Magoroth

I think that Mikal was killed because he was probably right scum were off my train, now that I think about it. Nobody here is genuinely super scummy, which to me indicates the scum haven’t really been pressured.

Magoroth

I do believe Wylted is Town because again why the hell all the weird stuff, why claim Miller, why lie about who stole your favour, especially when its so in your face

Magoroth

On another note, not really game related but I disagree with some of those takes. But maybe it’s just a culture clash issue and not important. I apologize for making it personal, it was not my intention, I genuinely was frustrated because it seemed to me at the time you would scumread everything I said and did regardless of how I answered it, which set me off. Of course, if you read these things in the way you do and it sets off your scum metre it seems more like a misunderstanding than you being scum or whatever. So I want to apologise and go forward with a clean slate between us :) No sense in hating each other in our first game

Magoroth

Lunatic, can you answer the following, I still can’t quite get over how scummy it is to say that we can afford a mislynch:


  1. why did you say “even if you’re Town we can lynch you”?
  2. I still feel like the questions you asked me, either you had already made up your mind on my alignment, or you just really wanted me dead. Can you explain what exactly you found scummy about my behaviour and why
Magoroth

I don’t know about this site, but I have seen scum Tracker on other sites before, yes. I guess in this setup its idea would be to detect people with favour, since they’re the only ones who can visit.

Magoroth

Mikal was Empress Dowager, which if I’m not mistaken is the Emperor’s mother. I don’t think he can appoint a new mother for himself :)

Magoroth

I’d like to hear an explanation from the people who refused to lay down their vote yesterday. Not voting is a scum tell.

Magoroth

I forgot about Awesome. Kinda feels like there wouldn’t be much reason for him to switch to VTNL yesterday if he was scum. Could easily get away with voting me. Town lean.



Magoroth

I don’t really remember her meta/playstyle from my one game with her, from early gamr at least, but I feel like she had a lot more game related thoughts and reads at least later on. It feels like she’s just here to post stuff that I usually post when I’m scum. Plus the Tracker claim, which I have a strong suspicion that the information isn’t a lie (maybe she’s not a Tracker though, but the information I am tempted to 100% believe is true to her knowledge regardless of her alignment, her play reminds me of my scum play in a game I literally just got out of where I claimed my actual investigative information for days on end).

Magoroth

I don’t really remember who else is in this game.


Magoroth

Banana - Not sure. Maybe town lean based on vibes.

Wylted - Town read.

Lunatic - Town read. Part of me is paranoid I’m letting slip away after I so heavily scumread him during the night.

Thoth - Town lean.

Shining - No clue

Whiteflame - Unreadable as usual

Wryly - Scummy

Pie - No read on him


Magoroth

I guess wylted is probably Town because that is a rather crazy amount of fake claims, shenanigans etc if he is scum. Don’t see why he would do that, except literally in order to pretend to be Town, and he did this in my first game with him where he was Town.



Magoroth

I don’t know if Pie visited me last night. I threw a fake claim in the hopes he would claim he visited me on the off-chance that he did and would claim (it’s a stretch, I know).

Magoroth

Lunatic, I do believe you are town based on your latest posts, but I do believe there was a reason I was scumreading you and it’s not just because you voted me :)



I guess you could say the same shit of me so it is what it is.


I do think Wryly revealing she’s a Tracker to out some info on who Mikal visited is kinda odd. Feels like it’s more designed to get her townread than to… well, do useful stuff. Tracker in particular would actually be a useful role this game (yes, Watcher even more so but just because I outed myself doesn’t mean everyone should)

Magoroth

not gonna deal with this. you guys can try and Lynch me all you want, I’m Town and I won’t engage with this nonsense AGAIN. if you want to waste a second day by pushing a Lynch on me, be my guest but I won’t be a party to it.

Magoroth

wait so you didn’t receive feedback I stole your favour? just that someone took it?

that seems much more plausible