I really am Town btw. I know you don’t trust me but can you at least tell me why? I’ll tell you why I’m not scum.

There was almost 0 interaction between Wylted and Shining. Also, why did Wylted not agree to the Shining policy lynch D1? It’s a decent push as scum.

Wylted and I have interacted sufficiently to the point where you can have doubts at the very least that we’re aligned. Wylted and Shining tho? They basically never spoke. Shining just called Wylted scum yesterday. That’s their interaction

I’m gonna be a bitch and state that Wylted slipped yesterday that scum have a Redirector since he stated that he wasnt gonna believe Lunatic was redirected or something.

Now Shining is saying there’s no redirector snd it just so happens the universe where he’s scum is exactly that universe lol

Yeah, this is why the Strat for today would likely be to get Shining to talk as much as possible. If there’s any questions you or Lunatic have for me I’ll be happy to answer them. I can literally just tell the truth and win the game, Shining has to lie. The only thing he has going for him is the fact Lunatic didn’t see him visiting, and that he was quiet all game.

As an aside Mafia can defend themself against Vigilante by redirecting him. Redirector or Bus Driver or what have you is effectively an anti-claim mechanic

Also that doesn’t sound balanced either. Tracker/Cop/Doctor/Vigilante, with Mafia having no protection against tracker? Tracker could literally find the entire Mafia my friend, there being a Mafia Goon doesn’t make sense

How are you confirmed Town?

Yeah, but Shining can’t say Redirector makes sense or it throws suspicion onto him lol

Ninja and Lawyer vs Cop/Tracker virtually guarantees Scum will never be found. It’s almost as bad a combination as Godfather/Ninja. It don’t make a lick of sense. At least Rediector is skill-based...

Redirector makes WAY more sense

Fuck off, Ninja and Lawyer vs Tracker and Cop is retardded

Why would there be a ninja and a lawyer?

Holy hell nothing in 9 hours?

1. ILikePie5
2. Thoth
3. Alyssa
4. Whiteflame
5. RexFavilla
6. Helz
7. Mag1cman

7/13

Signups (6/13)

1. ILikePie5
2. Thoth
3. Alyssa
4. Whiteflame
5. RexFavilla
6. Helz

it’s not really ridiculously unnecessary, but I see your point

just saying that if you had tracked me you would’ve gotten the same result so we would be in the same situation

I realise this is is some BS to you since as scum I coulda just planted that doubt on purpose (I guess it would not be hard to do), though

what I mean is that Shining was utterly convinced it was me and Wylted last day, didn’t even consider the possibility of Thoth or Lunatic. it’s borderline TMI-ish. not a single doubt? hes also not read or been here most of the game yet somehow seems “informed” of all the things that have gone down. remember D1 Lynch when I asked shining how much of the game hes read?

to clarify, I don’t think either of you is scum, but if you are, well-fucking played. I admit defeat, and I blame shining for not town telling enough, or rather town telling less than the scum lmao

the thing with shining vs me is that its impossible to get an accurate read on shining due to how little he talks. he doesn’t seem uber scummy in his few comments, only thing you can really pin on him is agenda and FMPOV I have TMI since Shining is almost certainly scum and for me that’s easy but it does nothing for you.

so I think if you really wanna make a decision and find shining as scum, get him to talk more. theres plenty to read into when it comes to me

Safest bet when you redirect someone is to redirect them into themself. If they’re secretly a killing role instead of whatever they claimed that way they die

They redirected the Cop into some random Town person (maybe himself) and killed Alyssa

No, I meant on N1. Hence could explain why Lunatic saw Wylted visiting but not Shining.

What?

Yeah this isn’t looking good IMO. I suppose it could be an Even night ninja or whatever. But that’s kinda crazy.

Actually - not sure how likely a redirector is considering we have a Vigilante. That might be.... a little strong.

VTL Shining

There need not be a ninja. If you’re worried about Wylted showing up as visiting, there could be a redirector. There’s 0 reason for you to be redirected with a Cop in the game. So my guess is Shining redirected Vader N1 into himself, and theres no Ninja.

To me the question is if it’s Lunatic or Shining.

I think Lunatic wouldn’t bus his teammate so hard. Thoth, his Vigilante claim I do not see coming from scum.

there’s no point to no lynching, Vader will just die lol