Kohai

>Reported Vote: YN // Mod action: Removed
>Voting Policy: https://www.debatecraft.com/debates/vote-rubric
>Voted for: con
>Reason for Decision: other
>Reason for Mod Action:
This vote was written entirely by AI. Per the rules, AI is not allowed to write your RFD.

---YN's former vote---
Voted for: con
Con won. Clearly.
Here is why:

1. Framing and burden of proof Pro's core mistake never gets fixed. They repeatedly try to force atheism into making a metaphysical claim, and they demand disproof of god. Con correctly holds the line that most athiesm is a withholding of belief, not a counter assertion.


2. Pro treats "no evidence" as if all athiests are claiming omniscience. Con correctly reframes it as no sufficient public, testable, compelling evidence available. Pro insist on literal wording and ignore how reasoning work.


3. Category error from Pro's side. Con explained the distinctions multiple times. Pro explicitly states "I will not be debating words and definitions" which is essentially conceding in a philosophy debate. Definitions matter.


4. Con decisively dismantles this by distinguishing religious faith from provisional conclusion based on evidence. Pro never answers this.
In round 4 and 5, Pro effectively concede by claiming "no rebuttals" while ignoring the substantive refutations already made.
Con won in all criteria. Pro had flawed counters and arguments.

Welcome to the site! This looks like an interesting topic.

You can accept

Please vote. This was a tough debate and I can see this going either way

I’ll try and have my final round tonight. This was a tough debate and looks like it’ll be tough to judge.

Thank you for the debate. This was certainly a tough one. I’ll have my final round up later tonight or tomorrow.

You can post now

Actually post it around this time tomorrow.

I think you’re safe to post them now if you want.

submitted. I'm sorry my opening was a bit sloppy

Sounds good. I’ll post my arguments sometime tomorrow or Friday

I’m going away to the beach this weekend. Any chance you can delay your second round as long as possible once I post mine?

I'm ok for whenever wou want to post it

Same. Good luck to you

Thanks for the vote

<p>>Reported Vote: Kohai // Mod action: Removed</p>
<p>>Voting Policy: https://www.debatecraft.com/debates/vote-rubric</p>
<p>>Voted for: pro</p>
<p>>Reason for Decision: other</p>
<p>>Reason for Mod Action:</p>
<p>Smoke screen test</p>

<p>---Kohai's former vote---</p>
<p>Voted for: pro</p>
<p>Full forfeit </p>

Thanks for the debate

Please vote

Thanks for the debate!

<p>>Reported Vote: Kohai // Mod action: Removed</p>
<p>>Voting Policy: https://www.debatecraft.com/debates/vote-rubric</p>
<p>>Voted for: tie</p>
<p>>Reason for Decision: other</p>
<p>>Reason for Mod Action:</p>
<p>test</p>

<p>---Kohai's former vote---</p>
<p>Voted for: tie</p>
<p>Test</p>

<p>>Reported Vote: Kohai // Mod action: Removed</p>
<p>>Voting Policy: https://www.debatecraft.com/debates/vote-rubric</p>
<p>>Voted for: tie</p>
<p>>Reason for Decision: other</p>
<p>>Reason for Mod Action:</p>
<p>Test</p>

<p>---Kohai's former vote---</p>
<p>Voted for: tie</p>
<p>Test test</p>

<p>>Reported Vote: Kohai // Mod action: Removed</p>
<p>>Voting Policy: https://www.debatecraft.com/debates/vote-rubric</p>
<p>>Voted for: pro</p>
<p>>Reason for Decision: fails-to-analyze</p>
<p>>Reason for Mod Action:</p>
<p>Voter failed to analyze arguments and thus is removed </p>

<p>---Kohai's former vote---</p>
<p>Voted for: pro</p>
<p> This is a test vote for a new moderation system. This will be removed once I test it on the local back end. </p>

<p>>Reported Vote: Kohai // Mod action: Removed</p>
<p>>Voting Policy: info.debateart.com/terms-of-service/voting-policy</p>
<p>>Voted for: tie</p>
<p>>Reason for Decision: other</p>
<p>>Reason for Mod Action:</p>
<p>Test </p>

<p>---Kohai's former vote---</p>
<p>Voted for: tie</p>
<p>Test test</p>

Thanks for the vote

<p>>Reported Vote: Kohai // Mod action: Removed</p>
<p>>Voting Policy: info.debateart.com/terms-of-service/voting-policy</p>
<p>>Voted for: tie</p>
<p>>Reason for Decision: other</p>
<p>>Reason for Mod Action:</p>
<p>Test</p>