I’m not sure you realise, but Thoth flipped Town. EVERYONE had all day to suggest alternatives and nobody did, except for Awesome/Kohai who is probably Town...
I’m not sure you realise, but Thoth flipped Town. EVERYONE had all day to suggest alternatives and nobody did, except for Awesome/Kohai who is probably Town...
I’d give you one but mine is probably biased.
The one that removes all the personal elements would be something as follows.
I pushed hard for a mass claim on D1. People scum read this. I was asked to claim at one point, and I lied abut my last ability, I claimed Framer, it was in fact Vengeful.
I was almost lynched on D1, sneaked out of a Lynch by screaming and kicking, and we no-lynched D1. I accused Lunatic and a bunch of others but mostly Lunatic of being scum.
Mikal believed I was Town but wasn’t sure.
D2 was basically.. nothing relevant
led*
VTL Lunatic
He lead two town lynches, town is just implicitly accepting him as Town, I would say he needs pressure but I’m just pretty sure he is scum.
Also, I know I just said Wylted is Town, but him saying “no no protectives on a Miller” is sus. It’s LAMIST and also weird. Town should ALWAYS be okay with doctors/bodyguards/whatever on them, unless they are not Town and just saying it because “look how towny I am, I am Miller, go heal a Cop you idiot!"
What is the PoE ATM? Pie/Thoth/Banana/Awesome or something?
I would add Wryly and Whiteflame to it. Pie I have absolutely no read on at all.
And I would say that the Lynch order should be something like,
Pie > Wryly > Whiteflame > Lunatic > ...
Pie, I’m only putting there because I have literally no read on him.
protective roles should be on people we trust to be town.
why are you telling people not to have protectives on you?
I’ll eat my words if Thoth is scum, but I have my doubts he is.
Wylted - Claimed Miller, seems all over the place with reads in a way that indicates Town. Plus, a bunch of other stuff like baiting reactions by lying about me visiting him, that feels like it should come from Town. Top town read.
Shining - I thought his reaction to me sussing him was over the top, but now that he’s been outed as the Empress, it makes sense. Second highest town read.
Thoth - Light town read. D1 I thought his OMGUS at me was rather Towny, usually scum doesn’t OMGUS that hard. Not very sure of him but Thoth’s activity is mostly NAI from what I’ve seen of him. Also, not a fan of how people seem to be comfortable with this Lynch.
Whiteflame - I feel like Whiteflame’s taking some things for granted that he usually wouldn’t. Not sure how to slot him. D1 I thought he was Town, now I’m not sure. Could be either Town or Scum.
Banana - Not sure. Both towny and scummy points. I’d say a bit townier than she’s scummy. Maybe should be in the Town slot rather than Schrodinger’s Scum.
Awesome - My gut tells me this is Town, but I’m not sure. Potential for Awesome to be Lunatic’s partner since he was like “awesome or Thoth” and then ppl agreed on Thoth. Not necessary, but it is possible.
Wryly - Not sure. I thought she was scummy D1, but somehow her play style seems townier than on D1? I might be biased. Could definitely still be scum.
Only person who goes in here is Pie. I have no read on Pie either way.
Lunatic - Acting like Town leader today, makes people feel too comfortable, and was potentially trying to drive a mislynch on D1, I’m suspicious of this slot.
Anyone I haven’t mentioned goes into True Null Reads.
"Debates: 0
Comments: 169
i might not be around later, so i'll go ahead and add my vote now. seems like thoth is the lynch today
vtl thoth
"
this post is very scummy to the point where I’m not sure it could come fro scum. does scum does just come to put a vote on the top train and disappear?
How does a host make setup with Princess, Watcher/Roleblocker/Vengeful, plus a RoleCop/Mayor who cleared the vengeful, plus a Tracker who seemingly cleared the role cop and himself?? Does that make any sense? Is that not ridiculously town sided?
I don’t really like this EoD. I’m very suspicious of the fact that multiple people have been cleared mechanically and it leaves me very uneasy. I would expect you to be one of the first to mention this, whiteflame. Why haven’t you?
I still do believe Wylted is a person I’m never lynching this game. If anyone still disbelieves the fact that I’m Town, after I die, please put a memo on your computer that says “Wylted is Town and I shouldn’t Lynch him”. Protectives on him.
I honestly still think Lunatic might be scum. He’s acting like Town leader trying to get everyone’s thoughts/claims and asking shit that just looks towny on the surface, but in fact is NAI.
And now we’re walking kinda braindead into a lynch, all because of mechanical clears. In a game where everyone is or can become a power role. And scum has fake claims. And they have only 2, which implies one of the scum doesn’t even need it.
VTL Lunatic
Also, we should have a counterwagon to Thoth. Nobody is defending Thoth and he’s not even here for EoD. I don’t even think Thoth is especially scummy.
I have a strange feeling one of the people who got randomly “towncleared” is probably scum.
Scum has two fake claims, and in game of this size, you’d expect there to be three scum. So why not three fake claims?
My guess is one of the scum has a Towny role/character and doesn’t need a fake claim.
sorry, kinda zoned out of this game for a bit, did other stuff. I see Thoth is at L-2 even though there’s only 3 votes on him, I assume one of them is the Empress. Why is Thoth being voted?
Why do you think I’m being a dumbass for voting you?
My reason for thinking you’re scum(my) is that Mafia do like to reveal their investigative results, for towncred and because, who’s gonna kill a Mafia? It’s risk-free.
VTL Shining
I agree with ILikePie5 that shining claiming here is a little sus, it kinda feels like it wasn’t really necessary? I don’t think anyone was actually doubting my claim
Yeah see. This is what I don’t understand. Why does this role cop check on me change people’s read on me? I don’t get it. I don’t understand why I was scumread before and now I don’t understand why I am townread.
Consider my vote on awesome in spirit. Not voting yet because I do not know how many votes are on awesome and don’t want an early hammer.
Ok so apparently I wasn’t vanillaized. I need to read my role card better next time lol.
My watcher ability was tied strictly speaking to the Empress Dowager (Mikal). Now that he’s dead, it’s been disabled.
Well not almost the same but they both have green/blue and I don’t really look at them
Your avatar and Shining’s look almost the same and I had to do a double when I read your last message cuz I was like “Is Shining talking to himself?"
I get the feeling Banana is town, actually. My guess is that if she was scum, it would be odd for her to state she has two ways of confirming herself. It doesn’t feel like something a scum would say.
I don’t know. If I’m scum his incentive is clear (if he is scum), you’re right he could just allow me to be mislynched if he was scum. Probably I would just lie back and wait if I was scum and wait for someone to mislynch Magoroth.
It was more that I didn’t understand Wylted’s flip flopping on me, but I guess I’m being retarded for questioning it; it is Towny to flip flop and wylted really hasn’t been especially scummy, by any means.
Ok fair enough. I guess you flip flopping around so much makes you townier. Town flip flops, scum appears more collected.
Isn’t it uber suspicious in your eyes your scumread gets randomly confirmed on D2
But why can’t he be lying?
Wylted, could you explain why you unvoted me after Shining claimed rolecop on me? Why does his “confirmation” of my role make me Town in your eyes? FYI I can’t understand why I was being scumread and now I can’t understand why I’m being townread.
Could someone heal me tonight? I’d rather not die. Also the fact that nobody is coming forward with a Poisoner claim makes me think the Poisoner is scum.
Second, we’ve already had so many claims, I think it would be safest if everyone just full claimed at this stage.
I don’t really care about characters. Host confirmed there isn’t much to go off flavour, so maybe only claim your justifications.
note that scum received only two fake claims, and I suspect there are 3 scum. Which means the third scum either has no fake claim and needs to make something up, or they don’t need a fake claim and can just true claim their actual role.