I understand correctly since hes still alive? Has WF claimed because I don’t see it anywhere
VTL: whiteflame
Completely forgot about this game I’m so sorry, what did I miss lol
Wait what
I dunno if it’s that bastard. We would also have to figure out if the person in question was in fact evil, and they stay in the game and can continue to speak, but not vote. They still have an influence on the game and a death wouldnt be as bad as in a normal game
So if I understand correctly Whiteflame has two results on him that implicate him as evil?
Originally Posted by Magoroth on 11/08/2026 at 9:37 (post #127)
Originally Posted by Kohai on 11/08/2026 at 2:36 (post #62)
I'm royally confused with this entire setup and mech. From what I'm seeing an empath can see if the player above or below them in the player list is evil which means from their pov either whiteflame and / or rex has to be scum.
I'm not getting this mech at all. This seems extremely OP'd in a small player game.
I thought so too at first, then realised we don’t get flips, so in fact it’s not as OP as you might think.
I want everyone to look at this post and check if they can see what I’m seeing. If Kohai is scum there’s a very good chance Banana’s Town and her information is accurate.
Originally Posted by awesome5000 on 11/08/2026 at 5:16 (post #87)
here we go again
Scum? I thought you were Town last game based on your first few posts but I’m getting the opposite vibes this game.
I AM VOTING AWESOME IN SPIRIT
Originally Posted by Kohai on 11/08/2026 at 2:36 (post #62)
I'm royally confused with this entire setup and mech. From what I'm seeing an empath can see if the player above or below them in the player list is evil which means from their pov either whiteflame and / or rex has to be scum.
I'm not getting this mech at all. This seems extremely OP'd in a small player game.
I thought so too at first, then realised we don’t get flips, so in fact it’s not as OP as you might think.
I feel like you might be scum this game. You sound a bit off
This is making it very tempting for me to vote you ngl
Well, most roles shouldn’t claim but these roles if claimed by someone who is about to be lynched will not look great for them. So it’s better if they claim now.
Especially that Saint thing which would instantly lose us the game if they get lynched
Yeah. I think that will happen a lot this game
Obviously, by posting this I am clearly confirming I am not one of the above roles.
The following roles should immediately claim
Saint
Recluse
Virgin
Virgin should immediately claim as well. I thought of using this to narrow down investigative results later on but I think it’s too risky. Playing around this role would sabotage us too much by not allowing us to throw votes around.
There’s gonna be a lot of signalling or faking scum/town reads as an excuse to get a group chat with a player lol
We may have to watch for whoever claims multiple roles or namedrops random roles out of nowhere. Demon was given all 3 fake claims for the whole scum team so there’s a good chance he’ll try to slip it in somehow so the minions get their claims.
Probs bad English: what I meant was that he decided this ahead of time to make the setup more balanced due to the roles that exist in the game.
Maybe the game is imbalanced already or he built this night 0 infomation into the game prior to game start, we don’t know the full setup. Anything is possible.
For my DnD game, I was going to put in a Town role (Whiteflame was randed to receive this role btw) that would find out a true piece of information about the game and one that could be either true or false from the host, every night. I decided in advance which info he would receive.
But yeah having read through the setup further it appears there are roles that interfere with investigative results, like that Spy thing
Apparently drunkenness is permanent and I imagine chosen by the host on night -1, there’s some shit like “you won’t know what role they thought they were if they were drunk”, which has to be night -1
Poisoning is a night ability, I don’t think it has to be any one of us tho it could be anyone in the game.
If a player is Drunk or Poisoned, any information they receive from abilities is decided by the Storyteller, and non-investigative abilities do not work. The Storyteller may choose to give Drunk or Poisoned players true information. The Storyteller will not tell players when they are Drunk or Poisoned, and will go through the motions as though their abilities were functioning normally. Note that, in this script, Drunkenness lasts for the entire game, whereas Poisoning only lasts for a night and the following day. If a player uses a once-per-game ability while Poisoned, they may not use that ability again."
I think it’s borderline OP to have both Banana and Shining’s roles in the game. One of them is probably drunk I’d say. Or lying
Okay, please stop claiming. I think there’s a perfect way of gaming this setup.
We ALL start chats with whoever we are sure is Town, only two people per chat (three including Thoth, I guess). Then everyone claims their role privately to that person.
We don’t need scum knowing what roles are in the game. If necessary we can pressure people by forcing them to publicly claim
Are you overexplaining this because you’re scum and you’re lying or because you think people won’t believe you
I hardclaim demon
/sign
Automated Vote Count
This vote count was generated by the mafia vote bot.
Shoresy (2/3): Kohai (p#22), Vaarka (p#60)
Kohai (2/3): Shoresy (p#25), JoeBob (p#37)
No Lynch (1/3): Mag1cman (p#44)
Mag1cman (1/3): Ultracrepidarian (p#50)
Not Voting (0): None
With 6 players alive, it takes 3 to lynch. Day phase has ended.
